Switch Theme:

Micro Art's Iron Brotherhood review  [RSS] Share on facebook Share on Twitter Submit to Reddit
»
Author Message
Advert


Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you:
  • No adverts like this in the forums anymore.
  • Times and dates in your local timezone.
  • Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance.
  • Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely.
  • Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net.
If you are already a member then feel free to login now.




Made in gb
Sagitarius with a Big F'in Gun






Review of Micro Art studios Iron Brotherhood

Placing an order and P&P
I ordered ten of the Iron Brotherhood along with a grovelling servant and a big ol' tech base. The webshop has a pretty user-friendly interface, and I liked the currency conversion service – very useful. The shop allows money to be sent through Paypal, which I appreciated – it gives a nice element of insurance that I always appreciate when ordering from a shop for the first time. Call me cowardly!

There was quite a delay in receiving the package, but I think that's more due to the transfer between the Polish and British postal services than any fault on Microart's part. I would note that communication was good – my e-mails were answered within a day or two, and in polite and clear English. The staff were very helpful, though I'd recommend they get one person to sort things out – I think I was corresponding with about half-a-dozen people!

The parcel took a month to arrive. This is worth noting – even though my order was delayed due to postal hoo-has, the delivery will probably take quite a long time (though chime in if you received yours quickly!).

That said, it was nicely packaged and secured, with plenty of polystyrene chips keeping everything safe and sound:


The models
The Iron Brotherhood come as three-part models; the main body and two separate arms. There are five different designs of bodies, of which I received an even selection – while they are listed as randomly picked, it looks like some kind soul makes sure you don't end up with loads of the same one.
Here are some front and back pictures of the bodies, showing one of each design.



The designs are fairly similar to one another; varying mainly in the tubing and details, but I like this relative uniformity. Others might want to make some alterations.

Note that these are virtually untouched – the casting is exceptionally clean, with little or no mouldlines or flash. The resin is high quality, and has held the detail well. It is fairly tough to work with, being dense and resistant. This is both good and bad – they don't lend themselves to easy conversion, but they are pretty tough; well able to stand up to the rigours of gaming.

Some of the bodies I received had a large 'plug' of resin attached to the bottom, nearly the same size as the model itself! This was easily removed with a large pair of clippers and then cleaned with a knife.

The arms were supplied in a separate tissue paper package, secured with tape. This is presumably to keep them all together and safe during shipping. There are two designs – a claw and a rifle/pointy thing.


Once opened, you see these:

I wasn't so impressed with the arms as I was the bodies. As you can see, there's a lot of flash on these – though they do clean up well.

Here's my first gripe about these models – the arms don't fit into the sockets very well at all. Not only are the shoulder ends of the arms a bit lumpy and ill-defined, but the undercut socket of the torso gets a little clogged up with resin, and it's hard to clean out well. It took quite a bit of work to clear this out to dry-fit the arms, and they looked a little too long to me. I'd recommend trimming the arms to get them to fit more naturally.

This is made fairly difficult by the toughness/brittleness of the resin – I had quite a job getting a clean cut without really forcing it; and I'd be wary of snapping it in the wrong part, since there's no way of getting spares.

Of course, the toughness of the resin makes it great if you're happy with the basic poses: the only bits that are easy to remove is the flash!

Here's a piccy of the grovelling menial:

A fun little model that'll fit right in with the Adeptus Mechanicus. I didn't like the fact it's a random selection (I'd rather have picked one for the cost), but they're all nice sculpts, so I'd have to be a bit miserable if I called this a real gripe. Based on the selection of Iron Brotherhood models I got, I'd anticipate the nice people at Micro Arts picking out a broad selection.

Cost
Here's my second gripe. They are nice models, but for the price I'm paying (equivalent to Forgeworld prices), I'd expect a little more. I think dropping the price by even a small amount would lead to a lot more people to buying these – in my personal experience I know three people who love the models, but were put off by the price.

Versatility:
These models are fantastic in terms of compatibility with other materials: there's plenty of space on the models to add all sorts of fun bits: here's an example with a GW metal servoarm and a set of FW resin arms to show you how well they combine with other sets.



Painting
I've only just got around to starting to paint mine, so no painted piccies yet, I'm afraid. That said, there seems to be little or no release agent (I gave mine a quick bath in warm soapy water just in case) and they primer well (I used Halford's black car primer). I've applied Citadel colour paints, and they're sitting well so far.

Notes
Hortwerth is sculpting some larger, elite versions of the Iron Brotherhood, so the range is set to expand (they look great so far!). This is worth bearing in mind if you're thinking of investing in an army.

Conclusion
Overall, I'm very happy with my purchase. The Iron Brotherhood are high quality resin figures that will stand up to a lifetime's gaming, and I'm happy to recommend them to other gamers. The menial is a fun little extra that would work well in an Inquisitorial force for 40k, or as a wound marker/civilian in other games. He might even fit into a Warmachine Menoth force.

I've docked a couple of points for the price (realistically, they're too expensive to make a complete army, unless you're very wealthy) and the problems I had with the arms.

Overall, I'd say they're absolutely ideal for a showcase squad or two.

8/10 mechadendrites up.

LINK TO IRON BROTHERHOOD:
http://www.shop.microartstudio.com/iron-brotherhood-http05-p-147.html

This message was edited 3 times. Last update was at 2008/02/29 11:51:58


 
   
Made in gb
Sagitarius with a Big F'in Gun






For those interested, here's a size comparison of an Iron Brother next to a skitarius converted from a Bretonnian Men-at-Arms:



   
Made in us
Regular Dakkanaut




Webway

Excellent review. Now I just hope GW won't pull a copyright infringment of Adeptus Mechanicus out of their legal pocket...

: : www.stephane.info : :
"It's better to enlarge the game than to restrict the players" -- Eric Wujcik 
   
Made in us
Omnipotent Lord of Change





Albany, NY

Thanks for the review Saint, I've been interested in these guys for a while now. Might be passing on them for the $$$ involved - and lack of needing another army right now - but very happy to have an indepth look at them

- Salvage

KOW BATREPS: BLOODFIRE
INSTAGRAM: @boss_salvage 
   
Made in be
Bonkers Buggy Driver with Rockets



Right behind you...

I also bought 10 of the Iron Brotherhood, a couple of the servants and some tech bases from MicroArt. I really like the models although I only got two different poses (5 of each) so a bit disappointed there. Also agree with the very small mold lines- that part is nice. But I have numerous (virutally all) models with air bubbles all over the detail. For instance, the bolts, hoses and mechadendrites almost all needed to have greenstuff repair/filling- this was very disappointing. The arms also had a LOT of air bubbles- none of them were nearly as good as the ones that the OP showed in his picture. All that being said, I am still mostly happy with them despite the relatively high price. The obsequeous servants were nice models and they indeed do fit in really well with the AM theme. The tech bases are nice although they don't lie flat. They arrived sanded/flat on the bottom, which is nice, but they aren't level so the models will lean a bit if mounted vertical to the base top.

My shipping time was about 3 weeks (within Eurpoe) but the communication was excellent and I really had no worries due to their use of Paypal.

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2008/03/04 15:52:49


Armies in my closet:  
   
Made in be
Bonkers Buggy Driver with Rockets



Right behind you...

Kotrin wrote:Excellent review. Now I just hope GW won't pull a copyright infringment of Adeptus Mechanicus out of their legal pocket...


Agree. But I don't see anything GW could possibly use as a basis for IP infringement. The 'cog' on the shoulder does not even have a skull in it.

I am eagerly awaiting the next sculpts (Seraphim-type elites he said).

Armies in my closet:  
   
Made in gb
Sagitarius with a Big F'in Gun






There's a sneak preview and discussion of the Skitarii elites Hortwerth has been working on at the Adeptus Mechanicus forums here:
http://z6.invisionfree.com/adeptusmechanicus/index.php?showtopic=95
   
Made in us
RogueSangre





The Cockatrice Malediction

Beast wrote:Agree. But I don't see anything GW could possibly use as a basis for IP infringement. The 'cog' on the shoulder does not even have a skull in it.

Does it matter? They can just send a Cease & Desist and let fear do the rest. Who's got the money to take them to court to determine the merit of their claim? It's always better to be rich than right.
   
Made in in
[MOD]
Otiose in a Niche






Hyderabad, India

I like the stuff, makes me regret scrapping my plans for an Adeptus Mech army (using lost and damned rules so I didn't really have a choice in the matter).

But I think micro arts and its fans should beware of remarks like this:

"They're intended to represent Skitarii elites. I'm not entirely sure what stage they're at now, but it can't hurt to circulate the image to see if it stirs any interest – maybe Micro Arts will sit up and take notice if there's enough! "

As I understand trademark law that's a pretty big violation. Once you start using GW-trademarked terms like Genestealer, Ultramarine, Adeptus Mech, or Skitarii, whether or not your stuff is a copy of theirs (violation of copyright) it is a violation of their trademark. The same as if I sell my own tee shirts as Nike.

that being said, good stuff.

 
   
Made in gb
Sagitarius with a Big F'in Gun






Kid_Kyoto wrote:I think micro arts and its fans should beware of remarks like this:

"They're intended to represent Skitarii elites. I'm not entirely sure what stage they're at now, but it can't hurt to circulate the image to see if it stirs any interest – maybe Micro Arts will sit up and take notice if there's enough! "

As I understand trademark law that's a pretty big violation. Once you start using GW-trademarked terms like Genestealer, Ultramarine, Adeptus Mech, or Skitarii, whether or not your stuff is a copy of theirs (violation of copyright) it is a violation of their trademark.


Ah, my apologies for that – bit of a misunderstanding caused by my poor quoting. It ought to be pointed out that at no point have Micro Art or the original sculptor given any indication that the original sculpts or these WIP ones are intended to be used as Adeptus Mechanicus, merely robed cyborgs.

My statement 'They're intended to represent Skitarii elites' is a bit of a mistake – it should read 'I intend to use them to represent skitarii elites after a bit of conversion work.'

That said, I think you'll agree that they do look cool as Adeptus Mechanicus once they're converted a little and painted in red!
   
Made in in
[MOD]
Otiose in a Niche






Hyderabad, India

Cpl_Saint wrote:

Ah, my apologies for that – bit of a misunderstanding caused by my poor quoting. It ought to be pointed out that at no point have Micro Art or the original sculptor given any indication that the original sculpts or these WIP ones are intended to be used as Adeptus Mechanicus, merely robed cyborgs.

My statement 'They're intended to represent Skitarii elites' is a bit of a mistake – it should read 'I intend to use them to represent skitarii elites after a bit of conversion work.'

That said, I think you'll agree that they do look cool as Adeptus Mechanicus once they're converted a little and painted in red!


Sorry if I was singling you out, thanks for the review.

 
   
Made in ca
Fixture of Dakka




Canada

mmmmmm I liked them waaay back when the popped up as fresh sculpts on a few forums, and these shots of the raw resin only confirm that they're cool beans

I'd appreciate a scale shot with a space marine and guardsman if that's possible

"Nothing from the outside world can be imported into Canada without first being doused in ranch dressing. Canadian Techs have found that while this makes the internet delicious it tends to hamper the bandwidth potential. Scientists are working furiously to rectify the problem. "

--Glaive Company CO 
   
 
Forum Index » News & Rumors
Go to: