Yeah I know according to the
SW fluff there was genetic instability making the first successor chapter a failure yadda yadda (the Blood Angels don't seem to stop trying though) and the harsh Fenrisian climate likely keeps the population of worthy aspirants low... but one nice thing about the general
40k fluff is that it leaves a LOT of room for personal invention.
If you look at just general
40k history there were many periods of near chaos, over-thrown leadership and experimentation in the Imperium and it's great armies. At any given point the old or new High Lords of Terra could have attempted the creation of a new
SW successor given maybe a boom in population on the planet due to a period of climate stability. Your army could also just be a 'Great Company' that changed it's colors and heraldry after some significant event in their up-start history. In the
SW codex you already have Bran
Redmaw's company and the Gunnar
Red Moon company - either of which could have easily justified going 'red'.
Automatically Appended Next Post: Harms66 I just sent you a
PM.