So me an my small band of gamers we are planning to just stay with 8.0 though we may give KoW a try just for kicks.
None of us liked ET so there is no problem there. None of us like the 6th level spells but we aren't crazy magic heavy people anyway. We thought about returning to 6th but some guys had newer models that don't really have a 6th ed equivalent, ie our Ogre player has a Stonehorn and the HE player has that sky chariot thing. Myself I like 8th because IMHO it is the best for core units. Big blocks of infantry can actually do something, "Step Up" is great. 6th wasn't terrible for core, because characters weren't too OP. But all you had to do was charge and wipe out the front rank and combat was just about in the bag. 7th was close but the power level went from a creep to a leap. So 8th is were we be, maybe with a few tweaks but nothing major.
As for the fluff, I have never liked GW story lines so I could care less about all that. I have stuck with WH and 40K over the years because I liked the rules and the models and just made my own story to go with it. One friend of mine was down about the whole fluff thing and being frozen in time. But he felt better when I reminded him that loads of people play WWII, WWI, ECW, ACW, and those plots aren't changing so why should fantasy be any different? Lots of people got into LOTR (and unless you're crazy like Peter Jackson) that story is not changing. It is just picking a setting to move our little toys around to.
|