Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

 Lathe Biosas wrote:
How tough can CSM really be? Didn't they lose a bunch of their forces to a single Tau Firewarrior?

Ah, but the only time gameplay = lore is when the games are called Space Marine or Boltgun

To be fair, he's mostly packing Imperial weaponry

 Bobthehero wrote:

 Lathe Biosas wrote:
How tough can CSM really be? Didn't they lose a bunch of their forces to a single Tau Firewarrior?

Ah, but the only time gameplay = lore is when the games are called Space Marine or Boltgun

It was also a Black Library novel.

It was? Huh

 Bobthehero wrote:
It was? Huh

Simon Spurrier wrote it.

It's not just BL novels. I recently watched Iron within and was quite... irritated about the presentation of the Dark Eldar there. They're a serious thread to the Guardsmen but also die repeatedly, but when the Space Marines come in they all die like stupid chaff, only the Archon can put up a fight. I'm usually one to say aspect warriors, immortals, nobz, Crisis suite and whatever are on par with Space Marines... but more and more I get the impression that's not current lore. Space Marines are the Avengers and everyone else is mooks. Only in DoW Trailers Space Marines die as they should

A lot of animations pit Space Marines against things that should be far more threatening to them than what is portrayed, I don't know if it stems from the ''Astartes'' short, but at least there the Marines fought cultists.

Lets not overlook that most animations are VERY short snippets and favour whichever side they are told behind. If they focus on the Admech then a single robot and priest can take on whole swarms of orks; if its a single battleship of nurgle worshippers they can wipe out a whole Imperial bastion.


So yeah the marine focused ones focus on marines and the marines win and because its not got 60-120-a whole season to play out the marines often win pretty easily etc...



Honestly I think some of it is just people hyper-fixating on marines winning. Which is compounded when a LOT of the lore (esp BL) is focused on the Imperial faction.

Both the 9th and 10th edition trailer animations have a lot of Space Marines die.

 Lathe Biosas wrote:
How tough can CSM really be? Didn't they lose a bunch of their forces to a single Tau Firewarrior?

Are CSM immortal? Do they get reincarnated/new bodies in the Warp after they die? Or does Chaos need to keep corrupting new/different servants of The Emperor/The False God to keep going?

Who the feth cares? Do people really look at the novels and the game in the same breath? Holy gak...my writing critique group would obliterate the authors of the GW universe with simple, basic criticism. The writing is literal gak, in most cases. The only reason it gets published is GW has its own publishing company. Many tournament players don't put more than three colors on their army, just so they can meet the minimum. GW writers aren't much different.

Money is what matters now, not hobby. That died in what? 1999? Pick a year. You'll be right.

Outside sm novels, 40k books not that bad.

 Kagetora wrote:

 Lathe Biosas wrote:
How tough can CSM really be? Didn't they lose a bunch of their forces to a single Tau Firewarrior?

Are CSM immortal? Do they get reincarnated/new bodies in the Warp after they die? Or does Chaos need to keep corrupting new/different servants of The Emperor/The False God to keep going?

Space Marines are generally considered to be 'soft' immortal in the sense that they do not die of old age and appear to never grow infirm with age. It is unclear if this is because they really don't get to this state or if because no Space Marine has ever lived long enough to reach that state.

Loyalist Space Marines either die in battle before death by age would incur or are stuck in stasis most of the time (Bjorn the Fell-Handed). Traitor Marines spend long stretches in the Warp, especially the Eye of Terror, and do not age while there. This extends whatever their natural lifespan would be.

Regardless, all Chaos Space Marine who have not ascended to Daemon Prince are mortal in they die from outside forces and stay dead. This is where the entire 40K setting becomes a bit silly. None of the numbers presented make sense. Given how few Space Marines (Loyalist and Chaos) there are, they die far too quickly for them to still exist given their replenishment rate.

I should do a new playthough of SM2 and count the bodies. I remember noticing the first time though the sheer numbers of SM corpses scattered around. Like “the chapter may not recover” levels of death.

But they do liven up the place and set the scene that the bad guys are dangerous.

(while a trio of guys murders hundreds of mooks and a hefty number of serious foes)

 Kagetora wrote:

 Lathe Biosas wrote:
How tough can CSM really be? Didn't they lose a bunch of their forces to a single Tau Firewarrior?

Who the feth cares? Do people really look at the novels and the game in the same breath? Holy gak...my writing critique group would obliterate the authors of the GW universe with simple, basic criticism. The writing is literal gak, in most cases. The only reason it gets published is GW has its own publishing company. Many tournament players don't put more than three colors on their army, just so they can meet the minimum. GW writers aren't much different.

That's just, like, your opinion, man.