Switch Theme:

Share on facebook Share on Twitter Submit to Reddit  [RSS] 

Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 09:40:28


Post by: squilverine


Inspired by a post in another thread, and the recent smack in the head Leona Lewis got at a book signing, because a fan had to wait for too long and she signed his name incorrectly! It got me thinking, if you could smack just one celebrity who would it be?

If possible post a picture along with your reason for giving them a good wallop!

Mine has to be



Micheal Ball

I can't stand the guys cleaner than clean, house wives favorite image, it makes me sick


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 09:46:09


Post by: Jimi Nemesis




I would hit that. Oh! you mean..? I gets it now...

I wouldn't mind bludgeoning to death every member of Behind Crimson Eyes for making me sit through their massacre of Motorhead's "The Ace Of Spades" while waitning to see Iron Maiden last year.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 09:50:05


Post by: Anshal


Jimi Nemesis wrote:

I would hit that. Oh! you mean..? I gets it now...

I wouldn't mind bludgeoning to death every member of Behind Crimson Eyes for making me sit through their massacre of Motorhead's "The Ace Of Spades" while waitning to see Iron Maiden last year.



Oooo me to But back on topic, I would like to punch Bradd Pitt and Nicolas Cage, well scarp that and just add enthier hollywood


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 09:54:46


Post by: Albatross


There are quite a few slebrities i would like to give 'a bit of a slap'.

Here's a couple.



Grrr... you can't sing, you smug tit. BIFF!




What? You want some 'n' all Blunt? POW!



Well, I know I shouldn't hit a woman, but.... ZAP! POW! BOFF! ZANG!
I hate Jordan.



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 10:00:38


Post by: SilverMK2


I wouldn't mind dropping a huge bomb on the next reality TV/make-a-random-person-"famous" TV conference.

Although strictly speaking (or dancing, if I were a bee), I suppose none of those people are actually celebrities.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 10:07:13


Post by: Wrexasaur


Power combo pimp-slap, coming up.



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 10:25:57


Post by: warpcrafter


Wrexasaur wrote:Power combo pimp-slap, coming up.



Put Bill O'Reilly in that picture and you'd have a pretty good argument against the first amendment.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 10:34:39


Post by: sonofruss


That twit who wrote twilight.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 11:41:17


Post by: chromedog


Wrexasaur wrote:Power combo pimp-slap, coming up.



So who are they that I should care?

Not all of us on this board are US-ians, after all.

I'd like to hit Chris Martin from Coldplay with Bono. Sanctimoniuous gits.





Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 11:47:06


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik




Fat because he's smug, or smug because he's fat? Who cares? BOKO! Right in his insincere kisser.



STOP RUINING MUSIC YOU COCK!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 14:30:17


Post by: FITZZ


I have a few...but at the top of my list would be
Sean (P Diddy,Puff Daddy) Combs,I can't even begin to explain how much joy I would get from kicking this mans teeth out.



A close second on the "stomp"list is this guy...



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 14:40:43


Post by: Commissar Molotov


I'd really, really like to punch Perez Hilton right in the eye...



Hey - looks like somebody beat me to it!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 17:39:05


Post by: chaplaingrabthar


chromedog wrote:
Wrexasaur wrote:Power combo pimp-slap, coming up.



So who are they that I should care?


Political opinion cockgobblers, specifically:

Rush Limbaugh & Glenn Beck
To prove fairness, here's two more cockgobblers from the other side of the spectrum who need punching


Keith Olbermann & Chris Matthews

shame they got political, Olbermann used to be great when he was on ESPN's Sportscenter alongside Dan Patrick.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 18:22:07


Post by: theocd


ALL OF THE ERS!!!!!

The OC-D


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 19:04:20


Post by: George Spiggott




Ghandi


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 19:15:12


Post by: chaplaingrabthar





Ghandi is so insubordinate


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 20:00:13


Post by: barlio


1. I would like to slap the smug grin off of Rachel Maddow's face.

2. Spencer Pratt from the Hills. I don't really need a reason, it just comes naturally.

3. Alec Baldwin - he should be on everybody's top 5 list.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 20:03:41


Post by: dietrich


Who's the hot redhead? Did Tori Amos go slutty?

As far as who I'd like to punch in the face - David Hasselhoff.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 20:19:48


Post by: Commissar Molotov


Look out! He wants to hassle the Hoff!



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 20:24:48


Post by: chaplaingrabthar


The most punchable face in the world


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 20:28:36


Post by: dietrich


All I can say to Hugh Grant is, "You cheated on Liz Hurley with her? What is wrong with you?"


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 20:45:36


Post by: MeanGreenStompa


Must...destroy...this...cu..........



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 20:47:34


Post by: Frazzled


MGS, I would buy you a beer just on general principles.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 20:48:42


Post by: Anshal


Forgot to add to people I want so slapp hard
1. The slowed monkey who currently dose his best to ruin Norway
2. The evil, evil man

[Thumb - Jens_Stoltenberg.jpg]
[Thumb - uwe.jpg]


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 20:54:09


Post by: Frazzled


Who are they?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 21:05:54


Post by: Izual


1. The Norwegian stateminister Jens Stoltenberg
2. Crappiest Director of all time: Uwe Boll


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 21:13:18


Post by: Joetaco


i want want to beat down
1. Adam Sandler-because hes just not funny and is in way too many movies.
2. Owen Wilson- same as above
3. Ben Stiller- same as above
4. Nicolas Cage- can't act and yet still finds work for some reason
5. Michale (f'n) Phelps- proves a white man can be caught doing something illegal and not get in trouble while a African American football legend can be sent to prison because of hearsay and the fact it happened at his vacation home
6. Steven King- worst writer ever. Insult to the horror genre



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 21:21:26


Post by: dietrich


I still want to know who the redhead is. In fact, I don't recognize most of the 'celebreties'.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 21:24:56


Post by: barlio


I thought that was Wolfgang Puck at first and was like, "Why would somebody want to punch Wolfgang. He seems like a cool dude." But now that I know it's Uwe Boll I'll Tag Team with whomever wants to fight him.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 21:25:44


Post by: Krak_kirby


What's a celebrity? I sit in my living room building and painting models, when I'm not in my LGS playing games...


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 21:28:40


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik




Well, look who it is! It's a cretin who feels that being Gay is in of itself a source of comedy.

WRONG! And take your lame mate Justin Lee Cockface with you.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 21:29:02


Post by: speedfreak


Alexander Ovechkin. I can't stand him.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 21:59:54


Post by: sonofruss


* Looks around wondering why H.B.M.C. has not put up a pic of Jervis?*


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 22:34:55


Post by: Kilkrazy


It seems bad taste to mention real people who might actually read this forum but, anyway...



I have loathed Jamie Cullum and his smug, pseudo modern massacres of jazz classics ever since I first heard him. Whenever he comes on the radio I want to spew up.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 22:52:29


Post by: Golden Eyed Scout


I would beat Heidi and Specncer Pratt to death with a pillow case full of rusty doorknobs.

I would punch every member of jersey Shore in the face. Oh wait, someone beat me to my favorite target. Oh dang.






Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 22:59:59


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Kilkrazy wrote:It seems bad taste to mention real people who might actually read this forum but, anyway...



I have loathed Jamie Cullum and his smug, pseudo modern massacres of jazz classics ever since I first heard him. Whenever he comes on the radio I want to spew up.


He plays? DAMN HIS EYES! After we've both punched him of course.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 23:02:16


Post by: chromedog


dietrich wrote:Who's the hot redhead? Did Tori Amos go slutty?


Simone Simons, lead singer for the Dutch symphonic metal ensemble Epica.

Yep, she's a hotty alright.

I found it by googling "Heavy metal bands with hot redheaded singers" no lie.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 23:03:04


Post by: Jazz is for Losers


Nice thread! I think about this quite often, though instead of a punch in the face my punishments range from smashing their hand with a 9lb hammer to shooting them, execution style, with a .22 (or something small calibre that will ping around inside the brain pan).

Candidates include-

This incredible tool


and this munchkin


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 23:04:30


Post by: Asherian Command


Every Singel Celerbrity that was involved in Lost in Space.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 23:08:51


Post by: Ravenous D


George Spiggott wrote:

Ghandi




Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 23:21:40


Post by: Albatross


"Big guy, big reach - skinny guys fight 'til they're burger..."


Awesome film.

Also...
@MGS - I quite like Justin Lee Collins - Alan Carr can feth right off, though. And Gok Wan.



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/22 23:26:49


Post by: eldarbgamer13


falcon punch the octomom in the stomach to solve her child problem


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 00:12:35


Post by: dogma


Cindy Sheehan
Sam Harris
John Madden


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 00:19:14


Post by: Khornholio


I don't think "punch" is the verb of choice. 'Flay'...in some cases 'Nail'.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 00:53:53


Post by: Norwulf


Bill Maher, because people aren't going to hell fast enough. And maybe "punch" isn't enough? How about eviscerate or burn alive?


and Nic cage and keanu reeves cant act. Fred Durst and that crap band that mutilated "Holy Diver".


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 01:06:20


Post by: garret


Cyrus-Both of them.
For general stupidness and degrading disney into a music label and music in genral

for letting her do that but in other word hes a good guy

same as cyrus Although i aim for the south




Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 02:28:00


Post by: chaplaingrabthar


speedfreak wrote:Alexander Ovechkin. I can't stand him.


I will cut yo

/Caps fan. Ovie is AWESOME


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 02:29:50


Post by: Kanluwen


Tom Cruise.

For making Scientology 'hip'.

You lousy bastard.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 03:09:38


Post by: Snikkyd


Damn Garret you beat me to it.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 03:16:31


Post by: nintendoeats


Is it just me or do the Jonas brothers have NO personality? I mean, they are both playing BLACK guitars for frazps sake, and not even something iconic like a Strat (Actually, I hate black strats, but anyway).

I mean, a BLACK SG and a BLACK Explorer? Who the hell thought that was even remotely interesting/cool/attractive/not blatantly bought off the internet by a fashion designer who resented having to co-ordinate another accessory?

And why do thye always have to be clearly standing in the order:

Not really suave guy---not really deep guy---not really a rocker guy?

In every picture I see of them its like they drew a line and they want everybody to be attracted to the one in the middle because he represents some kind of idiotic middle ground, like personalities all fall along a single axis (love and fear to be precise).

ANYWAY

I want to punch every member of "The Feeling", Metallica, Will Smith for the damage he has done to great sci-fi novels and GOD DAMNED FRAKKING RACIST CHICKEN gaking ASS-FACE NOT-A-DOCTOR PHIL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Automatically Appended Next Post:
And another thing, why the hell do people even buy explorers? It makes the very clear statement "I want my instrument to look as akward and impractical (and not all-together cool) as possible."

Its better than a Flying V, but come on. If you want an impractical guitar, get a Bo-Diddly. At least they are good for a laugh.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 05:45:55


Post by: Shaman


Cant believe no one said Kanye West.



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 08:52:10


Post by: Albatross


@nintendoeats - I want to punch the guy who designed THIS fething monstrosity:




GAH! The pointy!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 09:00:44


Post by: Tim the Biovore


Being the violent me, I would punch:
Miley Cyrus
Robert Patterson
Stephanie Meyer
The Jonas Bros
And if I'm not tired of maiming, George W. Bush


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 09:33:58


Post by: squilverine


Jazz is for Losers wrote:Nice thread! I think about this quite often, though instead of a punch in the face my punishments range from smashing their hand with a 9lb hammer to shooting them, execution style, with a .22 (or something small calibre that will ping around inside the brain pan).

Candidates include-

This incredible tool


I have always had a theory that Gok is in fact straight, and has just figured out a very cunning way of touching up fatt girls without getting a slap or a court order. Good on him I say!

Back on topic another "on my list"



Dull, talentless bint.



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 12:33:10


Post by: Jimi Nemesis


dietrich wrote:Who's the hot redhead? Did Tori Amos go slutty?

As far as who I'd like to punch in the face - David Hasselhoff.


Chromedog got it right. The ever lovely Simone Simons

chaplaingrabthar wrote:The most punchable face in the world

MeanGreenStompa wrote:Must...destroy...this...cu..........



I love both of you like brothers.

nintendoeats wrote:And another thing, why the hell do people even buy explorers? It makes the very clear statement "I want my instrument to look as akward and impractical (and not all-together cool) as possible."

Its better than a Flying V, but come on. If you want an impractical guitar, get a Bo-Diddly. At least they are good for a laugh.


Some Explorers can look alright, as long as you're OVER 6 feet tall...

Albatross wrote:@nintendoeats - I want to punch the guy who designed THIS fething monstrosity:




GAH! The pointy!


Now then Albatross, you had better NEVER show your face in ANY topic about metal EVER again.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 12:47:00


Post by: nintendoeats


Why would you want to consort with anybody who was interested in THAT? Thats like saying "now that you have made fun of sticking your face in crap, you aren't aloud into any of my orgies."

EDIT: and jeez, what must that thing sound like? I mean, there is almost nothing there for the sound to reverberate through. Its like they made a neck and thought at the last moment "aw crap! the hardware has to go ON something"...


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 12:48:48


Post by: Chibi Bodge-Battle


First of all, Gandhi?
only coz ya know he won't hit back
Not sure Gandhi counts as a celeb. I mean, when was he last in Hello or such like?

Secondly, it would be simpler just to line all celebs up against the Great Wall of China. Then make the media pillocks who have a career out of promoting celebrity culture shoot the lot of 'em with dum-dum bullets

then line the media lot up and shoot them too

AHH! I feel so much better now!


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Yup I hate Gok because he shouts "OK Girls get nakee!" and they all take their clothes off!

I thought it was a jolly good idea
but when I tried it, i got a smack in the gob and ended up with a broken jaw and arrested.

The court case is next week :(


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 12:56:47


Post by: Geosto12mer


I want to punch Shaun White so hard in the face his ginger falls off!!! i don't know why i want to though....


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 13:11:08


Post by: Tim the Biovore


I was just thinking about that guitar, when it hit me. It hurt. But seriously, it could only be good for the guitar breaking stunt.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 14:43:28


Post by: Albatross


Jimi Nemesis wrote:
Now then Albatross, you had better NEVER show your face in ANY topic about metal EVER again.


Don't worry, I won't - I have a girlfriend and don't hate my parents.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 15:02:30


Post by: SlaveToDorkness


Oh, yes, Kanye must DIE! That gay fish!

Hmm....

THIS guy form the Budlight commercials:



I have come very close to destroying my TV remote trying to change the channel fast enough to not see his gak ass.

I feel pretty good about my pop-culture immersion (or lack thereof) because I have no idea who 90% of the people pictured in this thread are.



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 16:15:23


Post by: Jazz is for Losers


Are we allowed to nominate Dakka posters? For his Cheryl Tweedy Blasphemy I'd nominate


Also Headshot these two




And also Katie Price while we're at it.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 16:18:41


Post by: nintendoeats


Nope, don't kow them at all.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 17:31:27


Post by: J.Black


This man......


.....Has a really punchable face.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 17:38:07


Post by: Orkeosaurus




Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 18:21:36


Post by: Anshal


This vile fiend needs to be punched

[Thumb - george-clooney-picture-2.jpg]


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 18:39:43


Post by: hcordes



I wouldn't do it myself.. but i'd pay money to see someone do it.... vote or die, and she didn't even register dumb beezy.


and then this tool box....


not really a celeb per say.... but famous enough.... I went to high school with this tard, and he used to give me and my friends s t for being into all the stuff he talks about on his show... and now he some "nerd icon" and it makes me sick. Also on my schools website, he's the only "notable" graduate.



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 19:04:20


Post by: Hans_posthumus




Damn I hate those fools


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 19:14:08


Post by: Major Malfunction


All three of 'em... but open handed pimp slapping because real men don't punch women.





Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 19:21:52


Post by: nintendoeats


I
Hate
Kevin
Perarrah

He is one of the reasons that X-Play became unwatcheable. AOTS is garbage. He destroys everything he touches.

I', glad to hear that he really is a d**k in real life, because now I'm allowed to REALLY hate him.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 20:16:14


Post by: Wraithlordmechanic


I will second:
Robert Patterson
Stephanie Meyer
The Jonas Bros
Paris Hilton
Bill Maher
Uwe Boll
Kanye West

and add:
Sarah Silverman
Sacha Cohen
Rosie O'donnell
Al Gore


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 21:05:02


Post by: Jazz is for Losers


Wraithlordmechanic wrote:
Sacha Cohen


Is it 'cos he is black?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 21:07:24


Post by: Kanluwen


I remove Robert Pattinson from the list.

Have you ever seen any interviews with him? He wants to talk about anything *but* Twilight...and openly mocks Twilight fans.

Anyone who does that, while getting paid millions is okay in my book.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 21:34:20


Post by: Malo


Miley Cyrus/ hannah Montana, The Jonas brothers (all three of them) and Justin Bieber!
Along with all the other talentless teen-stars from Disney...


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 21:57:36


Post by: Major Malfunction


Wraithlordmechanic wrote:
Rosie O'donnell
Al Gore


I would break my own rule about not hitting women to punch Rosie.

On second thought maybe not... can you really call her a woman? I mean, I know she's female and all but...

Al Gore most definitely.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 22:02:54


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Max Clifford. He needs more than a punch though.

Chris Moyles. Fat useless, talentless prick.

Oh, and Ben Fogle, who was only hired by the Beeb for being a little bit posh. gakker.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 22:03:37


Post by: whatwhat




how the hell the fact this guy made up torture allegations (including falsifying photos of troops pissing on iraqis), which almost got several British troops court marshaled/imprisoned, got forgotten by the general public I have no idea.

pow, right in the kisser.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 22:05:02


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Oh hell yes. Head Stomp for him I think.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 22:12:00


Post by: fire4effekt


Id really like to punch Shaun White in his ginger face, also Tobey Macguire(Spiderman) or however its spelled, he looks like a crier


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 22:25:23


Post by: squilverine




Because he looks like a fething chimp


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 22:31:35


Post by: Golden Eyed Scout


Albatross wrote:
Jimi Nemesis wrote:
Now then Albatross, you had better NEVER show your face in ANY topic about metal EVER again.


Don't worry, I won't - I have a girlfriend and don't hate my parents.


You have just earned the hatred of every metal head on dakka. Prepare for your DOOM!!!

Hans_posthumus wrote:

Damn I hate those fools



Thats a very pretty girl-GAHH!!!!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 23:00:14


Post by: Darth Bob





He's not just a talentless, prepubescent girl, but my friend knows him and says he's a gigantic douchebag in person.

I would like to award him the douche of the year award. And by that, I mean my foot in his face.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 23:13:57


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Justin who now?

Did they manage to splice Justin Timberlakes DNA with higher quantities of 'gakker'?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 23:30:34


Post by: Albatross


@whatwhat - You make an excellent case for giving Piers Morgan a sound thrashing! Perhaps someone should put a sack over his head and wee on him. Poetic justice.


GES wrote:You have just earned the hatred of every metal head on dakka. Prepare for your DOOM!!!


OOOHH! I'm quaking in my boots!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 23:39:55


Post by: J.Black


Don't worry Alba; it seems most people on this board who like 'metal' actually like 'Emo'. Personally I'm not gonna be scared of someone crying on me.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/23 23:54:23


Post by: Darth Bob


Mad Doc Grotsnik wrote:Justin who now?

Did they manage to splice Justin Timberlakes DNA with higher quantities of 'gakker'?



No, at least Timberlake has noticeable talent. He can dance his ass off and has a very nice voice. I'm not crazy about his music, but I won't deny he's got talent.

Justin Bieber, on the other hand, is a 15-year-old kid that sounds like a pre-pubescent girl. He sings like he knows all about love (because you totally know that at 15), and frequently uses ghetto language such as 'son' and 'shawty'. Not to mention he can't sing because he uses autotune. And his personality is also a trainwreck. He dumped his last girlfriend because she was in a boating accident and suffered brain damage and will be unable to walk again.

He is the definition of a gakker.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:08:41


Post by: Asherian Command


Everyone here hasn't Mention Jon Stewart or Steven Colbert. Thats good.

Heres people that must die.

\

Take that hollywood. This was the worst movie of all time wait sorry this was.



The two worst movies and casts of all time. I liked the main character from Water World. Because without that we would not have The Untouchables.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:11:00


Post by: KingCracker


Hans_posthumus wrote:

Damn I hate those fools



Who, or more noteably,what, the feth is that?! I cant tell if those are hardcore female rights activists....or hardcore sheboys. Seriously Im confused.

I want to punch the ever living poop out of Usher. Dunno why, I just cant stand anything that guy touches. I think if we ever crossed paths, Id just haul off and deck um


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:11:29


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Albatross wrote:


GES wrote:You have just earned the hatred of every metal head on dakka. Prepare for your DOOM!!!


OOOHH!


Fix'd AND improved!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:17:15


Post by: Darth Bob


KingCracker wrote:
I want to punch the ever living poop out of Usher. Dunno why, I just cant stand anything that guy touches. I think if we ever crossed paths, Id just haul off and deck um



On that note, it may be a good time to mention it was Usher that introduced Justin Bieber to the musical world....


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:18:12


Post by: FITZZ


I'm going to have to quickly come in on Albatross' side on the Guitar "issue".
I've been playing for MANY years (in quite a few metal/punk bands) and I HATE "warlock" style guitar bodies.





Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:20:51


Post by: Albatross


@KingCracker - I do believe it's Tokyo Hotel. I'm deducting 1 man point from myself for knowing that.

@MDG - Geniuses - I've got everything they've ever put out on DVD. I particularly love 'Catterick' - it's their 'Kid A'.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:23:53


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Still have to see Catterick, but my mate has it. One day, when his harridan missus is out, we shall pile round for a Vic and Bob fest.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:26:49


Post by: KingCracker


Darth Bob wrote:
KingCracker wrote:
I want to punch the ever living poop out of Usher. Dunno why, I just cant stand anything that guy touches. I think if we ever crossed paths, Id just haul off and deck um



On that note, it may be a good time to mention it was Usher that introduced Justin Bieber to the musical world....



Making my Usher punching all the more legitimate!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:26:51


Post by: FITZZ


While I'm thinking about it, I'd like to punch John "Johnny Rotten"Lydon right in the teeth for doing those ridiculous butter comercials.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:29:58


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


I dunno man, it's pretty Punk to have sold out like that. He tried to smash the state, failed, so started playing it at his own game.

Still considerably more punk than even the punkest teenager currently alive, who are a mere shadow of what they ape.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 00:36:58


Post by: FITZZ


I get your point MDG, and agree with the last part of your statement 100%.
Still abit disheartning to see this...



Become this...



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 04:14:59


Post by: SlaveToDorkness


Just goes to show that all of it is fake for the cash.

If it's not "Hey look at the crap I can do" it's Hey look at the crap I can sell"


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 10:19:12


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Nah, still think he's sticking true to his roots.

After all, Malcolm 'Bellend' MacLaren was in it purely for the money. First to promote his shop, and then when they started selling lots. You are aware The Sex Pistols were pretty much a manufactured band, yes?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 11:45:57


Post by: Hans_posthumus


@ Kingcracker; Jep it's tokio hotel. And if I were you I would stay with the "hardcore sheboys" thing.

Also does anyone recognizes this guy? He was the coach of Sven Kramer. Anyone saw the match yesterday? Anyone from Holland would like to punch him in the face I believe



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 15:50:27


Post by: nintendoeats


Back up a moment...Twilight was written by a GUY?....

That is disturbing.

Anyway, I have this theory about punk. Every single cultural phenominon that was actually worth something has been somehow stolen by the powers that be. With punk, they went further than we did so we said "Hey, I actually like that" and then proceeded to smack the person selling it to us with a chair and run off with several copies for all our buddies.

And that is how we stole punk...metaphoricly...


Automatically Appended Next Post:
He is involved in the olympics?

ME FIRST!!!!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 17:31:47


Post by: Little lord Fauntleroy


I can't believe no-one has mentioned mine yet....


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 18:02:20


Post by: Albatross


Nah, he actually seems alright. There are way worse tossers than him.

And now for this week's edition of Rockstars I would Like to Punch:


The Bell tolls for YOU, Ulrich!


Never mind The Police, someone call an ambulance!


It'll be a 'Bloody Sunday' if I ever catch up with THIS fething prat!




Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 18:08:00


Post by: Hawkins


Quinton Terintino. hands down he needs a shot in the head for all the psycho babble in his films.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 18:09:55


Post by: nintendoeats


@Albatross
I would point out that U2 recorded war (and hence Sunday Bloody sunday) BEFORE they became the most obnoxious and pretentious band in the universe. It also hapens to be fething awesome.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 18:12:06


Post by: Albatross


@Nintendoeats - And I would like to point out that I know that, and that I own it. And actually, that I quite like U2.

Just not the frontman. Good voice though.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 18:16:32


Post by: Hawkins


KingCracker wrote:
Hans_posthumus wrote:

Damn I hate those fools



Who, or more noteably,what, the feth is that?! I cant tell if those are hardcore female rights activists....or hardcore sheboys. Seriously Im confused.

I want to punch the ever living poop out of Usher. Dunno why, I just cant stand anything that guy touches. I think if we ever crossed paths, Id just haul off and deck um


That my friend is Tokyo Hotel and they come out of Germany. Germany unfortunately has some of the worst music in the world, sorry.


HAS the worst music inthe world. i mean come on they had David Hasslehof with a number 1 hit for christ sakes.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/24 18:59:52


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


I'd like to second Bonio.

And to prove it, here's a joke!

Q: What's the difference between God, and Bonio out of U2?

A: You'll never find God walking round Dublin thinking he's Bonio.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 01:05:38


Post by: guardpiper


For some reason, I would like to see Bob Villia or Norm Abram punch congress, or hit them with 2x4s. Just me.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 02:09:57


Post by: nintendoeats


To hell with it, I want to punch everybody who I have heard of who has not contributed in some positive way to my life. That means everybody from Brangelina to Rush Limbaugh to fething Hitler (Godwin can eat my cat).

Screw you useless famous people.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 02:59:33


Post by: George Spiggott


Albatross wrote:Just not the frontman. Good voice though.
That's the thing that pisses me off the most, that he named himself 'good voice'. What a prat.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 07:43:13


Post by: Dronze



Since when does Bjork have a poorly dressed, gay entourage?


Anywho... Celebrities I wanna punch....

Dennis Leary.

Not for any real reason, just because I had a dream where I did, and it was awesome.



Yes, yes, yes and yes.


And anyone who's name was attached to this giant cinematic hunk of crap....

All of these people for being the garbage version of SNL...



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 08:37:07


Post by: dogma


Mad TV was, in times immemorial, good.

The same is applicable to SNL, which is now, and has been for the last 10 years (maybe longer), crap.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 09:07:16


Post by: Khornholio


dogma wrote:Mad TV was, in times immemorial, good.

The same is applicable to SNL, which is now, and has been for the last 10 years (maybe longer), crap.


I choose maybe longer in this case. I remember it consistently sucking bad since 1995....


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 09:42:50


Post by: Terje-Tubby




WTF? Seriously, what is that?



I know you don`t hit girls, but this is an exception


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 10:39:14


Post by: JEB_Stuart


Don't worry, they aren't sure that it is a girl...


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 10:55:28


Post by: MeanGreenStompa


Terje-Tubby wrote:



I know you don`t hit girls, but this is an exception


Cannerus_The_Unbearable arrives nerdragin and all foamin at the mouth in 5,4,3....


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 11:19:28


Post by: chromedog


George Spiggott wrote:
Albatross wrote:Just not the frontman. Good voice though.
That's the thing that pisses me off the most, that he named himself 'good voice'. What a prat.


Actually, I believe the sobriquet of "Bono voce" (Good Voice") was bestowed upon him by Midge Ure of Ultravox fame.

That he liked it enough to keep it and though it was appropriate is enough to put him on a list of punchees, though.

Mind you, anyone wanting to punch Bono has to get behind Hank. Henry Rollins wants to punch him out first.



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 12:17:43


Post by: dogma


JEB_Stuart wrote:Don't worry, they aren't sure that it is a girl...


Like that stopped you before.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 13:18:04


Post by: Albatross


Liam Gallagher on Bono:

"You see pictures of Bono running around LA with his little white legs and a bottle of Volvic, and he looks like a fanny."


I'd quite like to hit Liam Gallagher as well, mind.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/26 14:07:30


Post by: KingCracker


Im in the same boat with U2. They made some really good music, but DAMMIT Bono is such and ass. I think he has the biggest god complex in the world.

And yea, Liam Gallagher deserves a punch for sure.
Same with Lars, god that guy is a total asshat as well. All he does is complain about people stealing his music, and then snuffs his fans with no autographs and the like. Sorry those people gave you millions, Im sure its such a burden


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/27 16:16:15


Post by: MeanGreenStompa


This ancient mound of gigatwatdom right here:


http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/7666826.stm


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/27 18:03:22


Post by: Albatross


@MGS - Woah, woah, woah! That man is a BEATLE ferchristsakes! You can't knock Ringo - the man changed pop/rock drumming forever...

...he could seriously break into my house in the middle of the night and stick his finger up my bum, and I'd still think he was great.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/27 18:10:29


Post by: nintendoeats


Hey, at least he is being honest. Its not like he is making some arbitrary statements about how stupid people are or anything, he is just being firm.

I can respect that.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/27 18:24:37


Post by: Albatross


Exactly - imagine how many autographs he's signed in his life! It's bound to get on your tits after a while, especially when most of them will end up on ebay these days.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/27 18:59:42


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Peace and Love, Peace and Love.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/27 19:06:29


Post by: Albatross


That's just, like, your opinion man...



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/27 19:37:26


Post by: FITZZ


Despite Ringos contributions to drumming,he did agree to do this...



Perhaps not worthy of a punch,but well worth a slap in the head.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:10:04


Post by: MeanGreenStompa


And whilst I'm railing against aged pop icons.

Here he is, the Lichmaster himself, the eternal botox bachelor boy, clad in a jacket of purest sanctimony...

Sir Cliff Richard.





Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:13:36


Post by: Albatross


MGS wrote:the eternal botox bachelor bum boy


Fixed.

It's nothing to be ashamed of Cliff! Light your light shine bright!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:16:14


Post by: dogma


Albatross wrote:...he could seriously break into my house in the middle of the night and stick his finger up my bum, and I'd love him forever.


Fixed.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:19:24


Post by: Albatross


I'll go along with that.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:27:20


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik




Hey! Wow! Look at me! I'm like, an effortless comedy genius! Yeah man! Wow! Aren't I kooky!

No.

You're a cock.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:29:33


Post by: nintendoeats


@Mad Doc Grotsnik: Don't say that to my Mom and brother, they will have your head.

The first season was pretty consistently funny...But on the whole I agree. TMB is more or less an extended youtube video.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:34:25


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


The Mighty Boosh.

To quote Spike Milligan 'they're about as funny as a baby with cancer'.

3 Series of 3 hours of poofy french jazz spank. I can't stand it. If you want weird and wacky humour, how about Vic and Bob? You know, the comedy double act the Mighty Boosh wish they were, but blatantly aren't?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:34:38


Post by: Albatross


@MDG - We've clashed about this before... let's just agree that I am right, and you are wrong and just leave it there.

Nice bloke as well, apparently.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:35:53


Post by: dogma


Albatross wrote:I'll go along with that.


Perhaps this thread should be renamed "Celebrities you would like to donkeypunch"?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:36:43


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Really? He's always come across as a self absorbed bellend on the Telly.

Rubbish! Rubbish! Rubbish!

And if Vic and Bob aren't your style, why not try The League Of Gentlemen for your fix of weird and bizarre.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:38:11


Post by: nintendoeats


The Goodies!!!!!


MDG gets my vote.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:47:24


Post by: Albatross


Dogma wrote:Perhaps this thread should be renamed "Celebrities you would like to donkeypunch you"?


Fixed.

@MGS - I like all three! Vic and Bob are my favourite comedians. My missus met Noel at a signing (I think - she got a picture, anyway), I'm sure she said he was a nice bloke. Good with the fans. I'll tell you who IS nice - Gordon Ramsay. Totally down-to-earth chap. So is Lenny Henry, although I don't particularly care for his comedy.

Apparently, Thom Yorke is a RIGHT knob-job - he tried to get my mate sacked! Still love his band, though.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:49:03


Post by: Slick Psychic


(1. Nicolas cage he is sooo boring.
(2. james patterson 1 for being on twilight, 2 for that screwed up face.
(3. paris hilton. GET. A. LIFE.!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:50:21


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


They do say never meet your idols!

But for Noel Fielding, I'll make an exception. In a dark alley. With a cricket bat. Knock that baseless, smug grin off his face. Seriously don't like him!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:51:57


Post by: nintendoeats


Albatross wrote:
Apparently, Thom Yorke is a RIGHT knob-job


don't
want
to
know


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:52:51


Post by: Albatross


You really hate him, don't you?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 00:54:40


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Yup! But not as much as I hate Eamonn Holmes.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 01:02:21


Post by: whatwhat


Albatross wrote:@MGS - Woah, woah, woah! That man is a BEATLE ferchristsakes! You can't knock Ringo - the man changed pop/rock drumming forever...

...he could seriously break into my house in the middle of the night and stick his finger up my bum, and I'd still think he was great.


To paraphrase John Lennon, Ringo Starr wasn't even the best drummer in The Beatles.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 01:06:09


Post by: nintendoeats


whatwhat wrote:
To paraphrase John Lennon, Ringo Starr wasn't even the best drummer in The Beatles.


OT: We were auditioning a guy to drum for us, and he was...not so good...nice guy, but couldn't keep a beat.

Of course, this meant that we had a drum set in my living room, which is also our practice space. We were shocked to discover that we were actually better drummers than him.

Funny.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 01:06:38


Post by: Albatross


@whatwhat - he may have said that, but when Ringo was recruited, he was widely considered to be the best rock 'n' roll drummer in Liverpool. He's influenced more drummers than he's ever really given credit for.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 01:12:23


Post by: whatwhat


The sole reason he has become an influential drummer was because he was in The Beatles. All he actually did was hold a beat.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 01:22:46


Post by: Albatross


@whatwhat - I'm not getting into this with you. You are incorrect, though.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 01:27:34


Post by: whatwhat


Albatross wrote:@whatwhat - I'm not getting into this with you. You are incorrect, though.


That's a good one. You're wrong, but I don't want to go into it. Brilliant.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 01:29:56


Post by: Golden Eyed Scout






Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 01:38:00


Post by: Albatross


@whatwhat - I could explain why you are wrong, if I thought you were doing anything other than trolling...

Oh well, here goes:

Most rock and roll drummers were lighter and jazzier before Ringo Starr, certainly in the UK. They also tended to use the orthodox-style grip, as opposed to the matched grip. Ringo played with a matched grip, mostly because he was left handed and he would often play on a right-handed set-up. This allowed him to hit harder than most other drummers. He also hit the bass-drum harder, and rather than decorating his parts with lots of fills, he just concentrated on playing the backbeat as hard as possible. This made the Beatles' music more danceable and 'insistent'. It definitely contributed to their success.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:00:04


Post by: whatwhat


None of that is remarkable for a drummer. Ringo's style suited the band, by no way was he the only person who could have done that. And Ringo didn't play fills because he was crap at them.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:08:12


Post by: nintendoeats


whatwhat wrote:None of that is remarkable for a drummer. Ringo's style suited the band, by no way was he the only person who could have done that. And Ringo didn't play fills because he was crap at them.


Yeah...and I can play the opening of "All Along The Watchtower." Jimi Hendrix is still a better guitar player than me because he was talented enough to do it first.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:10:49


Post by: whatwhat


Well I think I know what you're getting at. Much like my point earlier..

whatwhat wrote:The sole reason he has become an influential drummer was because he was in The Beatles.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:14:05


Post by: nintendoeats


You are making a circular argument. He was influential because he was in the beatles who were popular because they were very creative and made lots of interesting decisions that produced great work, making them popular and influential.

There are lots of popular musicians that aren't influential at all. You actually have to do something unique first.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:15:10


Post by: whatwhat


Well, in that case. I think your overestimating Ringo Starr's part in the creative decisions of The Beatles somehow. And even if he had had more of a role, that doesn't make him a great drummer.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:18:58


Post by: nintendoeats


whatwhat wrote:Well, in that case. I think your overestimating Ringo Starr's part in the creative decisions of The Beatles somehow. And even if he had had more of a role, that doesn't make him a great drummer.





Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:21:06


Post by: whatwhat


That's great. You were one half of a constructive argument until that. Thanks for your input...


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:25:19


Post by: nintendoeats


whatwhat wrote:That's great. You were one half of a constructive argument until that. Thanks for your input...


Yes I was. Albatross was the second half.

Don't get me wrong, I have no stake in this, I'm just calling them as I see them. However, Albatross has made a compelling argument. You have not, and in that post you repeated non-constructive statements, more or less ignoring what had been said previously rather than responding to it.

Hence, double facepalm.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:27:05


Post by: whatwhat


nintendoeats wrote:more or less ignoring what had been said previously rather than responding to it.


If I found irony half as funny as I should I would be on the floor right now.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:28:45


Post by: nintendoeats


Oh hell.

Not
Doing
This
.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:38:00


Post by: whatwhat



...and now I'd have probably rolled off the floor, down the stairs and into the kitchen.

Me I'm well aware who here is making the non-constructive statements, ignoring arguments and not responding and it's not me. If we could get back to my earlier point before your appearance then..

whatwhat wrote:
Albatross wrote:@whatwhat - I could explain why you are wrong, if I thought you were doing anything other than trolling...

Oh well, here goes:

Most rock and roll drummers were lighter and jazzier before Ringo Starr, certainly in the UK. They also tended to use the orthodox-style grip, as opposed to the matched grip. Ringo played with a matched grip, mostly because he was left handed and he would often play on a right-handed set-up. This allowed him to hit harder than most other drummers. He also hit the bass-drum harder, and rather than decorating his parts with lots of fills, he just concentrated on playing the backbeat as hard as possible. This made the Beatles' music more danceable and 'insistent'. It definitely contributed to their success.


None of that is remarkable for a drummer. Ringo's style suited the band, by no way was he the only person who could have done that. And Ringo didn't play fills because he was crap at them.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:55:09


Post by: nintendoeats


Ok, I'm being unfair.

THIS deserved double facepalm, since it completely failed to tread any new ground.

whatwhat wrote:Well, in that case. I think your overestimating Ringo Starr's part in the creative decisions of The Beatles somehow. And even if he had had more of a role, that doesn't make him a great drummer.


Up until then you were being reasonable. Not winning the argument I think, but reasonable.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:56:50


Post by: whatwhat


Maybe you could explain your disagreement with it rather than posting "non constructive statements" about it.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:58:37


Post by: Orkeosaurus


In a few years everyone will have forgotten about The Beatles anyways. Noone likes their old folk music.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 02:59:58


Post by: whatwhat


Well...I like "their old foke music." No good?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:02:05


Post by: Orkeosaurus


They'll be replaced by -=DRAGONFORCE=- !!!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:05:12


Post by: nintendoeats


whatwhat wrote:Maybe you could explain your disagreement with it rather than posting "non constructive statements" about it.


Its just a restatement of argument, the argument with which you began, and largely preying on the ambiguities of the situation. If you are saying that Ringo Starr having a reasonable creative influence on The Beatles work (Which I assume we all agree was some damn fine stuff) doesn't make him a great drummer, than you should define what you mean by a "great drummer." I expect what you were trying to do was shift the conversation to a discussion of what makes a musician great, a goal at which you did not succeed (unless you would like to do so now, but I don't see how one could make an argument about such a thing).


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:05:15


Post by: whatwhat


Orkeosaurus wrote:They'll be replaced by -=DRAGONFORCE=- !!!


Oh dear.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:05:26


Post by: nintendoeats


Orkeosaurus wrote:They'll be replaced by -=DRAGONFORCE=- !!!


I hate you.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:06:25


Post by: Vlad Von Carstien


BURNIE MADOFF
RAGE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
MUST TERMINATE


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:15:45


Post by: whatwhat


nintendoeats wrote:
whatwhat wrote:Maybe you could explain your disagreement with it rather than posting "non constructive statements" about it.


Its just a restatement of argument, the argument with which you began, and largely preying on the ambiguities of the situation. If you are saying that Ringo Starr having a reasonable creative influence on The Beatles work (Which I assume we all agree was some damn fine stuff) doesn't make him a great drummer, than you should define what you mean by a "great drummer." I expect what you were trying to do was shift the conversation to a discussion of what makes a musician great, a goal at which you did not succeed (unless you would like to do so now, but I don't see how one could make an argument about such a thing).

What? Read it again...

whatwhat wrote:Well, in that case. I think your overestimating Ringo Starr's part in the creative decisions of The Beatles somehow. And even if he had had more of a role, that doesn't make him a great drummer.

Firstly, how is that "the argument with which you began." I was talking to Albatross about Starr's ability as a drummer. That there above was a response to your entirely new point about creative input.

Ringo Starr having a reasonable creative influence on The Beatles work (Which I assume we all agree was some damn fine stuff)

If you will read my post again I'm not actually agreeing that Ringo had a great deal of creative input. Chiefly where I say.... "Well, in that case. I think your overestimating Ringo Starr's part in the creative decisions of The Beatles somehow."

Ringo literally waited on the other members to create the songs then turned up at the studio. On one occasion he temporarily quit because they were taking too long to get material ready for the studio. Ringos creative input was I'm afraid lacking compared to the other members.

....doesn't make him a great drummer, than you should define what you mean by a "great drummer. I expect what you were trying to do was shift the conversation to a discussion of what makes a musician great, a goal at which you did not succeed (unless you would like to do so now, but I don't see how one could make an argument about such a thing).

I think it was fairly clear myself and Albetross were talking about Ringo's ability as a drummer not a band member which you seem to be confusing it with.


What part of that was worthy of your "double facepalm"?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:39:23


Post by: nintendoeats


mwahaha. Much better.

So in essence, we ARE debating what we are debating.

This whole thing started with discussion about how and why Ringo was influential.

You were restating your argument very literaly. "even if what you say is true, I am still right" is just a restatement and a dismissal, unless you attatch a REASON that it is not true; perhaps a defenition of a great drummer.

In that veign, I realise that you weren't saying that Ringo had an influence. Your disgreement of that (which Albatross made a good argument for) is not a problem persay, but the point I was making against the second half of your post required it as a hypothetical.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:44:02


Post by: whatwhat


nintendoeats wrote:mwahaha. Much better.

So in essence, we ARE debating what we are debating.

This whole thing started with discussion about how and why Ringo was influential.

You were restating your argument very literaly. "even if what you say is true, I am still right" is just a restatement and a dismissal, unless you attatch a REASON that it is not true; perhaps a defenition of a great drummer.

In that veign, I realise that you weren't saying that Ringo had an influence. Your disgreement of that (which Albatross made a good argument for) is not a problem persay, but the point I was making against the second half of your post required it as a hypothetical.


What are you on about now? I never disagreed that Ringo Starr had an influence. Where did you get that from?

Read it back...

Albatross wrote:@whatwhat - he may have said that, but when Ringo was recruited, he was widely considered to be the best rock 'n' roll drummer in Liverpool. He's influenced more drummers than he's ever really given credit for.

whatwhat wrote:The sole reason he has become an influential drummer was because he was in The Beatles. All he actually did was hold a beat.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:47:44


Post by: nintendoeats


whatwhat wrote:All he actually did was hold a beat.


This I believe to be The main point of contention.

In essence, Albatross is arguing that Ringo actually did something worth drawing inspiration from. This, it would seem, is what you disagree with. yes?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:53:04


Post by: whatwhat


Erm, lets just leave it there. If Albatross wants to come back to this he can do but, nintendoeats no offence, you've done nothing but confuse me.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 03:56:14


Post by: nintendoeats


Same here.

Rum and coke?


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 12:42:45


Post by: Albatross


I'm back.

whatwhat wrote:Ringo literally waited on the other members to create the songs then turned up at the studio.


Erm... he was the drummer. That's fairly normal.


We shouldn't get away from the fact that my original point was that he changed rock drumming forever. I never said or implied that he was a virtuoso. He wasn't - a fact which he acknowledges. It was his 'feel' that was so vital to the Beatles, his stripped-down, 'heavy' style that influenced many subsequent drummers, from John Bonham to Dave Grohl and many others.

whatwhat wrote:None of that is remarkable for a drummer. Ringo's style suited the band, by no way was he the only person who could have done that. And Ringo didn't play fills because he was crap at them.


Can you play them? There ARE fills in Beatles songs, and they are often very good. Ringo plays some fairly tricky stuff in 'I Feel Fine'. Plus whatwhat, you like dance music, yeah?

'Tomorrow Never Knows'

Sit there and tell me that it isn't influential. The beat is great, and trickier than it sounds.
In any case, perhaps another drummer could have done those things - but he didn't, not at that time and place. Elvis was only Elvis because of a certain set of circumstances, it could quite easily have been someone else. The Beatles were'nt the first to use a heavy backbeat, they weren't the first to use modal harmony, or Orientalism, sound collage or intertextuality and recontextualisation. But they popularised them - a certain set of factors meant that it is THEY who became influential. None of those things are remarkable now, but they were then, and so was Ringo's aggressive style.



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 13:03:05


Post by: MeanGreenStompa


Golden Eyed Scout wrote:



Who is this? She can bounce on Uncle Stompa's knee.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 14:41:59


Post by: hcordes


isn't that Kristen whats her face from Twilight


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 21:09:06


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


I dunno who she is. But she looks like a window licker to me. Seriously, if that face is meant to be seductive, she's missed the mark by some miles.

Cold, dead eyes of a slow!


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 21:38:28


Post by: Flashman


If we're still on about punching famous people and not ogling Kirsten Stewart, can we line up George Osbourne as the recipient of my knuckle sandwich?

For non-UK Dakkaites - George (real name Gideon) Osbourne is one of 'Call me Dave' Cameron's Eton cronies and will be in charge of all the money if they're voted in. He is an utter twit (substitute the 'i' for an 'a' for my true meaning) and needs a good kick up the arse all the way to China and back.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 21:42:53


Post by: squilverine


I wouldn't so much like to punch these two chods, as kick the living feth out of them



Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 21:54:31


Post by: Mad Doc Grotsnik


Oh dear oh dear.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/02/28 22:43:42


Post by: Albatross


'Chods'





Haven't heard that word since I was 14! Quality.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/03/01 01:06:03


Post by: chaplaingrabthar



I would like to punch him until his head was no longer so square, whining miserable piss pot.

You were in the best cars on the grid for damn near a decade and you couldn't even compete for one lousy championship, you Scottish knob gobbler

For the uninitiated, that's David Coulthard, former bad Formula 1 driver.


Celebrities you would like to punch @ 2010/03/01 01:08:22


Post by: Orkeosaurus




Did he spend the first fifteen years of his life with his head in a box?