My theory would also explain how the AI is at times able to pull off some seriously bull

moves to come back from behind and tie the game. Especially when you're facing a team that's play style counters yours (Power teams vs high
AG teams).
I've been waiting for a another chance to redue my experiment with a better scope and got one last night. I again encountered the ball problem, and I did more extensive experimentation.
I redid 20 attempts to pick up the ball, and all failed. I attempted it then 20 times with another character (with sure hands) and it again failed all 20 times. I also noticed this time that the ball always landed in the same place all 40 permutations (I did not notice this before so I'm not sure). The AI always placed the ball in the same place until I reorganized my line for a different try. It landed somewhere else but in the same place each time for that organization.
I actually want to test my own kick offs next to check for a similar result.