BetrayTheWorld wrote:
Peregrine wrote:
There's about as much "ambiguity" as there is in debating whether bolters are
STR 4 or
STR 10.
This statement would be true if it said bolters were
Str 4 on one page, then said that they were
Str 10 on another.
The ambiguity in this comes from the fact that every reference to the
ADL refers to it as a fortification, purpose-built fortification, or purpose-built battlefield defense. Purpose-built fortifications give a 3+ cover save per the cover section.
The
ADL also has a generic terrain type of Battlefield Debris(Defense Lines). As we all know, terrain types involved several various rules dependent upon type(not just cover save). In the terrain type section, it's generic terrain type offers a 4+ cover save.
There are many pieces of terrain that are/could be classified as Battlefield Debris(Defense Lines), but only one of them is considered a fortification: the Aegis Defense Line. Arguments can be made for both sides, and no one can "win" the argument without input from
GW because the rules are in conflict with neither of them specifically categorized as a "Basic" rule. I encourage you to email
GW questions on this so that hopefully they
FAQ it. I've already sent mine, and was disappointed to see that nothing about it was included in the recent
FAQ update.
It is just the name of the
FoC section where you can purchase the
ADL, that doesn't mean anything you pick will be classified as a fortification. It is like saying that any havoc/devastator squad armed with plasmaguns/meltaguns can't move and shoot normally because they are heavy and heavies need to be stationary to fire with normal
BS any heavy choice on the codexes would actually not be allowed to move and shoot with normal
BS unless they are tanks.