ShumaGorath wrote:We had a talk a bit ago about the failure of democracy in the united states. Remember that?
Most of these things have come up before on this site. That keep coming up again and again, in part because new members raise them, and in part because the usual suspects keep pretending they don't know how something really works.
Mind you, we haven't had a gold standard thread in a while. Maybe that's one issue we finally managed to kill for good.
Automatically Appended Next Post: Aerethan wrote:In Australia it is illegal to not vote. We need this law.
I've argued for how well this works in Australia for a long time. You may be the first American who's agreed with me
Automatically Appended Next Post: ShumaGorath wrote:No we don't. I don't want people who don't know what the issues are voting. I'd rather not have elections made even more into American Idol contests than they are now. The electorate is a beast.
You've made a big mistake in assuming the people who vote know any more than the people who don't. Think about the people you know who sound off about their favourite political parties (or more likely sound off about how bad the other side is). Do they actually know anymore about politics than people who don't have strong political beliefs, or do they just have a bunch of political slogans memorised?
And then consider the impact of how this works overall. Swinging voters are a vastly overstated demographic in the US, and the parties both know this. People who aren't attached to one party or the other almost all stay home on election day. This means the election really comes down to how well each party gets out the people affiliated with its own side. The impact this has on US politics is enormous - there's no interest in doing anything, or campaigning on issues of general interest to the electorate, instead its all about making noise on specific party interests - so pleasing the social conservatives, gun nuts, evangelicals and businessmen for the Republican party. The Democrats make similar noise to appeal to minority groups, progressives and the like. Conversation on issues of general importance to the population is largely lost.
Automatically Appended Next Post:
Wow. That pretty much just takes away the pretense entirely, doesn't it? Hmm, Pennsylvania is likely to be the tipping point in a Romney win, as well.
Automatically Appended Next Post: Ahtman wrote:There will be no day without brisket!
BBQ'd brisket? Wouldn't that be really, really tough? I mean, if ever there was meat that needed slow cooking to make it edible...