http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/list/14.page JForum - http://www.jforum.net
Here's a quick list I contemplated, note the sang guard and hon guard are only there to deal with enemy elite combat units:

HQ
Libby
Jp

Hon guard
Jps, 2pf

Elites
3 sang priests
Jps, mbs

Sang guard
3 axe, 2 sword

Sang guard
3 axe, 2 sword

Troops
10 man assault squad
2 melta guns

10 man assault squad
2 melta guns

10 man assault squad
2 flamers

10 man assault squad
2 flamers

10 man assault squad
2 flamers

OR

HQ
Libby
Jp

Elites
3 sang priests
Jps, mbs

Troops
6 x (i got bored) 10 man assault squad
2 flamers, mbs

Allies (Iron hands)
Chap master (attached to an assault squad)
Bike, aa, se, th

5 scouts
Bolters

Thunderfire cannon
(Thunder hammer on chap master, 9mbs and countless st5 attacks against rear armour should be nice AA if I get there).


In both lists the 3 priests (+ noviate in first list) should cover all BA models in the army. The second list denies the enemy heavy weapons any shots at models above 18pts, not quite horde advantage but still an advantage right? Neither list has any anti-air, but the idea is to be in the enemies face before flyers can be too decisive. Obviously a list with multiple units of scoring troops in flyers will just out dance these lists.]]> http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/562823/6243775.page http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/562823/6243775.page GMT IH CM with Shrike. Saves points, actually is stronger defensively overall (unit stealth + infiltrate will make a big difference to the enemy's shooting) and depending on what you're facing in combat is actually stronger offensively than the CM anyway, particularly against the kinds of things ASM should be facing. You can infiltrate Shrike, Librarian, Blood Priest and 10 scoring ASM right into the heart of the enemy. Worst case scenario, you get first turn and finish your move 1" away (if you want) from an enemy of your choice and get to flame/melta it, pistol it + librarian zap it. Best case scenario, you start in cover 12" away, cop a round of shooting in cover with stealth and FNP, then charge, shoot and bring the pain to any unit you want. I think Shrike's benefits would be greater than the IH CM. You could always put the libby in another squad if you don't want to put all your eggs in one basket, but especially if you have some good defensive powers or short range powers like those from telepathy/divination, he could be a game changer when infiltrated too.

Anyway, love the idea. I wouldn't say it'll be heaps competitive, but you said you're not worried about that anyway. I definitely think you'll be in trouble if they bring in any kind of air (like... you pretty much have nothing unless they're hovering) and I don't think you'll get to apply the hurt until turn 2-3, which gives them time to get their air in. I'd say you could still do with a little more AT too, but as long as you have meltas in your ASM squads to combine with the MB, you'll be okay. Last thing is the scouts, why bolters? What are they gonna do? I'd say just give 'em snipers, sit 'em in a building and hope they can pin something at some point.

Good luck man! If you play a game, let us know how it goes ]]> http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/562823/6245038.page http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/562823/6245038.page GMT
Generally it looks pretty decent, although my major concern is your complete lack of dealing with enemy armour. 4 melta guns isn't going to cut it - I'd definitely try and equip another assault squad with 2x melta and try to get meltabombs on each of the sergeants. Another issue will be flyers - I would just ignore the flyers and try to win through objectives with your list.

It will be quite fun to see almost 70 JP marines wreaking havoc.]]> http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/562823/6247265.page http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/562823/6247265.page GMT MC counter. Swings and roundabouts.
@ gossipmeng, you're right, it needs more AT, as I cant just rely on fc assault for that. I could drop 5 assault marines and a flamer for 95pts and upgrade 4 flamers to melta for 20pts, leaving me 75pts to play with (powerweapons or change the 5 man assault to a 5 man dc?)
Both of you are right - my best bet is just to ignore flyers completely.]]> http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/562823/6248743.page http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/562823/6248743.page GMT