Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Haley2
-bonded stormclad
-thorn

Stormblades
- 2 gunners
-officer and standard bearer

5 ogryn assault corps
-Jonas Murdoch

gun mages
- officer
- defender

rhupert carvolio

TA corps

Thoughts?

Why the Ogruns? What is your vision for that lot, and why Jonas? Do you really want to assault with AOE weapons? And he won't help with spells.

 motyak wrote:
Why the Ogruns? What is your vision for that lot, and why Jonas? Do you really want to assault with AOE weapons? And he won't help with spells.

Because I have a different opinion to you? I like them as a unit where the models are properly tough and hit hard for a decent 9pt price. Jonus makes them real ogrun assault corps because I'm not sure if the cannon blast damage can mathematically even hurt them. Haley's got Thorn but arc node sheninegins anyway.

Lol if you are going to snap like that, then have fun with your list as is, you probably won't get many people offering help.

I'd offer advice, but you seem pretty stuck with what you have without wanting criticism. Have fun!

Farseer Faenyin wrote:I'd offer advice, but you seem pretty stuck with what you have without wanting criticism. Have fun!

I'm taking well-written and researched criticism only.

motyak wrote:Lol if you are going to snap like that, then have fun with your list as is, you probably won't get many people offering help.

if you had read about the http://battlecollege.wikispaces.com/AssaultCorps/OAC, you have known what they do [which would be unique for cygnar], how Murdoch assists and that their own blast damage can only hurt them on a .

Having done this, you would be able to correctly evaluate how could this list is, so I wouldn't have had to talk to you like this.

Was that good enough for you kiddo?

So we have to meet whatever arbitrary level the OP deems to be "well-written and researched criticism" to not get snapped at?

Well, you're on your own there. You've given no write up for why you've chosen certain units and attacked people that question why you've taken them. That's not criticising. That's a simple question. Tell us why you've taken these things and the theorymachine for how you think this list works in your head then people can maybe offer some suggestions as to what they think will work better or differently.

That's how it works. Though I highly doubt anyone will do this now if you're just going to bit their faces off.

Personally I would consider a unit of Stormlances in place of the OAC. Already have in built assault plus they offer you the ability to Jam with reach and offer you some hard hitting high mat troops on the charge and with Haleys feat they should be able to get two alphas off.

I would also drop the TAC and a gunner for Arlan and Jnr. Obviously Jnr for the Arcane Shield and Arlan can power the Defender to help get then Crit and the potential 4d6 damage and offers Evasive to help with help getting the assassination run with either thorn or the Stormclad.

Also why no Squire?