Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Sorry guys no pregame show, let's just get to the action, GW's finest rule-writers, sculptors, fluff-writers and so on

The rules: Each item starts with 10 points. Copy the list into your reply and make a "vote" by either adding or subtracting one point from a single selection. When a selection reaches "0" it is out of the game. You may not vote again until four other posters have voted after you, or two hours have passed without any valid votes from anyone (not any posts, any votes).

Andy Chambers 10

Brian Nelson 10

Bryan Ansell 10

Dan Abnet 10

Frank Herbert 10

Gav Thorpe 10

Ian Watson 10

Jack Yeovil 10

Jervis Johnson 10

Jes Goodwin 10

John Blanche 10

JRR Tolkein 10

Mark Copplestone 10

Michael Moorcock 10

Perry Brothers 10

Rick Priestley 10

Space McQuirk 10

The Fat Bloke 10

Trish Morrison 10

Tuomas Pirninen 10

 

Andy Chambers 11+
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 10
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 10
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 10
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 11
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 10
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 10
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11+
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 11
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 10
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 10
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11+
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 11
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 10
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 10
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10 -
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 11
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 10
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 10
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11+
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10-
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 10
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 10
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10 *corrected as balzac's vote is invalid*
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 9-
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 10
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Gav has got to go, and go early

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 9
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 9- (His kid has too much influence)
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

who is the fat bloke?

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 9
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 8- (His kid has too much influence)
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 9
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 8
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11+
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Not sure that I agree that my last vote was invalid...depends on what Kyoto meant in the wording of his rules.  Other Survivor games I have seen allow you to vote after two hours have passed.  Is this one different?  (and,  I agree, the way Kyoto has worded it, it would appear to be so)

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 9
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 7-
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 10
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

@Balzac, Kyoto's rules are pretty clear and you violated them.

I'm not sure what Balzac's question is, there were 4 votes between his previous and latest vote. So it looks fine to me.

Anyway...

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 9
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 7
Jes Goodwin 10
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9-
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

He stole all his ideas from Dragonlance.

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 9
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 7
Jes Goodwin 11 +
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Kyoto, the question arose from my first two posts, not the second and third ones.  Apparently, I misread the rules.

My question was regarding the two hour rule. As I read it, you can "vote" again after two hours, but only if no one else has voted at all in that time. If even one person votes within two hours of your first vote, you can't vote again until three more votes have follwed that person's. Is this correct?

If it is, someone else needs to hurry up and vote, so I can again

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 9
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 6-
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 8-
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 6
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

the vote was invalid due to there only being one post between two of balzac's. It went (on 6/18/07) balzac at 0810 hours, keichi246 at 1005 hours and then balzac again at 1018 hours.

One post between instead of four and only 13 minutes between valid votes instead of 2 hours.

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 8
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 5-
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Two Hours

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 7-
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 5
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 11
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 7
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 5
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10-
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 7
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 4-
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 10
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 7
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 5+
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Survivor needs a fanboy.

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 11+
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 7
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 5
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

@D.I.G. Ahhh, okay. Apparently, after misreading the rules, I then misread them differently the second time ... ")

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 11
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 6-
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 5
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Two Hours

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 11
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 5-
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 5
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 11
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 5
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 4-
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 9
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 11
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 5
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 4
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 8-
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 11
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 5
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 4
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 8
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 9-
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10

Andy Chambers 10
Brian Nelson 10
Bryan Ansell 10
Dan Abnet 11
Frank Herbert 10
Gav Thorpe 5
Ian Watson 10
Jack Yeovil 10
Jervis Johnson 4
Jes Goodwin 11
John Blanche 10
JRR Tolkein 8
Mark Copplestone 10
Michael Moorcock 10+
Perry Brothers 10
Rick Priestley 10
Space McQuirk 10
The Fat Bloke 11
Trish Morrison 10
Tuomas Pirninen 10