Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you:
No adverts like this in the forums anymore.
Times and dates in your local timezone.
Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance.
Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely.
Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net.
If you are already a member then feel free to login now.
2016/02/23 10:24:33
Subject: Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Its from a thread over on a military current events forum. Someone yelled "all Pro-Ukrainians are Nazis", queue arms race of spamming pictures of both side's right sector (and far left in the some cases ...and the even weirder Nazi Communist groups in others). Those groups without the nerve to show off swastikas really like the black sun motif...
Joke is that a load of Russian Neo-Nazis joined the Ukrainian side as they're dissatisfied with the state Russia's in and want to create a white nation there. ...Which is to say how extreme they must be then considering Russia's already pretty fare to their cause as it is (lists all the Neo-Nazi politicians/ fascist policies).
2016/02/23 15:55:52
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Wyrmalla wrote: Its from a thread over on a military current events forum. Someone yelled "all Pro-Ukrainians are Nazis", queue arms race of spamming pictures of both side's right sector (and far left in the some cases ...and the even weirder Nazi Communist groups in others). Those groups without the nerve to show off swastikas really like the black sun motif...
Yeah, it looks good and is all mysterious and occult (most neo-nazis are pretty fond of paganism and occult stuff, I have found) The Kolovrat and Wolfsangel are also pretty popular symbols, as are the black-white-red flag of the German Empire and the black-yellow-white flag of the Russian Empire. So Swastikas or no, recognising neo-nazis is usually pretty easy
Wyrmalla wrote: Joke is that a load of Russian Neo-Nazis joined the Ukrainian side as they're dissatisfied with the state Russia's in and want to create a white nation there. ...Which is to say how extreme they must be then considering Russia's already pretty fare to their cause as it is (lists all the Neo-Nazi politicians/ fascist policies).
Neo-nazis don't really view it that way. Russia is very much a multi-ethnic state in which many minorities have special rights and privileges in their respective territories, and equal rights outside of them. Neo-nazis often think that the Russian government panders too much to its minorities and puts them above the Slavic population. They are afraid that the minorities, with their higher birthrates, will eventually outnumber the Slavic people and take over (parts of) Russia. They also want to stop Slavic Russians from interacting and mixing with the non-Slavic populations. Basically, they want the Russian government to segregate society along ethnic lines, and the Russian government of course doesn't really pay any attention to their crazy ideas, which frustrates them. Along with that, the Ukrainian government is much more tolerant of neo-nazi and extremist groups than the Russian government. The Ukrainian government needs these groups to fight for them, while the Russian government sees them as a threat to its authority and usually cracks down hard on any neo-nazi organisation that gets too large, ambitious or extreme. Most groups therefore can't actually participate in the political process of Russia, whereas they can in Ukraine. And seeing as that Russians and Ukrainians are technically both Russians (English language unfortenately does not have seperate words for Russians as citizens of the Russian Federation and Russians as a people (maybe that Ukrainian idea of re-introducing "Muscovites" is not so bad after all)), it is not so weird that these groups take the Ukrainian side. It is only really the anti-Western, pro-(Muscovite)Russian state groups that are anti-Ukrainian.
This message was edited 2 times. Last update was at 2016/02/23 15:57:37
Error 404: Interesting signature not found
2016/02/23 23:16:11
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Wyrmalla wrote: The Russian paper tiger: A foreign volunteer in the Ukrainian Army’s view of Russian troops
A person who wrote this article is most likely an American, judging purely from the terms he uses and the information he presents.
Ukrainian neo-Nazis commemorate the death of members of their volunteer battalions. Such a happy bunch, ain't they?
@1:39 - "Moskali [derogative term for Russians] na nozhi, na nozhi! [on knives, on knives]"
"There is no Nazism in Ukraine." (Any Western politician)
Yet another reason why I think Putin is a traitor to Russian people. Instead of a finial blockade of Junta he allowed the Russian government and private banks to operate in ukraine and thus finance Junta. I still hope he and his family will end up hanged on Kremlin walls. It's too bad it didn't happened to Yeltsin's daughter and now she and her family are Austrian citizens.
Automatically Appended Next Post:
Wyrmalla wrote: Its from a thread over on a military current events forum. Someone yelled "all Pro-Ukrainians are Nazis", queue arms race of spamming pictures of both side's right sector (and far left in the some cases ...and the even weirder Nazi Communist groups in others). Those groups without the nerve to show off swastikas really like the black sun motif...
Joke is that a load of Russian Neo-Nazis joined the Ukrainian side as they're dissatisfied with the state Russia's in and want to create a white nation there. ...Which is to say how extreme they must be then considering Russia's already pretty fare to their cause as it is (lists all the Neo-Nazi politicians/ fascist policies).
The joke is that some of those "Russian Neo-Nazis" identify themselves as "ethnic ukrainians, living in Russia". Therefore, when you see a picture of people with Nazi salute, which apparently was made in Russia, you never know who they really are.
This message was edited 5 times. Last update was at 2016/02/26 12:10:43
Yet another reason why I think Putin is a traitor to Russian people. Instead of a finial blockade of Junta he allowed the Russian government and private banks to operate in ukraine and thus finance Junta. I still hope he and his family will end up hanged on Kremlin walls. It's too bad it didn't happened to Yeltsin's daughter and now she and her family are Austrian citizens.
Pot. Kettle. Black.
Is calling for the lynching of public figures and their fething families on the Dakka Bingo?
This message was edited 2 times. Last update was at 2016/02/24 01:21:54
2016/02/24 01:48:37
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
The joke is that some of those "Russian Neo-Nazis" identify themselves as "ethnic ukrainians, living in Russia". Therefore, when you see a picture of people with Nazi salute, which apparently was made in Russia, you never know who they really are.
"There's no Russian Nazis in Russia! They're Ukrainians!"
2016/02/24 11:58:26
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Is calling for the lynching of public figures and their fething families on the Dakka Bingo?
I never seen any regrets by anyone after Ceaușescu and his wife were shot without a proper trial. But do continue, you must onto something here.
That was nearly 30 years ago, before I was even born. Exactly what do you expect me to say about it, and what the feth does it have to do with Ukraine?
This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2016/02/24 12:00:03
2016/02/24 22:23:22
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
"There's no Russian Nazis in Russia! They're Ukrainians!"
Way to go to make an assumption out of something I didn't say. I never said that there are no ethnic Russians in Russian who are not fond of Nazi ideology. 20 years of spiting at your own history and rampant anti-Russian propaganda by the West via payed by the CIA so-called "liberals" do produced at least some results.
This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2016/02/24 22:28:05
Meanwhile Ukraine's Eurovision entry. The subject's the Soviet deportation of Crimean Tartars in 1944. ...A step up from Poland's "Slavic girls are hot" song from last year IIRC.
2016/02/24 22:39:31
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
First, if you don't know something about a historical event because you are too young, you shouldn't try to voice you opinion, especially when it comes to things that may offend somebody? I personally find your ignorant and bigoted opinions slightly offensive. Second, there is thing called "logic" if you are not capable to see a parallel between the historical events, how you suppose to have a conversation about the historical events? You've questioned my personal view about Putin and I told you that this kind of thinking has it's examples in another cultures. Putin has a lot to do with that fething "ukraine" that still unfortunately exists. Is it clear now or should I repeat myself for better understanding?
Jeez, Yaraton. Try looking in a mirror. You're calling for public figures to be lynched without trial. You're basically advocating murder. And yet I'm the bigoted, offensive one?
(Spoiler-ed a wall of text).
Spoiler:
I personally find your ignorant and bigoted opinions slightly offensive.
Point out where in this thread i have said something "bigoted and offensive". Thats a very loaded accusation, so back it up with some evidence.
I find YOU to be violent and bloodthirsty, judging by your calls for public figures and their families to be lynched.
First, if you don't know something about a historical event because you are too young, you shouldn't try to voice you opinion, especially when it comes to things that may offend somebody?
As Appeal to Authority fallacies go, thats a new one. Only people old enough to have been around at the time of the event have the right to voice an opinion on it? What is that, Appeal to Seniority? My point regarding Ceaușescu's murder taking place 30 years ago before my birth is NOT that I know nothing about his execution. In fact I already knew who he was, I sure as feth don't need you to tell me. My point is that his execution took place so long ago that its completely irrelevant to the current discussion about Ukraine.
Second, there is thing called "logic" if you are not capable to see a parallel between the historical events, how you suppose to have a conversation about the historical events?
I never denied theres a parallel. I'm saying Ceaușescu has little relevance to this discussion on Ukraine, besides your desire for Putin to be murdered in the same manner as Ceaușescu. As AlmightWalrus said, you're engaging in whataboutism.
You've questioned my personal view about Putin and I told you that this kind of thinking has it's examples in another cultures.
No I didn't, I said nothing about him or your opinion on him. I did not criticize your opinion of Putin, I sure as hell am not defending him. I'm criticizing your violent desire for him and his family to be murdered. Its YOUR thinking I'm criticizing, not other cultures'.
Is it clear now or should I repeat myself for better understanding?
No. I think you should step away from the computer, go take a long cold shower and calm down.
Wyrmalla wrote: "There's no Russian Nazis in Russia! They're Ukrainians!"
Way to go to make an assumption out of something I didn't say. I never said that there are no ethnic Russians in Russian who are not fond of Nazi ideology. 20 years of spiting at your own history and rampant anti-Russian propaganda by the West via payed by the CIA so-called "liberals" do produced at least some results.
I'm pretty certain Wyrmalla is responding to the quote from the Russian nationalists that you posted. Hes NOT implying that you yourself said it.
This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2016/02/25 00:44:44
2016/02/25 01:44:57
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Shadow Captain Edithae wrote: Jeez, Yaraton. Try looking in a mirror. You're calling for public figures to be lynched without trial. You're basically advocating murder. And yet I'm the bigoted, offensive one?
You post about Russia and Russians, I posted my personal opinion about the top of Russian "elite". How the hell am I exactly "bigoted"?
Spoiler:
Point out where in this thread i have said something "bigoted and offensive". Thats a very loaded accusation, so back it up with some evidence.
Well, since you've asked so nicely, I sure will. I will go through all 171 pages of this topic and pick all your posts which I find offensive.
I find YOU to be violent and bloodthirsty, judging by your calls for public figures and their families to be lynched.
Oh well, live with it. I have no sympathy what so ever for the enemies of Russian people. Russia was too merciful to it's enemies and this why we have today what we have. As long as I don't break forum rules I can post anything I want.
As Appeal to Authority fallacies go, thats a new one. Only people old enough to have been around at the time of the event have the right to voice an opinion on it? What is that, Appeal to Seniority?
I am giving you an example, you reply is "That was nearly 30 years ago, before I was even born." So suddenly the whole world should stop because of something you have no clue about? It doesn't work like this.
My point regarding Ceaușescu's murder taking place 30 years ago before my birth is NOT that I know nothing about his execution.
Yet you still felt that it's important for everyone to know that if something has happened before you were born (B.C.? LOL) it's not admissible. Good luck with that.
In fact I already knew who he was, I sure as feth don't need you to tell me.
I will tell you anything I want as long as you feel like telling me anything you want. Deal with it.
My point is that his execution took place so long ago that its completely irrelevant to the current discussion about Ukraine.
It's relevant because I feel that a key figure of this conflict - Putin, should be treated the same way.
I never denied theres a parallel. I'm saying Ceaușescu has little relevance to this discussion on Ukraine, besides your desire for Putin to be murdered in the same manner as Ceaușescu. As AlmightWalrus said, you're engaging in whataboutism.
I've seen accusations, I am yet to see any prove of it. My logical parallel between Ceaușescu and Putin is quite obvious.
No I didn't, I said nothing about him or your opinion on him. I did not criticize your opinion of Putin, I sure as hell am not defending him. I'm criticizing your violent desire for him and his family to be murdered. Its YOUR thinking I'm criticizing, not other cultures'.
Oh well, I hate Putin, oh well I want to see him dead. If it's my "violent desire" you don't like then say so. As of now I see only trolling from you.
No. I think you should step away from the computer, go take a long cold shower and calm down.
What are you now, a personal coach? I've got my own routing set up and I don't need any advices about the task management.
I'm pretty certain Wyrmalla is responding to the quote from the Russian nationalists that you posted. Hes NOT implying that you yourself said it.
Why the hell he is quoting me then? Does he need a lecture on how to use forum tags properly?
I think the two of you should just drop it. Let each other have his own opinion. Further discussion is not productive and will only lead to annoyance. Annoyance leads to anger. Anger leads to rage. Rage leads to worshipping Khorne. Worshipping Khorne leads to summoning deamons. Summoning Deamons leads to the entire world being massacred, and I'd rather not be another skull on Khorne's throne, so please stop.
Error 404: Interesting signature not found
2016/02/25 02:35:45
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Shadow Captain Edithae wrote: Jeez, Yaraton. Try looking in a mirror. You're calling for public figures to be lynched without trial. You're basically advocating murder. And yet I'm the bigoted, offensive one?
You post about Russia and Russians, I posted my personal opinion about the top of Russian "elite". How the hell am I exactly "bigoted"?
I...think you're confusing me with someone else. I've largely been on Russia's side in this debate. Ask Iron Captain, Baron or AlmightyWalrus. If I'm being "bigoted" ( ) against anyone, its against Ukrainians and gak stirring European bureaucrats, not Russians.
Well, since you've asked so nicely, I sure will. I will go through all 171 pages of this topic and pick all your posts which I find offensive.
You do realise that you can just filter all my posts through this entire thread, don't you? You have no excuse. You accused me of bigotry, yet you cannot cite one example. You saw that I was disagreeing with your opinion on Putin, and jumped to conclusions without bothering to actually research my positions and opinions through this thread. (whatever he is, I don't think he should be murdered. If he's a criminal, he should be prosecuted and jailed according to the Rule of Law).
Franky, you're using ad hominem and flinging accusations of bigotry at anyone who disagrees with you. And besides, "offense" is subjective. Offense is always taken, never given. Personally I think calling for the extra-judicial murder of public figures is extremely offensive, and quite possibly illegal.
You're still ignoring Alpharius and being rude and abusive, so I'm done. If anyone is trolling here, its you. Welcome to my block list.
This message was edited 8 times. Last update was at 2016/02/25 03:09:07
2016/02/25 02:37:30
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Wyrmalla wrote: Meanwhile Ukraine's Eurovision entry. The subject's the Soviet deportation of Crimean Tartars in 1944. ...A step up from Poland's "Slavic girls are hot" song from last year IIRC.
Poland's song was great. Everyone knows Slavic girls are the hottest girls.
Ukraine's song is garbage. Aside from it being just a bad song and a bad performance, the text is also clearly political (which is not okay at Eurovision ) and hypocritical. No one really cares about Crimean Tatars. Everyone, including Ukraine, hates them (And lets not forget that Ukrainians played their fair share in the deportations). They are just being used as political tools now.
To counteract this, I now vote for Russia sending in this song:
Error 404: Interesting signature not found
2016/02/25 02:50:37
Subject: Re:Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Yaraton wrote: First, if you don't know something about a historical event because you are too young, you shouldn't try to voice you opinion, especially when it comes to things that may offend somebody?
That's not how history works. In fact, first hand witnesses taken alone with no supporting evidence/testimony are in fact some of the worst evidence you can have. EDIT: Actually a really good exercise on this that can be extrapolated from the confusing interviews of Susan Hamlin/Hamilton (Interviewers couldn't agree on her name )
parallel between the historical events, how you suppose to have a conversation about the historical events?
The first thing any historian will tell you is that parallelism is a dubious method of analysis that generally relies on boatloads of logical fallacies to get anywhere
Putin has a lot to do with that fething "ukraine" that still unfortunately exists.
That seems like a kind of offensive statement and maybe a little bit bigoted.
This message was edited 2 times. Last update was at 2016/02/25 02:54:04
A bunch of young neo-Nazis showed up at a City hall of Belozersk city (ukraine) and tried to impeach the mayor by yelling for him to get out of the building. When the mayor and some of his City hall workers did, one of chief yellers got punched by the mayor (the fat arse at 1:02) and after that "AZOV Civil Corp" (AZOV - is the most famous of neo-Nazi volunteer battalions) and their parents started telling on cameras that they came for "a peaceful demonstration".
Better quality video:
This message was edited 2 times. Last update was at 2016/02/26 12:08:33
Yes, because Russians would never vote against officials they're cross with. It's clearly the west plotting against Russia, from inside the Russian people's own heads!
Fate is in heaven, armor is on the chest, accomplishment is in the feet. - Nagao Kagetora
2016/02/26 22:34:27
Subject: Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Because there's seriously a chance that Putin won't be in for this xth term as Prime Minister/ President (same thing to him, whoever takes the other role's a puppet)? He'll be in those positions for the rest of his life, or till its decided that he'll move off to his mansion and own half the Russian economy.
Wonder how many of the opposition he'll have thrown in prison/ killed this time around?
2016/02/27 00:55:01
Subject: Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!
Yes, because Russians would never vote against officials they're cross with. It's clearly the west plotting against Russia, from inside the Russian people's own heads!
No, it is the West plotting against Russia by supporting shady liberast groups and interfering in Russia's political processes, nevermind that is exactly what Russia does in the West (Go Trump! Yay Brexit!) But regardless, foreigners should be kept away as completely as possible. This is Russian politics, for Russians. Not for foreigners. Foreigners smell funny (and want to destroy Russia).
Ustrello wrote: Russia is the last country to produce propaganda, they would never stoop to the level of the 5th column
Sarcasm?
Automatically Appended Next Post:
Wyrmalla wrote: Because there's seriously a chance that Putin won't be in for this xth term as Prime Minister/ President (same thing to him, whoever takes the other role's a puppet)? He'll be in those positions for the rest of his life, or till its decided that he'll move off to his mansion and own half the Russian economy.
Wonder how many of the opposition he'll have thrown in prison/ killed this time around?
I don't think any will be killed, that has never happened before. There are probably going to be some in prison though, most likely because of holding illegal protests. Not that it matters, those are the kind of politicians Russians would never vote for anyways. The only politicians Russians are going to vote for are: 1. Putin 2. Putin 3. Whomever Putin says to vote for. 4. Commies 5. Vladimir "take Alaska back" Zhirinovsky
Let us just hope Putin wins again. Not only is he one of the best leaders in Russian history, he is also one of the least crazy popular politicians. If Putin doesn't run, let us hope Shoigu will. Shoigu is a nice guy (would also be special seeing as that he'd be the first Asian leader of Russia ever).
This message was edited 2 times. Last update was at 2016/02/27 01:04:20
Error 404: Interesting signature not found
2016/02/27 02:50:08
Subject: Ukraine: Witness the rise of a new Russian Empire, live!