I noticed something in one of my galleries. I somehow managed to upload three very similar pictures of the same mini...
The first pic is much better lit, and much smaller. Paintjob 7, coolness 7.5
The second pic is very large, and poorly lit. Paintjob 6.44, coolness 6.33
The third pic is very large, and equally poorly lit. Paintjob 3.4, coolness 4.2
The second and third look quite similar to me, but that is a BIG difference to be due to random chance.
I always knew lighting, proper sizing and decent cropping makes a difference to how people perceive your miniatures, but not how much.
My objective here is not to get good scores on the gallery, but to show people nice things that will make them happier. Clearly, it is not enough to paint a nice mini, you need to show it to them in a nice way, and it is surprising to me
how important the presentation is.
I put a lot more though into lighting than I used to anyway, but often work when it is dark. I think I'll always wait until I can get good lighting in future... I always crop and resize these days.