Yes, a group of friends and I have stuck primarily to the older editions. 3rd was the edition when I got started, and 4th and 5th were editions of heavy gaming for our group. 6th ed. was good depending on the list one was running, but some lists suffered as things went along. (Flying landraiders and other shenanigans).
The main change I recall was when fliers were introduced, we were always good with the hand full of Forge World flyers doing good ol' strafing runs, and super heavies and units from Forge World as they were gems and rare opponents. But as flyers and super heavies became more and more common, the game changed (at least my, and a few others perspective).
I remember the Chicago Games Day when they introduced Apocalypse, and a few of us knew with the introduction of larger and larger individual units and tanks the game was going to develop in a different way. -- Different is not bad, just not what I was looking for.
I do have an army list put together for later editions, but simply 4th-5th are our editions of choice as it is what many of us know (mainly due to the average age of our group).
|