Hi there! Thanks for weighing in on this apparently controversial matter.
While I appreciate your repetition of a point which is not your own, I can't help but note that when you did so you ignored all of the points which I made in response.
In regards to your focus on the 'unique' nature of this Eldar army. There is an established precedent for primitive or regressed Eldar within the
WH40K canon, namely the Exodite Eldar. Exodites have been used for inspiration for several armies which can be found online. I have seen many fine Exodite armies which use both
40K and Fantasy miniatures together to create a unique look. If I had appropriate Eldar bitz, I would have attempted to kitbash similar conversions to those armies. Unfortunately I didn't have those bitz, so I did the best I could with what I had on hand.
Does this mean that this army is less 'unique' than another Eldar Exodite army? I don't think it does. Could I have tried advertising this as an “Eldar Exodite Army” only to have people point out that those Exodites are in fact Wood Elves? Certainly I could have, but I felt that would have been dishonest. Instead I used a tantalizing word to make viewers wonder what was 'unique' about this army. I presented exactly what it was that was unique about this army as soon as someone looked in my post.
I can only apologize if someone ended up feeling that my practical solutions, unifying paint scheme, and proxied figures don't meet someone's exacting standards of something 'unique'. Nonetheless, I still feel that all of my original points regarding this army are valid, and I feel that my title best describes the army I'm offering.
Please feel free to examine some pictures of this army and judge for yourself:
Automatically Appended Next Post: Hey there Folks,
Today is the last day on my two remaining auctions! I'm pleased to announce that my Bretonnians have been sold off, and are currently speeding their way to their new home!
In celebration, I've put up an auction for a fully painted Lizardman Slann Mage Priest. This big guy is fully painted to a tabletop quality, and pictures can be found on his auction site!
http://www.ebay.ca/itm/251338144337?ssPageName=STRK:MESELX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1555.l2649
Thanks for the support!