http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/list/69.page JForum - http://www.jforum.net MEQ with PK/KS.


Power Klaw
hits: 2.6668 attacks out of 4
wounds:2.2224 times
armor saves:
2+ goes to 5+---- 1.48 wounds go through
3+ goes to a 6+------1.85 wounds go through
4-6+ has a null AS------2.2224 wounds go through

KillSaw
hits and wounds the same as powerklaw(2.2224)
armor saves:
2+ goes to 6+------1.85
3-6+ has a null AS-----2.2224


So it ends up with a .374 wound/ .748 damage difference(they both averagely do 2 damage) with the killsaw ahead in 2+ and 3+ armor saves. This math scales all the way up to T7 because of the WB doubling out most nerds in the game, meaning that most things in the game excluding tuff' vehicles and monstrous foes will end up hurting after a WB charge.

Here is some math at T7 for the more bulky enemies like failbaddon, oh wait he is only T5, how about the swarmlord, only T6

PowerKlaw
hit is still the same at 2.668
wounds: 1.778
armor saves:
2+ goes to a 5+----- 1.1856
3+ goes to a 6+----1.48
4-6+ goes to oblivion----1.778

KillSaw
hit/wound the same as the power klaw
armor saves:
2+ goes to 6+-----1.48
4-6+ goes to oblivion-----1.778

So the difference here between the two is .296 wounds or .592 damage which is less than T4, but there is still a difference. Now is this difference worth three points? That's for you to decide adventurers!

Bonus round~~~~~~ I finished this sooner than I thought so here are some BC and regular choppa maths at T4, the further you go up the worse they get in comparison to PW/KS lul(WB still doubles out because of the weak fleshy T4). Also, ALWAYS take your friendly attack squig because not only are they free but also because they like krumpin' just as much as you do.

BC
Hit: 3.3312 of 4 attacks
Wound: 2.777
2+ goes to 3+---.926
3+ goes to 4+---1.389
4+ goes to 5+---1.85
5+ goes to 6+---2.314
6+= rip boyz and gaunts------2.777

And in case you want your 55 point model to act as a bigger boy here are some maths

Choppa
Hits:4.1665 of 5
Wounds:3.47 wounds
2+---.578
3+---1.157
4+---1.735
5+---2.313
6+---2.89

Personally I will probably run the killsaw as the WB is already dirt cheap and for three points more than the klaw you get decently better at killing TEQs and MEQs. Also, I haven't done the math, but from just some "brain thinking" the BC seems better for nobz than PK. I could also put some nob math later if anybody wants it, maybe comparing powerstabbas, BC, and PK. Or any other maths people don't have time for.







Automatically Appended Next Post:
Nobz


Powerstabbas
Hits: 2 of 3
Wounds:1.333334
2+ goes to 4+---.666667
3+ goes to 5+---.88889
4+ goes to 6+---1.111
5/6+= nothing----1.334


BC
Hits: 2 of 3
Wounds: 1.333334
2+ goes to 3+--.444
3+ goes to 4+--.666667
4+ goes to 5+--.889
5+ goes to 6+--1.111
6=nothing ------1.3334

All of this is at T4

The BC also does 2 damage comparatively to the power stabbas 1

From T5-T7 the BCs will perform the same, however, the stabbas decrease significantly after 5. So take stabbas if you are facing a considerable amount of 1W T3-5 models and take BCs if you face T5 and above or 2W models.

]]> http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/728029/9416041.page http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/preList/728029/9416041.page GMT