Thanks for the comments! Here are my own thoughts, based on yours:
Black robes: I expected the dip to tone down the highlight and I wanted a bit off-black anyway, therefore no black wash prior dipping. I did consider it, though. Maybe I will add a mid-layer or two to smooth the highlights for next batch. I have two Farseers and 5 Warlocks waiting for undercoat (
skull white, by the way) plus some more hidden in my closet. I did collect Ulthe Strike force back in the days of Codex: Craftworld Eldar and Eye of Terror, but didn't paint a lot of them back then.
I have to consider simple freehand lines or transfers to make the robes more interesting for the next batch.
Black armour: Happy with it, currently.
Wraithbone: As with black, I expected a stronger shading from the dip. I'll see what I can do with this.
Gems: I think I'll skip the red glaze which fades the highlights, and blackline the gems away from wraithbone better with Agrax Earthshade or similar.
Inverted colours for helmets etc: The colour scheme is inspired by studio Ulthwé army, which has inverted colours here and there. It will feature mostly on my Seer Council (like the two warlocks seen here), but on random guardians as well. The Guardians shown here were previously painted 10 years ago and therefore intended for test figures, I wanted to try both helmet options on them. My own addition is white kneepads, which will feature on some models (but not consistently).
Basing: Base trim was originally darker but I didn't like it. The current is Steel Legion Drab. I would like to try out one shade lighter, but it might start to clash with the wraithbone. For the grass tufts I tried a few colours, but these were my favourite.
Modelling and conversions: Future guardians will feature small ammo bags and holsters borrowed from lesser races. I think cut down
Space Marine ammo bags should match the ones sculpted on Warlocks, Farseers and classic Rangers. Actually some of these guardians already have them, but they are not visible in pics.
Automatically Appended Next Post:
fenshysa wrote:Simple and effective. The grey highlights on the black are clean, and the white is solid - I wish I could get my white to come out like that.
Out of curiousity, what color did you prime them?
The Warlocks and Farseer were undercoated
white, the Guardians were painted over 10-year old
black-ish Ulthwe paintjob. The future models will be undercoated white, at least for infantry.
The white areas are painted first, because to get smooth coverage you need to be messy. They have been basecoated Pallid Wych Flesh and highlighted with by adding equal amount of Ceramite White it to it. The key for smooth coverage here is wetbrushing.
The black areas are then basecoated Charadon Granite (my favourite colour), followed by highlights of Adeptus Battlegrey and Codex grey. Two Foundation paints there, thankfully I hoarded multiple pots of both when they were discontinued

.