Belongs here:
http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/forums/show/57.page;jsessionid=535B702839100C9D420C705535B08A0F
But, will get more views here. Excellent review! Not too fanboy, not too harsh. With a fresh outlook that pretends to ignore that this is the third and fourth remake of a 26 year-old game. Well done!
It really takes an active imagination (and probably a personality disorder) to NOT like this edition of a classic game. One could always want more. But,
GW settled for nothing less than excellent. These versions of the game (Third and Fourth edition) are completely self-contained, requiring no expansions. And, they managed to include the "best of " previous expansions (expanded weapons, specialists, and simplified, workable Psychics). OK, maybe, with the release of the
40K Genestealer Cult, one might wish for an expansion that includes the Cult goodness from the
Genestealer expansion. But, one might also recall that those rules were less than perfect. I already own a new
GSC army, so don't need the models. I can find the expansion rules from the Internet (OK, who am I kidding, I've owned the original
Genestealer and
Deathwing expansions since they went on sale). But, what would be super-spiffy is the tiles from those expansions redone for this edition. Oh, and some Hard Core Genestealer Cult cinematic action.
And, yes, I currently have on my painting table an all new Burning of Prospero plastic Mk III "Iron Armor" squad in Blood Angel colors, expressly destined for Space Hulk.
Obsession is to Passion as Need is to Want.