Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

I know you can't cast the same spell on a model/unit to buff them twice, but what about pMadrak casting carnage (+2 to melee attack rolls) on top of Kriel warriors Fervor (+2 to attack and damage rolls)?

Pretty sure that's legit as it's too different spells/sources, just the same effect!

Kinda like when pDenny pops off her feat which includes an ARM penalty on top of some poor soul who has Parasite on them! All of a sudden they're sat with -5 ARM!

Yep it works. As long the effects have different names they stack.

WH40K007 wrote:
I know you can't cast the same spell on a model/unit to buff them twice, but what about pMadrak casting carnage (+2 to melee attack rolls) on top of Kriel warriors Fervor (+2 to attack and damage rolls)?

Pfft! Is that all you can do?

Try this:
[Fervor] from the Kriel Warriors for +2 attack +2 damage with [War Cry] from the Fell Caller hero for +2 attack and [Carnage] from pMadrak (the one that comes in the battle box) for +2 attack to attack rolls and [Charge of the Trolls] from the stone Scribe Chronicler for +2 Attack and Damage Rolls

Giving your Kriel Warriors +8 to Melee Attacks rolls, and +4 damage.

Try them apples.

Well, if they're in melee range of a troll warbeast.

And frankly if your troll warbeast needs bailing out from your Kriel Warriors you're probably doing it wrong.

 Emperors_Champion wrote:
Pretty sure that's legit as it's too different spells/sources, just the same effect!

Kinda like when pDenny pops off her feat which includes an ARM penalty on top of some poor soul who has Parasite on them! All of a sudden they're sat with -5 ARM!

Pfft, that is all? My friend got a collossal down to Arm 1. Dice+11

 hotsauceman1 wrote:

 Emperors_Champion wrote:
Pretty sure that's legit as it's too different spells/sources, just the same effect!

Kinda like when pDenny pops off her feat which includes an ARM penalty on top of some poor soul who has Parasite on them! All of a sudden they're sat with -5 ARM!

Pfft, that is all? My friend got a collossal down to Arm 1. Dice+11

How?

 motyak wrote:

 hotsauceman1 wrote:

 Emperors_Champion wrote:
Pretty sure that's legit as it's too different spells/sources, just the same effect!

Kinda like when pDenny pops off her feat which includes an ARM penalty on top of some poor soul who has Parasite on them! All of a sudden they're sat with -5 ARM!

Pfft, that is all? My friend got a collossal down to Arm 1. Dice+11

How?

Hmm... I suppose if you have an Armour Piercing attack (half ARM, rounding up so 19 becomes ARM 10) against a model with Parasite (-3 ARM), affected by Denegrahs feat (-2 ARM), within 2" of a bane thrall (-2 ARM), and hit by a Rust Bomb from Gorman (-2 ARM)... That'd be ARM1 against that attack. But I don't think Cryx has any Armour Piercing attacks, does it?

Though we'll see if Hotsauceman had a different way of doing it

Ahh I hadn't thought of armour piercing. I wonder if thats how his mate did it.

I know Cryx has a bunch more armor reducing things they can get. Although the most I ever figured was Arm8. Can't remember how I got there.

Just remember Ragman and Bane thralls don't stack the -arm, as they've both got the same named ability.

But yeah, to get to ARM1, armour piercing is needed, I'm pretty sure...

Oh yeah, the worm. The damnable Cankerworm

 motyak wrote:
Oh yeah, the worm. The damnable Cankerworm

Ha, yes, Cankerworm has Armour Piercing bites! I honestly just came back to post that myself, after looking on Battlecollage. So yes, it is possible to reduce a Colossal to ARM1, in a normal single caster game (for one attack at least). So there you go

 Maddermax wrote:

 motyak wrote:
Oh yeah, the worm. The damnable Cankerworm

Ha, yes, Cankerworm has Armour Piercing bites! I honestly just came back to post that myself, after looking on Battlecollage. So yes, it is possible to reduce a Colossal to ARM1, in a normal single caster game (for one attack at least). So there you go

In such a case, one hit (with average dice) will do 21 damage.

I can live with that.

But its not that single attack you need to worry about. Its the half dozen mechanithralls charging and combo-punching you to death. Assuming the Banes didn't eat you.

 Grey Templar wrote:
But its not that single attack you need to worry about. Its the half dozen mechanithralls charging and combo-punching you to death. Assuming the Banes didn't eat you.

Shhh! You'll ruin the surprise!

 Grey Templar wrote:
Assuming the Banes didn't eat you.

Which they did. Every time.

 Maddermax wrote:

 motyak wrote:
Oh yeah, the worm. The damnable Cankerworm

Ha, yes, Cankerworm has Armour Piercing bites! I honestly just came back to post that myself, after looking on Battlecollage. So yes, it is possible to reduce a Colossal to ARM1, in a normal single caster game (for one attack at least). So there you go

Dont forget ripjaws!