Flinty wrote:But by specific reference to the Munitorum Manual, and by general reference to the setting, the penalty for basically every infraction in the Guard is death. Its down to the individual taking the punishment as to whether being alive, but with a very knackered back is a more or less positive outcome than being summarily executed.
For al of the onlookers, though, it shows that if you make a few stupid mistakes in judgement, you don't necessarily get instantly murdered for it. This is likely to make one better disposed to this particular Commissar, compared to the psycho murder boys that seem to turn up in all the other regiments, and more likely to want to keep the current incumbent alive. Friendship is not really part of it, just enlightened self-interest on all sides.
Exactly this. We’re not talking about modern western militaries where we generally care highly about the welfare of our (mostly volunteer) personnel.
We’re talking about ‘the most bloody and brutal regime imaginable’ where the punishment for most infractions is death.
Having the guy in charge of discipline hand out floggings for things where people are getting shot in other regiments (and it is very common to be working alongside other regiments so this will be noticed) is going to be a guy in charge of discipline you’re going to be pretty keen on having around.
And when you’re the guy in charge of discipline who’s been through a brutal training regime for your job, complete with live fire exercises where you actually shoot people, that is designed to mould you to execute people without mercy or hesitation - then having a drive to come up with punishments you can justify to your peers that don’t involve executing people for minor infractions does in fact show care for your personnel.
Neither side is seeing things in line with modern morality.
For the troops, being flogged is better than being shot.
For Cain, he has to give out punishments that fly with his peers, so even if he justifies not shooting people they can’t be too lenient by Imperial standards.
Multiple books show this issue where Cain is having to thread this needle of having to give a punishment within the bounds of what the Imperium expects, while doing his best to be as lenient as he can get away with. Right from the first few chapters of the very first book. He’s repeatedly called out on this by other commissars and generally only gets away with it through a combination of his built up reputation and that he inevitably saves the day.