Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

If I were rooting for the IoM, none. The primarchs were a terrible idea that lead to the eventual downfall of the human race, at the peak of its power. Given the rate and ease of which they turned considering what they were, the Apex of humanity... I'd be afraid the ones that came back would destroy the rest of the IoM.

If I was rooting for Chaos, I'd vote for Horus given that he was the strongest and the wisest of them all. The fact that he wrecked Sang in combat and then wrecked the Emperor speaks for itself... he also seiged Terra almost 2 months. Yeah, I'd want Horus back.

Lion'el Johnson is my choiche.

Rogal Dorn has proven his wrong attitude being headstrong and loosing his mind after the death of his father. Despite his human behaviour... I do not think he'd be the best Primarch to have back.

Guilliman neither, he's too much balanced... Sanguinius would be an excellent choice but the Dark Angels are the best ones in my opinion. With Johnson back they would stop with their repent nonsense and brought back to be a real chapter.

At least... IMHO

The Lion all the way.

Even though I play traitors now, I'll always have a soft spot for the DA.

Maybe if he returned, the DA will stop having such a gakky codex.

Magnus, with the remaining Thousand Son's restored and united.

Robot, because he is the epitome of what a Marien strive to be.

It'd have to be Magnus of the Thousand Sons, albeit a much more

Fulgrim all the way

Dorn for sure, the Imperium needs his defence tactics

Dorn would probably go of and get himself killed again anyway.

Magnus he was bad ass but betrayed!

Horus. I'm sorry, but the guy who could kick ass all the way to the Emperor and then defeat him is the guy the Imperium needs.

Besides, it's not as if he willingly went to Chaos. Guy was stabbed by a poisoned blade and then mind-screwed by a bunch of guys who had already gone to Chaos.

I think having Angron loyal, or what passes for loyal, again would be pretty awseome.

But i voted Magnus because in my belief, if he had not turned traitor, he could have been what saved the imperium...If he was just a little patient and sent messege Via ship or some such....

Fury_00011 wrote:Magnus he was bad ass but betrayed!

Actually, Magnus was himself betrayed... true he went against his word to the Emperor to cease all use of sorcery, but he did it with the best of intentions.

Horus convinced Leman Russ to attack the Thousand Sons and destroy them, contrary to the Emperors wishes.

tarnish wrote:I believe Dorn would be most beneficial to the imperium at large

Dorn indeed. Let's see Abaddon get past Cadia with Dorn building the defenses!

Oh, and apart from the pain-glove thingie he's the most "sane" Primarch.

OverwatchCNC wrote:

Lokirfellheart wrote:Lorgar, as in the grim darkness of the far future there is only religious emperor fanatics....
He would be completely impossible to 'convert' him back to the imperium however.

Not so sure about that. He didn't seem all that impressed with the Chaos Gods in The First Heretic.

I haven't read that, but it seems no-one satisfies him. And also, it seems nobody cares because no-one else voted for him.

Croax, one because the Raven Guard are my favorite chapter, two while he might not be the leader that everyone wants he could still help out all lot, and sneaky marines are always cool.

Girllyman, so I can torture him, then kill him, S-L-O-W-L-Y.

how can you bring back a Primarch when there still here .the demon Prince Primarchs are still kicking so why are they on the list

that was not meant to be rude (constructive criticism) but if you meant getting up and doing some thing then i'm all for this idea and i would vote for Magnus because he was stab in the back by Horus

because all the big E would have done is sent him to bed with out supper. but Horus had to get Magnus's legion massacred

II Legion Primarch. To be completely obliterated from the Imperium Records....got to know why. We know why the Soul Drinkers were, but I feel Counter's explanation pretty watery. IMO he "cheapened" the mystery behind the "Lost Legions". Does that make sense?

I voted Sanguinus, all things considered he seems most like the Emperor and the best hope for the Imperium

I initially voted Dorn, because he's the man with the plan, but thinking on it further, what about Fulgrim. He turned his homeworld from a dying resource starved hell hole into a thriving and successful planet with little trouble. He never actually turned to Chaos, it took a greater daemon crawling around in his brain for years to get him to even the point of weakness - with forewarning and foreknowledge of the Primordial Annihilator I think he would never turn/ have been turned. I think he would do really well in actually reversing the entropy affecting the Imperium, and he has style! No more skull skully skull skulls on everything for the Imperium.

Sanguinius can not only heal the Blood Angels but also resume his position as a beacon of hope for the downtrodden people of the IoM

He's also quite level-headed, pure and generally lovely.

After that? I'd probably say Rogal Dorn and Gulliman.

Horus he is just epic

This thread belongs in General Discussions.

As a BT fanatic I have to say Dorn. He would be so proud of our Crusades.

As a Blood Angels player this is easy. Sanguinius deserves to be brought back (unless he already has as the Sanguinor)