Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

via the official FB page :

https://www.facebook.com/Warhammer-40000-1575682476085719/?fref=nf

FAQs eh?
All right, let’s knuckle down and do this.
What one (just one, there’s rather a lot of you guys…) rules question do you want answered or clarified? Jot it down in the comments and we’ll take them to the Game Designers on your behalf. We’ll even return with answers, we promise. It might take a week or two but a collated list of freshly approved FAQs will be yours post haste

These oppurtunities are somewhat scarce, lets hope good things come from it.


....

Anyone wondering, some of the questions that have been posted:

Does PE grant re-rolls on scatters?
Do Witchfire without profiles (specifically Psychic Scram) roll To Hit?
Do Gargantuan Creatures fire 2 weapons or as many as they have?
Replace 1 weapon with 1 Relic - Limit or Ratio?
Do formation bonuses that target the unit confer to attached ICs?
Does Chaos Psychic Focus and Psychic Focus stack?
Ravenwing with Flyer - can Flyer start in Reserve and rest deploy normally?

There have been a number of repeat questions, so you might want to look through to see if your question was asked.

If we can vote, go for eithe the IC question or the Psychic Scream thing, maybe GCs if we really feel it necessary. Do general brb questions, not codex specific stuff!!!

That didn't last long, turds are already gaking up the thread.

 Ravenous D wrote:
That didn't last long, turds are already gaking up the thread.

What turds?

 Lord Scythican wrote:

 Ravenous D wrote:
That didn't last long, turds are already gaking up the thread.

What turds?

People asking for dreadnaughts to get additional attacks and other things that aren't rules questions.

I just posted the 'How many spyders in a Canoptek Harvest' question.

I'm impressed, over half the posts so far are questions not nonsense

(although a fair few of them are from people who can't count)

I really hope GW does manage get some FAQs up from them (and as FAQs rather than answers on facebook which the grumpy brigade will probably not consider official)

We need (I want) someone to ask about dual weapon profiles (melee and ranged), and how the Obelisk interacts with FMC's.

OH OHOH and the Tesla Sphere's firing arc!

 Ghaz wrote:
I just posted the 'How many spyders in a Canoptek Harvest' question.

I saw that one and was like "OH GOD YES!"

Slayer-Fan123 wrote:
We need (I want) someone to ask about dual weapon profiles (melee and ranged), and how the Obelisk interacts with FMC's.

OH OHOH and the Tesla Sphere's firing arc!

There're a couple of questions regarding weapon profiles with one of them being Necron specific so maybe you'll get your wish and have an answer.


Also, should this or the other thread be closed since they're the same thing?

 Happyjew wrote:
Anyone wondering, some of the questions that have been posted:

Does PE grant re-rolls on scatters?
Do Witchfire without profiles (specifically Psychic Scram) roll To Hit?
Do Gargantuan Creatures fire 2 weapons or as many as they have?
Replace 1 weapon with 1 Relic - Limit or Ratio?
Do formation bonuses that target the unit confer to attached ICs?
Does Chaos Psychic Focus and Psychic Focus stack?
Ravenwing with Flyer - can Flyer start in Reserve and rest deploy normally?

There have been a number of repeat questions, so you might want to look through to see if your question was asked.

These are all pretty good questions, honestly. I know where I stand on all these but getting official answers is preferred.

If I have to choose JUST ONE, I'd go with the formation bonuses to attached IC's thing, just because I see that one getting majorly abused if people believe that the IC does in fact gain the squad bonus.

Now there is people suggesting their home rule changes. Awesome.

 SRSFACE wrote:

 Happyjew wrote:
Anyone wondering, some of the questions that have been posted:

Does PE grant re-rolls on scatters?
Do Witchfire without profiles (specifically Psychic Scram) roll To Hit?
Do Gargantuan Creatures fire 2 weapons or as many as they have?
Replace 1 weapon with 1 Relic - Limit or Ratio?
Do formation bonuses that target the unit confer to attached ICs?
Does Chaos Psychic Focus and Psychic Focus stack?
Ravenwing with Flyer - can Flyer start in Reserve and rest deploy normally?

There have been a number of repeat questions, so you might want to look through to see if your question was asked.

These are all pretty good questions, honestly. I know where I stand on all these but getting official answers is preferred.

If I have to choose JUST ONE, I'd go with the formation bonuses to attached IC's thing, just because I see that one getting majorly abused if people believe that the IC does in fact gain the squad bonus.

While I'm on the other side of the argument I just have to agree - it affects so much stuff by now. I'll be happy whichever way they rule it.

Ghaz, your question was already asked. As was weapons with ranged and melee profiles, FMCs vs Obelisks, and GCs and difficult terrain.

 Happyjew wrote:
Ghaz, your question was already asked.

Ghaz, if I may make a request - since your question was already asked, would you mind changing it to something about non-slot units and formations, such as dedicated transports, or Primaris Psykers?

Dang, someone already asked the RW question. I had went up the thread quite a bit and could not find it. Maybe I should ask if Pedro Kantor's Dorn's Arrow is a Storm Bolter for the purposes of Bolter Drill instead.

There's just so much potential for this, and I KNOW there's going to be tons of fething junk being posted by people that, ironically or coincidentally, don't understand rules.

Th on wolves has been asked a few dozen times as well.

I fear the internet cannot handle this.

How ITC responds will be interesting. They've already ignored some official GW FAQs (see VSG rulings...). I doubt they will actually up date their document though.

A couple people already asked GW to address everything in the ITC FAQ.

mhelm01 wrote:
I fear the internet cannot handle this.

Nothing to do with the internet, people will always use opportunities like that to vent their anger / ask questions that matter to them even though they perfectly know that they won't get a response or that they're simply adressing the completely wrong person.
GW will sort it out - they'll just throw away anything that's unrelated / not fitting and hopefully take ALL the actual rules question and answer them. Throwing out another "where are my plastic sisters?" isn't really that much work compared to actually answering the others and removing duplicate questions (there're a ton of those for the most discussed questions).

 Happyjew wrote:
A couple people already asked GW to address everything in the ITC FAQ.

Which is not a rules question.


Automatically Appended Next Post:

 goblinzz wrote:
How ITC responds will be interesting. They've already ignored some official GW FAQs (see VSG rulings...). I doubt they will actually up date their document though.

I've never seen GW faqs mention vsg? Which are you talking about?

Wow I am starting to like this whole facebook experiment.

 oldzoggy wrote:
Wow I am starting to like this whole facebook experiment.

Too bad it is going to be ruined by morons just like everything else.

Is there a way to search in this facebook post to see if your question has been asked already ( perhaps a 3th party script) ?
It might be a good idea to upvote good questions, and be able to check before posting new ones.

 oldzoggy wrote:
Is there a way to search in this facebook post to see if your question has been asked already ?

Control-F , but it's tedious. I've scrolled through quite a bit now, if you have a specific question I might be able to remember if I've seen it by now

 casvalremdeikun wrote:

 oldzoggy wrote:
Wow I am starting to like this whole facebook experiment.

Too bad it is going to be ruined by morons just like everything else.

The internet is why we can't have nice things.