Switch Theme:

Share on facebook Share on Twitter Submit to Reddit  [RSS] 

So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 02:00:45


Post by: bash_bates


So, what really happened to all the primarchs? A few we know, some we assume, for example, Roboutte Guilliman sits in his shrine in his stasis field with these wounds right, who caused them, is he still technically alive etc? Of all the Primarchs who turned traitor, people seem to assume they are all Daemon Princes, that seems a bit weak to me. Forgive me I haven't read the Chaos Codex so am unaware if this sheds any more light.

So... in order...

1st Legion - Dark Angels - Lion El'Jonson

2nd Legion - Lost

3rd Legion - Emperors Children - Fulgrim - Possessed, turned into Daemon Prince

4th Legion - Iron Warriors - Perturabo

5th Legion - White Scars - Jaghatai Khan

6th Legion - Space Wolves - Leman Russ

7th Legion - Imperial Fists - Rogal Dorn

8th Legion - Night Lords - Konrad Curze/ Night Haunter - Allowed himself to be killed by a Calidus Assassin

9th Legion - Blood Angels - Sanguinus - Killed by Horus

10th Legion - Iron Hands - Ferrus Manus - Killed by Fulgrim/ Daemon Fulgrim becomes

11th Legion - Lost

12th Legion - World Eaters - Angron

13th Legion - Ultramarines - Rouboutte Guilliman

14th Legion - Death Guard - Mortarian

15th Legion - Thousand Sons - Magnus - Killed by Russ to save his legion, spirit resides in Eye of Terror

16th Legion - Luna Wolves - Horus - Killed by Emperor on his battlebarge in battle for Terra

17th Legion - Word Bearers - Lorgar

18th Legion - Salamanders - Vulkan

19th Legion - Raven Guard - Corax

20th Legion - Alpha Legion - Alpharius (Twins)



Feel free to fill in any blanks!!!


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 05:47:09


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


bash_bates wrote:So, what really happened to all the primarchs? A few we know, some we assume, for example, Roboutte Guilliman sits in his shrine in his stasis field with these wounds right, who caused them, is he still technically alive etc? Of all the Primarchs who turned traitor, people seem to assume they are all Daemon Princes, that seems a bit weak to me. Forgive me I haven't read the Chaos Codex so am unaware if this sheds any more light.

So... in order...

1st Legion - Dark Angels - Lion El'Jonson

2nd Legion - Lost

3rd Legion - Emperors Children - Fulgrim - Possessed, turned into Daemon Prince

4th Legion - Iron Warriors - Perturabo

5th Legion - White Scars - Jaghatai Khan

6th Legion - Space Wolves - Leman Russ

7th Legion - Imperial Fists - Rogal Dorn

8th Legion - Night Lords - Konrad Curze/ Night Haunter - Allowed himself to be killed by a Calidus Assassin

9th Legion - Blood Angels - Sanguinus - Killed by Horus

10th Legion - Iron Hands - Ferrus Manus - Killed by Fulgrim/ Daemon Fulgrim becomes

11th Legion - Lost

12th Legion - World Eaters - Angron

13th Legion - Ultramarines - Rouboutte Guilliman

14th Legion - Death Guard - Mortarian

15th Legion - Thousand Sons - Magnus - Killed by Russ to save his legion, spirit resides in Eye of Terror

16th Legion - Luna Wolves - Horus - Killed by Emperor on his battlebarge in battle for Terra

17th Legion - Word Bearers - Lorgar

18th Legion - Salamanders - Vulkan

19th Legion - Raven Guard - Corax

20th Legion - Alpha Legion - Alpharius (Twins)



Feel free to fill in any blanks!!!

Johnson is sleeping in the rock, lorgar is a deamon prince, corax went insane and flew into the eye of terror, vulkan disappeared, magnus is a deamon prince on the planet of sorcerers, guilliman got his throat slit by fulgrim, angron is a deamon prince of khorne and the only prince primarch still active in m41, Morty is a deamon prince and rules over the plague planet which is modeled off the original death guard home world, Dorn killed himself durring one of the black crusades and the imperial fists have his gauntlet in a shrine, Russ went off to find a way to bring back the emperor, the Khan went into the dark eldar city with about a thousand of his best warriors, and Perturabo is a deamon prince and rules over Menengrad (yes i spelled it wrong but eh). the only one that is not fully known is alpharius he may have been killed by Guilliman but maybe not


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 07:09:56


Post by: Carlovonsexron


Guilliman cot a poisoned wound from Fulgrim, and is in stasis right now - and supposedly is slowly getting better (as compared to the Emperor who is also in a form of stasis who is slowly dieing off more and more...)


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 07:41:33


Post by: Nitros14


Magnus wasn't killed, he escaped into the warp after Russ broke his back.

Russ went into the Eye of Terror and was never seen again.

Perturabo, Mortarion, Magnus, Angron and Lorgar are all Daemon Princes sitting on their Daemon Worlds doing god knows what.

Alpharius or Omegon was killed by Guilleman but the other Twin lives.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 07:45:14


Post by: Gwar!



http://wh40k.lexicanum.com/wiki/Primarch#Fate_of_the_Primarchs
Fate of the Primarchs
Traitors

* Warmaster Horus was killed by the Emperor of Mankind, and his soul was obliterated. His corpse was completely destroyed by Abaddon the Despoiler, who also took over his place as overall leader of the Chaos Space Marines.
* Magnus the Red rose to the rank of Daemon Prince of Tzeentch.
* Angron rose to the rank of of Daemon prince of Khorne.
* Mortarion rose the rank of Daemon Prince of Nurgle.
* Fulgrim rose to the rank of Daemon Prince of Slaanesh.
* Lorgar rose to the rank of Daemon Prince of Chaos Undivided.
* Perturabo rose to the rank of Daemon Prince of Chaos Undivided.
* Konrad Curze, aka Night Haunter, was assassinated by Callidus assassin M'Shen. He allowed her infiltration, apparently wanting to die.
* Alpharius was killed by Roboute Guilliman, but the source which reported his death may have been manipulated. It is not known if Alpharius or Omegon is the primarch killed in the report. Due to the report's unreliability, neither may have been killed.8.

Loyalists

* Ferrus Manus was killed at the Drop Site massacre at the start of the Horus Heresy by Fulgrim who presented his head to Horus.
* Sanguinius was slain by Horus after refusing to join him.
* Lion El'Jonson returned to his homeworld of Caliban only to discover that his friend and second-in command Luther and the Dark Angel garrison had turned against him2. He led a strike force of his own loyal Dark Angels against the traitors. He disappeared amongst the inferno as the world was blasted apart by a Warp Storm and a bombardment from his ships in orbit. He sleeps deep within the Rock, the biggest piece of Caliban and current home base of the Dark Angels1,2. Only the Emperor and the Watchers in the Dark know of this secret.1-p14
* Jaghatai Khan disappeared while pursuing Dark Eldar into a webway portal after they had managed to raid Mundus Planus. There are rumors that he fights there still, lost in the twisting paths of the Webway. After nine thousand years it seems highly unlikely, but not impossible.
* Leman Russ disappeared in the Eye of Terror. The Space Wolves hold a legend that says Russ went on a quest to find a means to cure the Emperor. His final words before his disappearance is that he would return for the Wolftime (the final battle). It is also said that Leman Russ led the 13th Company into the Eye of Terror and ordered them to hunt down the Traitor Legions which had fled to the Eye of Terror, particularly the Thousand Sons.
* Rogal Dorn boarded a Chaos cruiser during a Black Crusade alongside a company of his sons and died fighting. He died after many of his loyal brother Primarchs. Today, his hand is housed in the holiest shrine of the Imperial Fists chapter, and his dead body encased in amber and put in Phalanx 11.
* Roboute Guilliman was struck down with an envenomed blade by his former brother Fulgrim. His body is perfectly preserved in a stasis field at the heart of the Temple of Correction3. It is rumoured that he is still alive and that his wound is slowly healing, something normally impossible in a stasis field. The truth of this rumour is unknown but this is seen by many (including the Ultramarine captain Uriel Ventris) as mere optimistic thinking.
* Vulkan disappeared. The position of Chapter Master, filled by the Captain of the First Company, is considered to be a regency as the Salamanders believe that Vulkan will one day return and lead them on a great crusade against Chaos.
* Corax was racked by guilt and shame. In order to rebuild quickly the strength of his legion from the dropsite massacre on Isstvan V, Corax accelerated the growth of the gene-seed organs, producing more Space Marines, but this process also deteriorated the Gene-seed, causing many to become hulking monsters. Riddled with guilt over what he had done, Corax administered euthanasia to all of them and then locked himself away within his sanctum, the Raven's Tower. Exactly one year later he left his tower, haggard and gaunt, and took a small shuttle craft with the words Never more. It was last monitored setting a course for the Eye of Terror.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 16:31:01


Post by: bash_bates


Cheers for that! Could never find all of the information. Any chance of anyone coming back? Be nice to see some primarch models on the selves...


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 18:35:52


Post by: Partof1


I'd say they won't make Primarchs playable, as some, Magnus for examplle, could take down Titans, and oodles of the most powerful Space Marines single handedly. They're simply too powerful, and best left unattainable.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 18:39:52


Post by: Lexx


Partof1 wrote:I'd say they won't make Primarchs playable, as some, Magnus for examplle, could take down Titans, and oodles of the most powerful Space Marines single handedly. They're simply too powerful, and best left unattainable.


Agreed. Though I'd love it if Ferrus Manus had survived. He was my favorite Primarch .


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 18:57:50


Post by: Chowderhead


They are all dead, except for 7. 6 are Deamon Princes, and 1, Lion'El Johnson, my favorite, is in a coma over a floating base called The Rock. Also, apparently, Rouboute Guillman is healing. Maybe. So their either dead, deamon princes, or in comas.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 18:57:59


Post by: Chowderhead


They are all dead, except for 7. 6 are Deamon Princes, and 1, Lion'El Johnson, my favorite, is in a coma over a floating base called The Rock. Also, apparently, Rouboute Guillman is healing. Maybe. So their either dead, deamon princes, or in comas.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/13 18:57:59


Post by: Chowderhead


They are all dead, except for 7. 6 are Deamon Princes, and 1, Lion'El Johnson, my favorite, is in a coma over a floating base called The Rock. Also, apparently, Rouboute Guillman is healing. Maybe. So their either dead, deamon princes, or in comas.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/14 14:26:40


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


russ is alive.... as for primarch models, i can't see it happening at least not officially. though rules for them have been done, tempus fugitives made them well balanced but not unkillable


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/14 18:11:21


Post by: spamandchips


The people above me in this thread seem sure that primarchs like khan and corax are dead. Does anyone have anything to confirm/deny this?


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/14 18:25:05


Post by: Ghost in the Darkness


No they are simply MIA.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/19 09:55:49


Post by: Luna Havoc


TyraelVladinhurst wrote:russ is alive.... as for primarch models, i can't see it happening at least not officially. though rules for them have been done, tempus fugitives made them well balanced but not unkillable


they havent done a model for him, but angron is a playable daemon prince/primarch. granted its ni-impossible to field him but his does have his own stats and gear.


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Vulkan might have been lost at the dropsite massacre of Isstavan V, it was never really comfirmed.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/19 10:07:05


Post by: somecallmeJack


Luna Havoc wrote:
TyraelVladinhurst wrote:russ is alive.... as for primarch models, i can't see it happening at least not officially. though rules for them have been done, tempus fugitives made them well balanced but not unkillable


they havent done a model for him, but angron is a playable daemon prince/primarch. granted its ni-impossible to field him but his does have his own stats and gear.


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Vulkan might have been lost at the dropsite massacre of Isstavan V, it was never really comfirmed.


Where can I find the rules for Angron?


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 07:14:40


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


somecallmeJack wrote:
Luna Havoc wrote:
TyraelVladinhurst wrote:russ is alive.... as for primarch models, i can't see it happening at least not officially. though rules for them have been done, tempus fugitives made them well balanced but not unkillable


they havent done a model for him, but angron is a playable daemon prince/primarch. granted its ni-impossible to field him but his does have his own stats and gear.


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Vulkan might have been lost at the dropsite massacre of Isstavan V, it was never really comfirmed.


Where can I find the rules for Angron?

an old white dwarf


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 07:15:00


Post by: garret


chowderhead13 wrote:They are all dead, except for 7. 6 are Deamon Princes, and 1, Lion'El Johnson, my favorite, is in a coma over a floating base called The Rock. Also, apparently, Rouboute Guillman is healing. Maybe. So their either dead, deamon princes, or in comas.

Lies. Khan is still alive. Someday he will return and the white scars will be able to take on the whole ork species.
Then we turn our focus on the traiterous ultramarines.
Also vulkan will return when all artifacts return.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 15:36:27


Post by: oggers


What do they mean by Vulkan 'disappearing'?


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 16:01:36


Post by: FITZZ


This is a bit off the original topic,but does anyone else see the similarities between the Night Lords Primarch Konrad Curze and the Character of Colonel Kurtz in "Apocalypse Now"?



So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 16:02:54


Post by: Gwar!


FITZZ wrote: This is a bit off the original topic,but does anyone else see the similarities between the Night Lords Primarch Konrad Curze and the Character of Colonel Kurtz in "Apocalypse Now"?
I'm pretty sure Curze is just a Grimdark Batman.

GW aren't smart enough to do something subtle like that.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 16:15:11


Post by: FITZZ


Gwar! wrote:
FITZZ wrote: This is a bit off the original topic,but does anyone else see the similarities between the Night Lords Primarch Konrad Curze and the Character of Colonel Kurtz in "Apocalypse Now"?
I'm pretty sure Curze is just a Grimdark Batman.

GW aren't smart enough to do something subtle like that.


Your probably right Gwar.

The way both characters seemed to welcome their assains,seeing their deaths as proof of the truth of their convictions,along with "The Horror" both men had witnessed and participated in,may have been a bit beyond what GW would have thought of.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 16:21:04


Post by: reds8n


FITZZ wrote: This is a bit off the original topic,but does anyone else see the similarities between the Night Lords Primarch Konrad Curze and the Character of Colonel Kurtz in "Apocalypse Now"?



Yes. You'll note Kurtz was killed by Martin Sheen and the assassin who killed Curze was M'shen.

GW throw stuff like this in all the time.

Corax disappeared, interestingly the latest Imperial Armour book puts forward the idea that he might have secretly locked himself away in stasis, only to return when the Emperor has forgiven him for his failure to stop Horus' treachery.

Nevermore indeed eh ?!

This of course tallies with many of the Primarch myths ; the idea that they will return at some point in the future when all hope is lost/similar. It's a fairly common theme in mythology look at Arthurian legend and the like.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 16:25:25


Post by: Gwar!


Except in the case of Russ, he actually means to keep his word.

10k years kicking ass in the EoT while permanently blattered, naked and blue balled (don't forget, his armour was found in a Slaanesh temple ) make you damn sure to keep your word if it's the last thing that happens!


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 16:33:22


Post by: reds8n


..well the 13th company members who came back from the EoT have been quiet on the subject eh...

One of the more interesting theories I read.. literally years ago.. about Russ was that he had gone to try to return or restore or rescue The Lion's soul from the EoT. The "vision" he saw at his last feast being a message or a vision of/from The Lion.

It makes more sense than Russ simply buggering off for a scrap, him and The Lion having reconciled their differences by now of course and both of them somewhat distraught at their respective failures during the HH. Russ would keep the near disgrace of the Dark Angels secret, especially if he felt that he could rescue The Lion and restore him and his Legion to the Emperor's good graces.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 16:39:35


Post by: Gwar!


That is if you consider the Lion to be the Loyalist, which is not as clear cut as one would like.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 16:48:04


Post by: reds8n


Hmm... I would say the HH books have pretty much cleared that one up really.
The Lion's loyalty is very clear cut. He has his own ambition and schemes of course but, well, everyone in a position of that power and authority would/does of course.


..subject to what happens in the later books of course.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 16:57:21


Post by: Gwar!


Unless it's all Lies and Propaganda.

And Lies!


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 17:48:09


Post by: bash_bates


surely the lion had some idea of what caliban could be capable of. what did he expect luther to do in that position?


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/20 19:04:49


Post by: Ilkhan


It's easy to say that the missing Primarchs are just dead, but I really hope it's not the case. If 40k ever actually ends I think it should be with the missing Primarchs returning, to be joined by the healed Guilliman and a resurrected Emperor, only to have to hold the line against a full scale Chaos invasion headed by all the Daemon Prince Primarchs (and perhaps the Chaos Gods themselves), the full-scale rise of the Necrons, massive Waaghs and Hive Fleets, and the ascendant Ynnead, Eldar God of the Dead. This universe deserves to go out with the biggest bang imaginable.

I just don't know how the Tau could get in on the uberness.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/21 02:54:36


Post by: Henners91


Short answer:

If they're a loyalist, GW found a convenient way to get rid of them.

If they're a traitor, then it's more than likely than not that they're just itching their arses sitting on some backwater daemon-world doing nothing.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/21 04:48:33


Post by: Luna Havoc


TyraelVladinhurst wrote:
somecallmeJack wrote:
Luna Havoc wrote:
TyraelVladinhurst wrote:russ is alive.... as for primarch models, i can't see it happening at least not officially. though rules for them have been done, tempus fugitives made them well balanced but not unkillable


they havent done a model for him, but angron is a playable daemon prince/primarch. granted its ni-impossible to field him but his does have his own stats and gear.


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Vulkan might have been lost at the dropsite massacre of Isstavan V, it was never really comfirmed.


Where can I find the rules for Angron?

an old white dwarf


http://www.games-workshop.com/gws/content/article.jsp?community=&catId=cat1290027&categoryId=600005&aId=11600027
thats where its located under Battle for Armageddon


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/21 11:38:34


Post by: somecallmeJack


Nice one Luna Havoc. He seems a bit over-priced though!


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/21 15:39:31


Post by: Melissia


They all saw how much GW loved the ultramarines that they decided to ragequit.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/21 21:14:42


Post by: bash_bates


Ilkhan wrote:It's easy to say that the missing Primarchs are just dead, but I really hope it's not the case. If 40k ever actually ends I think it should be with the missing Primarchs returning, to be joined by the healed Guilliman and a resurrected Emperor, only to have to hold the line against a full scale Chaos invasion headed by all the Daemon Prince Primarchs (and perhaps the Chaos Gods themselves), the full-scale rise of the Necrons, massive Waaghs and Hive Fleets, and the ascendant Ynnead, Eldar God of the Dead. This universe deserves to go out with the biggest bang imaginable.

I just don't know how the Tau could get in on the uberness.


the tau would probably be the ones left over at the end to pick up the pieces!

either that or the grots will take over...


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/21 21:20:01


Post by: purplefood


oggers wrote:What do they mean by Vulkan 'disappearing'?


As in he is gone and no one knows where he is


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/21 21:22:41


Post by: Kogwar


CHeck here it also tells in detail what happened to most of them and also alot of them are said to be comign bakc in the End of day and yes i know they all have different names for that time but it is all the same it is mentioned in the sm fluff and the eldar fluff for the pheonix lords.
http://wh40k.lexicanum.com/wiki/Primarchs


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/27 08:56:05


Post by: Temujin


FITZZ wrote: This is a bit off the original topic,but does anyone else see the similarities between the Night Lords Primarch Konrad Curze and the Character of Colonel Kurtz in "Apocalypse Now"?



Apocalypse Now is based on Joseph Conrad's novel Heart of Darkness, which also had a character called Kurtz. I must admit I'd never realised that the assassin's name came from Martin Sheen.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/27 10:29:50


Post by: chub


All the Primarchs are dead, apart from the deamon prince ones and Guilliman. It said so in Codex Imperialis

"Although long lived, the Primarchs were not immortal and the last of their kind finally died after fourteen hundred years."

So there you have it, unless GW decide to rewrite their own fluff, and we all know that won't ever happen.....


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/27 12:39:49


Post by: Gwar!


chub wrote:All the Primarchs are dead, apart from the deamon prince ones and Guilliman. It said so in Codex Imperialis

"Although long lived, the Primarchs were not immortal and the last of their kind finally died after fourteen hundred years."

So there you have it, unless GW decide to rewrite their own fluff, and we all know that won't ever happen.....
You do realise that all fluff is written from someone viewpoint, and that all of it is bias in one way or another and that there is not one single piece of fluff in a 3rd person omnipotent view?


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/27 13:07:00


Post by: Lord of battles


Vulkan went out for smokes but never came back/


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/27 13:16:15


Post by: Temujin


Gwar! wrote: ...there is not one single piece of fluff in a 3rd person omnipotent view?


We have some lines written from the perspectives of beings who might well be near omnipotent, albeit perhaps not so trustworthy.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/27 15:45:10


Post by: chub


Gwar! wrote:
chub wrote:All the Primarchs are dead, apart from the deamon prince ones and Guilliman. It said so in Codex Imperialis

"Although long lived, the Primarchs were not immortal and the last of their kind finally died after fourteen hundred years."

So there you have it, unless GW decide to rewrite their own fluff, and we all know that won't ever happen.....
You do realise that all fluff is written from someone viewpoint, and that all of it is bias in one way or another and that there is not one single piece of fluff in a 3rd person omnipotent view?


Actually I wasnt aware, but that is hardly suprising as I dont pay much attention to it. I only posted the comment I made as I thought I remembered seeing it all those years ago, and a quick flick through found it.
Also Codex Imperialis doesnt read like a point of view more like a sourcebook which it is, being a part of 2nd editions core rule books


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/27 16:05:11


Post by: Gwar!


chub wrote:Also Codex Imperialis doesnt read like a point of view more like a sourcebook which it is, being a part of 2nd editions core rule books
The name kind of gives you a hint, don't ya think?


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/27 16:22:01


Post by: DEUS VULT


Lord of battles wrote:Vulkan went out for smokes but never came back/


He does that to all his families. Last time it was for a gallon of milk. What a deadbeat.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/06/27 16:25:26


Post by: chub


@ GWAR Didnt really think about that, Dont really care either, fluff is fluff and as far as I am concerned is 99% of the time totally needless


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/07 09:41:52


Post by: bash_bates


Fluff adds that extra depth to the game. It's one of the reasons my interest has been kept for so long. Fluff is important as it explains WHY legions/ chapters/ alien races act the way the do. Without the fluff it would just be a bunch of races with no background fighting for the sake of fighting. These forums would be bland had there not been any fluff to debate/ reasons to convert models. Without the fluff there is no 40K. Simples.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/07 20:21:12


Post by: chub


bash_bates wrote:Fluff adds that extra depth to the game. It's one of the reasons my interest has been kept for so long. Fluff is important as it explains WHY legions/ chapters/ alien races act the way the do. Without the fluff it would just be a bunch of races with no background fighting for the sake of fighting. These forums would be bland had there not been any fluff to debate/ reasons to convert models. Without the fluff there is no 40K. Simples.

Yet it means nothing to me when I play a game I am just pushing miniatures around a board and rolling dice, to me the game is all about the social interaction, I could just as easily be playing chess except I am not smart enough. Dont get me wrong Ive read dozens and dozens of BL novels but I enjoy them for what they are just 'Pulp Fiction' stories,they have no bearing on what I play or how I play. I also understand there are many out there who like yourself are kept interested by the fluff and even I have to admit I can get sucked into their excitement when I play against someone that enthusiastic.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/20 08:33:31


Post by: bash_bates


It can be infectious. The fluff doesn't effect how the game is played so much, but can change how the army is collected and structured. So does it have a knock on effect into how the games played? Maybe.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/20 10:31:59


Post by: Sgt.Roadkill


chub wrote:@ GWAR Didnt really think about that, Dont really care either, fluff is fluff and as far as I am concerned is 99% of the time totally needless


then why are you posting in the fluff section of this website?


anyhoo pretty much everythign has been said in regards to this HOWEVER

there were models for some of the primarch remember. 40k you had leman Russ and Robute Guilliman (SP for all) and in Epic You had Fulgrim and Angron IIRC, they were the size of titans. I think there may have been more but i can't remember.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/20 10:48:16


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


Sgt.Roadkill wrote:
chub wrote:@ GWAR Didnt really think about that, Dont really care either, fluff is fluff and as far as I am concerned is 99% of the time totally needless


then why are you posting in the fluff section of this website?


anyhoo pretty much everythign has been said in regards to this HOWEVER

there were models for some of the primarch remember. 40k you had leman Russ and Robute Guilliman (SP for all) and in Epic You had Fulgrim and Angron IIRC, they were the size of titans. I think there may have been more but i can't remember.

morty and magnus as well


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/20 15:31:25


Post by: Alpharius


Starting to get slightly uncivil in this thread.

Lets endeavor to keep things in check.

And yes, it probably isn't the smartest tactical decision to come into the Background Forum and post in a thread on the Primarchs if you really don't care about the Background.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/20 18:28:32


Post by: chub


Alpharius wrote:Starting to get slightly uncivil in this thread.

Lets endeavor to keep things in check.

And yes, it probably isn't the smartest tactical decision to come into the Background Forum and post in a thread on the Primarchs if you really don't care about the Background.


Sorry I dont often post in the fluff side of things, only on this occasion I thoughyt I had information that was relevant.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/20 21:10:34


Post by: bash_bates


Has anyone found any pictures of the Epic models???


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/20 21:48:07


Post by: Alpharius


Magnus the Red:



Mortarion:



Angron:



Fulgrim:





So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/20 22:01:56


Post by: Retribution


Melissia wrote:They all saw how much GW loved the ultramarines that they decided to ragequit.

Haha


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/21 04:21:41


Post by: Kogwar


chub wrote:All the Primarchs are dead, apart from the deamon prince ones and Guilliman. It said so in Codex Imperialis

"Although long lived, the Primarchs were not immortal and the last of their kind finally died after fourteen hundred years."

So there you have it, unless GW decide to rewrite their own fluff, and we all know that won't ever happen.....


Also Lion is still alive in the rock




So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/21 04:39:38


Post by: Gwar!


And Russ is still alive in the EoT, getting phenomenally drunk.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/21 04:48:52


Post by: SonofTerra


Dont forget that Alpharius and/or Omegon are still alive as well.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/21 08:51:17


Post by: tallshortguy


I remember reading somewhere of rumors that Russ was spotted along with the 13th Company during the 13th Black Crusade.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/21 12:00:21


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


tallshortguy wrote:I remember reading somewhere of rumors that Russ was spotted along with the 13th Company during the 13th Black Crusade.

he was according to the old EOT website


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/21 12:57:56


Post by: Brutii11


I know that Vulkan is meant to return once the Salamanders find all of his lost equipment.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/21 15:17:49


Post by: bash_bates


And the Salamanders quest could go on forever.... The epic models look massive compared to normal troops, were they any good in the game, I mean Magnus for example can take down a titan using mind bullets...

Ta for the pics btw!


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/21 21:29:03


Post by: Alpharius


TyraelVladinhurst wrote:
tallshortguy wrote:I remember reading somewhere of rumors that Russ was spotted along with the 13th Company during the 13th Black Crusade.

he was according to the old EOT website


Seriously?

Anyone have this quote/piece of fiction saved?

I'd love to read it!


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/21 21:40:21


Post by: KamikazeCanuck


Brutii11 wrote:I know that Vulkan is meant to return once the Salamanders find all of his lost equipment.


What? That lazy sonuva can't get his own stuff?


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/22 16:39:33


Post by: daedalus-templarius


Those Epic models are pretty hilarious looking.

Hopefully 6th edition will herald the return of Russ or some other Primarch just in time for a Black Crusade to break Cadia and the Golden Throne to fail...

or some other way to advance the background


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/22 16:55:19


Post by: Alpharius


daedalus-templarius wrote:Those Epic models are pretty hilarious looking.

Hopefully 6th edition will herald the return of Russ or some other Primarch just in time for a Black Crusade to break Cadia and the Golden Throne to fail...

or some other way to advance the background


You, me and just about everyone else would LOVE for the background to advance!

The Emperor dies - but is reborn!

But many don't believe, or choose to not believe, jealous of their own power base!

Civil unrest - CIVIL WAR!

Ultramar becomes the seat of the reborn Emperor's power - and base for a new Great Crusade!

Roboute Guilliman emerges from statis - healed!

The Great Khan, Corax and Russ - return!

Chaos breaks through Cadia!

The Tau and the Necrons are completely wiped out and never return, given that all they really were was a bad pandering attempt at drawing in the anime and 'Terminator Movie Fan' crowds!

Rejoice!

Never happen though...



So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/22 17:01:00


Post by: DEATH89


Alpharius wrote:
daedalus-templarius wrote:Those Epic models are pretty hilarious looking.

Hopefully 6th edition will herald the return of Russ or some other Primarch just in time for a Black Crusade to break Cadia and the Golden Throne to fail...

or some other way to advance the background


You, me and just about everyone else would LOVE for the background to advance!

The Emperor dies - but is reborn!

But many don't believe, or choose to not believe, jealous of their own power base!

Civil unrest - CIVIL WAR!

Ultramar becomes the seat of the reborn Emperor's power - and base for a new Great Crusade!

Roboute Guilliman emerges from statis - healed!

The Great Khan, Corax and Russ - return!

Chaos breaks through Cadia!

The Tau and the Necrons are completely wiped out and never return, given that all they really were was a bad pandering attempt at drawing in the anime and 'Terminator Movie Fan' crowds!

Rejoice!

Never happen though...



You forgot that Cypher exposes Azrael as Luther and the Emp casts the DA out and re-unites the fallen under Cypher and the Lion is freed from his cell in the rock for some much needed psycho-therapy


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/22 17:18:09


Post by: KamikazeCanuck


no, no no. 'Nids simply eat everything!


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/22 18:24:14


Post by: Alpharius


DEATH89 wrote:
You forgot that Cypher exposes Azrael as Luther and the Emp casts the DA out and re-unites the fallen under Cypher and the Lion is freed from his cell in the rock for some much needed psycho-therapy


OK, I did forget that!

But really, I can't remember everything!

Can I?


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/22 18:38:33


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


also forgot Dorn coming back as they never found his body


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/22 18:57:09


Post by: KamikazeCanuck


Alpharius wrote:
DEATH89 wrote:
You forgot that Cypher exposes Azrael as Luther and the Emp casts the DA out and re-unites the fallen under Cypher and the Lion is freed from his cell in the rock for some much needed psycho-therapy


OK, I did forget that!

But really, I can't remember everything!

Can I?


What!?! Azrael is Luther? Luther is The Lion!? Cypher is Cypher!? By the Emprah!


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/22 18:59:04


Post by: LordWynne


I got figures of Angron, Mortarion, Magnus and Fulgrim from the Epic game and at times run them as Chaos Lords looks pretty cool.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/22 19:22:16


Post by: Alpharius


You might want to check page 2 of this very thread...


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/23 06:18:11


Post by: SanguinaryGuard


Leman Russ went into the Warp to chase the TS CSM Chapter and took only his retinue with him, leaving behind Bjorn the Fell Handed to watch over the Chapter


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/23 06:34:23


Post by: del'Vhar


Is there any actual fluff on how long a Space Marine can live?
Obviously they dont die from old age because they are fighting constantly, but how long can they last if they dont die in combat?
I would assume primarchs could last even longer than a normal Astartes, but I havent heard anything about an actual life span.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/23 06:45:36


Post by: SanguinaryGuard


I think they are pretty much invincible outside of combat. They do a number of procedures to alter the body of a SM to make it resilient to poisonous gases and all that


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/23 08:18:42


Post by: Ryan4tor


AH! I mixed them up. Oopse. haha. Ferrus Manus was dead. Vulkan is missing, yeah.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/24 19:00:15


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


del'Vhar wrote:Is there any actual fluff on how long a Space Marine can live?
Obviously they dont die from old age because they are fighting constantly, but how long can they last if they dont die in combat?
I would assume primarchs could last even longer than a normal Astartes, but I havent heard anything about an actual life span.

marines are immortal, as are primarch's but they tend to die in combat


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/24 20:26:59


Post by: Henners91


Marines aren't immortal Tyrael, take old Dreadnoughts like Bjorn... they are only rarely woken up because they're starting to slow down.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/25 01:26:24


Post by: Orangebandguy


Gwar! wrote:
FITZZ wrote: This is a bit off the original topic,but does anyone else see the similarities between the Night Lords Primarch Konrad Curze and the Character of Colonel Kurtz in "Apocalypse Now"?
I'm pretty sure Curze is just a Grimdark Batman.

GW aren't smart enough to do something subtle like that.


It's a reference.

Corax saying "nevermore" is a direct reference to a famous poem called "The Raven" which was parodied in The Simpsons.

Lion El'Jonson is a reference to a poet called Lionel Johnson who wrote a poem called the Dark Angel.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/25 02:13:16


Post by: AgeOfEgos


If they came back though, who's going to babysit?






KHHHHHHHAAAAAAANNNNNN is the one I would like to see back but then again I play Scars...




So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/25 02:16:49


Post by: Asherian Command


Vulkan made me laugh so hard.
Vulkan and Gulliman would bring the imperium back to its Full glory.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/25 02:27:08


Post by: Kurb


Sanguinus
lives in the very blood of each Blood Angel


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/25 03:13:52


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


Henners91 wrote:Marines aren't immortal Tyrael, take old Dreadnoughts like Bjorn... they are only rarely woken up because they're starting to slow down.

HH books say otherwise


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/25 03:16:47


Post by: DEUS VULT


TyraelVladinhurst wrote:
Henners91 wrote:Marines aren't immortal Tyrael, take old Dreadnoughts like Bjorn... they are only rarely woken up because they're starting to slow down.

HH books say otherwise

Thats cause Marines still had that new-power armour smell on em at that point. The books actually say something along the lines of "as far as they knew, Marines are immortal"


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/25 03:26:01


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


lol, good point and with GW always changing the backround i've got $5 says with 6th ed codex marines all marines get a 6+ invulnerable save


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/25 08:46:18


Post by: shrike


TyraelVladinhurst wrote:
bash_bates wrote:So, what really happened to all the primarchs? A few we know, some we assume, for example, Roboutte Guilliman sits in his shrine in his stasis field with these wounds right, who caused them, is he still technically alive etc? Of all the Primarchs who turned traitor, people seem to assume they are all Daemon Princes, that seems a bit weak to me. Forgive me I haven't read the Chaos Codex so am unaware if this sheds any more light.

So... in order...

1st Legion - Dark Angels - Lion El'Jonson

2nd Legion - Lost

3rd Legion - Emperors Children - Fulgrim - Possessed, turned into Daemon Prince

4th Legion - Iron Warriors - Perturabo

5th Legion - White Scars - Jaghatai Khan

6th Legion - Space Wolves - Leman Russ

7th Legion - Imperial Fists - Rogal Dorn

8th Legion - Night Lords - Konrad Curze/ Night Haunter - Allowed himself to be killed by a Calidus Assassin

9th Legion - Blood Angels - Sanguinus - Killed by Horus

10th Legion - Iron Hands - Ferrus Manus - Killed by Fulgrim/ Daemon Fulgrim becomes

11th Legion - Lost

12th Legion - World Eaters - Angron

13th Legion - Ultramarines - Rouboutte Guilliman

14th Legion - Death Guard - Mortarian

15th Legion - Thousand Sons - Magnus - Killed by Russ to save his legion, spirit resides in Eye of Terror

16th Legion - Luna Wolves - Horus - Killed by Emperor on his battlebarge in battle for Terra

17th Legion - Word Bearers - Lorgar

18th Legion - Salamanders - Vulkan

19th Legion - Raven Guard - Corax

20th Legion - Alpha Legion - Alpharius (Twins)



Feel free to fill in any blanks!!!

Johnson is sleeping in the rock, lorgar is a deamon prince, corax went insane and flew into the eye of terror, vulkan disappeared, magnus is a deamon prince on the planet of sorcerers, guilliman got his throat slit by fulgrim, angron is a deamon prince of khorne and the only prince primarch still active in m41, Morty is a deamon prince and rules over the plague planet which is modeled off the original death guard home world, Dorn killed himself durring one of the black crusades and the imperial fists have his gauntlet in a shrine, Russ went off to find a way to bring back the emperor, the Khan went into the dark eldar city with about a thousand of his best warriors, and Perturabo is a deamon prince and rules over Menengrad (yes i spelled it wrong but eh). the only one that is not fully known is alpharius he may have been killed by Guilliman but maybe not

Didn't, Corax get killed by Perturabo in the audiobook raven's flight?


Automatically Appended Next Post:
AgeOfEgos wrote:If they came back though, who's going to babysit?






KHHHHHHHAAAAAAANNNNNN is the one I would like to see back but then again I play Scars...



why the f*** is Corax looking at porn?!

Anyway- if you listen to raven's flight, Corax is basically a ninja- in chapter's due, even normal raven guards and even techmarines can simply stand there, and even Telion doesn't notice them- Imagine what Corax can do- he brazenly walks straight past other marines and they didn't notice him!


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/25 09:16:30


Post by: TyraelVladinhurst


no he didn't, Corax is alive... sorta


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/26 06:07:01


Post by: Kogwar


he went into the eye of terror and also Konrad is much stealthier listen to dark king also alph legion they sneak past everything.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/28 00:05:05


Post by: Laughing God


As to SM being immortal they are not, as explained in Salamander...
Spoiler:
In salamander there is an entombed SM that they find from the Great crusade. He'd been alive for 10000 years down there in his power armor. But he was so old and had been sitting there for so long that if they tried to move im he would die. So this would suggest SM do age, but without combat can live over 10000 years


As for ferrus mannus being dead, were is his body? I know his head got cut off but didnt he have Necrometal arms? WERES HIS WBB ROLL!?


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/28 00:07:08


Post by: Lexx


Laughing God wrote:As to SM being immortal they are not, as explained in Salamander...
Spoiler:
In salamander there is an entombed SM that they find from the Great crusade. He'd been alive for 10000 years down there in his power armor. But he was so old and had been sitting there for so long that if they tried to move im he would die. So this would suggest SM do age, but without combat can live over 10000 years


As for ferrus mannus being dead, were is his body? I know his head got cut off but didnt he have Necrometal arms? WERES HIS WBB ROLL!?


Heres hoping hes on mars recuperating .


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/28 00:12:04


Post by: SoloFalcon1138


TyraelVladinhurst wrote:russ is alive.... as for primarch models, i can't see it happening at least not officially. though rules for them have been done, tempus fugitives made them well balanced but not unkillable


Games Workshop *did* make a Leman Russ mini, it came with two wolves, like the picture from 2nd edition.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/07/28 02:16:35


Post by: Kogwar


ohh post i link i would love to see it.


So, what happened to all the Primarchs? @ 2010/08/01 03:55:08


Post by: Azariah Kyras


Doesn't the fluff imply that Guilleman may not have even killed Alpharius or Omegon, considering that all of the members of the Alpha Legion call themselves Alpharius?