What exactly does he gain from taking the large foot squad anyway? Seriously.
2 darklances? He already has 10 of them on raiders and ravagers.
2 splinter cannons? You think the list needs what is essentially 4 storm bolters on a cheap but flimsy platform?
Objective grabber? So a raider squad can't snatch an objective?
What he loses in swapping a raider to a foot slogging is a mobile darklance, overall greater mobility and most importantly target saturation. Not a fair trade.
you need to get off this escalation stuff.. escalation doesnt happen all that often mnostly in tournies but not store games
I'm not going to 'get off' because escalation is something to keep in mind when giving general advice to complete strangers. I'd prefer to let him decide if escalation is going to be an issue for him.
and uh with escalation rules troops will be the only things on the board..what are you worried about? ill take 12-14 dark eldar in cover against any other armies troop choices any day of the week.
Well in escalation I'd be worried about infiltrators,
HB dev squads, heavy weapon teams, terminators, etc. Not only specific units but multiple units (even ones inferior to the mighty
DE warrior) against your single squad. It only takes 3-4 kills from shooting to force a moral check on that squad. Not hard to do with multishot weapons, even if you're in hard cover.
really? you do that your a sitting duck.. you cant move and fire the dark lance can you ? you can move and fire the splinter cannon you talk about being highly mobile your contradicting yourself in that way ..
I'm not contradicting myself. I'm simply pointing out that the splinter cannon isn't all that great and should only be on raider squads because: a) you can shoot it and move/assault and b) they can't take another blaster. And they shouldn't be taken over blasters on the raider squads because blasters are much much better.
As far as footsloggers, I'd take darklances everytime. Way more effective then splinter cannons; even if you can't move and shoot.
the splinter cannon is for the horde units to stop them before they get to my fire team
Good luck with that.