fe40k wrote:I'm surprised this offtopic discussion has gone on this long. It's actually really simple:
RAW: The errata and
FAQ do not allow units, arriving from reinforcements (which "Da Jump" is), to deploy outside the deployment zone - period.
RAI: You ARE allowed to deploy outside the deployment zone T1, as long as you were previously on the board already.
It is not reasonable to expect every player to have access to knowledge of every Facebook post ever made by
GW. The facebook
GW team also clearly states that they cannot provide official answers - except "this one time because we asked the rules team and it's actually official"; "here's a nice pretty picture".
RAW: Facebook
GW cannot provide official answers.
RAI: Facebook
GW CAN provide official answers, because "they talked to the rules team".
As far as the official question stated in this thread:
RAW: Waters are murky if the unit retains the buff. The question in specific is referring only to stratagem usage, so...
RAI: ...it's not a stretch of the imagination to understand they meant that rule to apply to units reployed via other methods (such as "Da Jump").
.
.
Knock it off you guys; both sides have said their piece, and the resolution comes down to if you're a
RAW player, or a
RAI player.