Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Anyone else playing it?
Got GamePass to try it out and just downed the first boss. I've seen a lot of people online compare it to Bloodborne, but the combat is pure melee and focused on block/parry (they call it guard/perfect guard in game). The enemy attacks are too slow to compare it to Sekiro (at least so far). It's closer to DS3/ER speed.

I really like the visual design. The first boss also had a great phase change that caught me off-guard.

I have been hearing a lot about this but have not played it yet and don't really know what it is at all. Just heard it was souls-like

Soulslike steampunk Pinocchio in a Victorian-esque setting. There's a clear AI theme with puppets = robots.

The game isn't bad, but I wouldn't recommend it to anyone unless you really, really, love Soulslike games. It's harder than Sekiro IMO. Perfect parry isn't an option, it's required and the timing is tighter. The 5th boss is a gank fight and each boss has been harder than the previous.

hm... This is probably a game on my list for later. Love me some Souls-likes. But I don't have the time/funds to pick up another game right now. Gotta finish what I am already playing.

I'm a little over half way (well maybe more than a little) and while the game is good I do have some criticisms that are shared elsewhere.
From least subjective to most subjective.

Weapon Durability:
Your weapon can actually break in combat against bosses even if at 100% beforehand. You have a built in repair as well as access to instant repair tools, but I don't know why this system was even implemented. Your weapon takes damage from blocking and dealing damage. You're already being punished when blocking by taking chip damage that you can't always get back with the Rally system (blocked damage and ONLY blocked damage can be restored by dealing damage in X number of seconds). It just seems like an additional way to punish the player that doesn't add any meaningful difficulty. Oh, and if your weapon breaks completely, you can't even repair it. The worst part is that there is a status effect that deals both damage and weapon durability damage and there is a boss that can inflict it in two hits. IIRC it goes through block.

Dodge mechanics are locked behind upgrades. These mechanics are baseline in every Fromsoftware game and Team Ninja (Nioh 2, Wo Long) game I've played. It seems like a form of artificial difficulty.

Enemies don't automatically stagger when 'poise broken'. They enter a 'groggy' state where a charged r2 can stagger them for a Critical/Riposte/Visceral type hit, but I've seen bosses not give openings for that multiple times. It feels really bad to do everything right and then be 'punished' by never getting a window.

There are some platforming sections that are worse than anything I've encountered in DS3, BB, ER, Sekiro, Nioh 2, Wo Long, and JFO. Obviously you can beat them, but they can be frustrating. The worst part is throwables completely negate them (or at least the ones I've seen), so they almost seem like an item check.

The perfect parry window is tighter than Sekiro's deflection window and this isn't terrible, but the enemy animations make it feel worse than it is because a lot of them are similar to the Erdtree Watchdog's delayed windup and almost instant swing.

There is no animation canceling which again, isn't terrible, but this forces defensive over offensive play or complete knowledge of the boss's moveset so you know exactly how big your punish window is at any given time. I really think melee focused games benefit from an attack cancel window in the first few frames of your attack and being able to cancel past the 25% point is what makes it broken.

You don't have 100% block, the blocked amount is tied to your blade. All non-boss weapons can be broken down into blade and hilt. The hilt determines the moveset (but not the Weapon Arts). This means it's better to throw a greatsword blade onto a rapier hilt for extra block than it is to use the actual rapier blade. It's just weird to me.

Further explanation:
Rapier absorbs 35%
Saw Blade absorbs 70%
If you take 4 swings at 1000 damage each
Perfect Parry 3 swings with Rapier and block the 4th = 650 damage taken
Perfect Parry 2 swings with Saw Blade and block the other = 600 damage taken

Even when attached to the rapier hilt the Saw Blade does more damage so you'll get more health back. It's weird to me that you're actually rewarded for playing WORSE based solely on your blade type.