Was NOT expecting the story in Spec ops: the line. I knew it was supposed to be rough, but I had no idea what I was in for.
Also, was pleasantly surprised by the new XCOM. It's just barely below the original, but I gotta say, they captured the feel PERFECTLY. I've been playing it on classic difficulty on ironman and holy crap does it not pull any punches. Assaulted the alien base far before I was ready and had a (what I thought) elite team of troopers get absolutely butchered like they were a bunch of rookies.
That game gives you the heebie jeebies far more than any horror game. It's all the little things they did, like the thin man "interrogation" (the way it looks at you as the shield closes was really well done) to the sounds, to how you're just ridiculously outclassed in the beginning. I think it's a pretty worthy installment to the series. I hope they do a "terror from the deep" style sequel, because I would love to play that game without a million game breaking bugs and it would look awesome with today's graphics.
EDIT: Had to add in a ridiculous moment, even for XCOM. Today switched to medium difficulty so I could better learn what all the gear does without half the world dying 2 months in. 1st friggin terror mission. Step off the skylander, have a bad feeling. Immediately put all 6 of my elite team into overwatch. THREE CHRYSALIDS JUMP OUT OF A DOOR RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME! *Insert gratuitous language* Literally the only thing that saved me was that I had two Colonel level snipers unloading at literally point blank range with double tap. "Ok, now I'm safe" I think. THREE MORE POP OUT NEXT TURN! I barely kill them and a zombie spawned from an idiot civilian. Those chrysallids are followed by TWO MORE. I have never freaked out that badly in a video game. Literally every shot counted. They nailed that XCOM feel to a tee.
Dammit XCOM, I hate you so much. Best game of 2012