I was unaware of her warlord trait. That is new info, so yeah, that’d make my math wrong.
Yeah she also fights twice for free 1 time.
Outshoots Gman - has a cyclone missle launcher basically.
She out damages Gman in melee vs hordes hands down - vs hard targets they are about equal with gman having a slight edge. The chances they do equal damage are pretty high.
Outsurvives him. 4++ half damage is better than a 3++ with +1 wound.
Buffs are equal IMO
- though not identical. You could give the edge to gman here I suppose - personally I think it is better to be able to give a unit reroll all wounds rather than multiple units reroll all hits. Granted her other ability is at least giving those units reroll 1's. The 12" aura of reroll 1's and +1 to charges is really nice...but still - it's not a huge synergy for what you want from him anyways.
Only really unique feature that Gman has is coming back to life on a 4+ with D6
wounds. No doubt a powerful ability - I'd honestly trade it for a 4++ with half damage anyways.
I'd say - in a fair world - these units are within 20 points of each other. Given the fact that there is no chance the similarities between the units could not have been missed at the rules conception phase. The comparisons were obviously made and they still made her cost nearly 100 points less.
Why do we even play this game?