Regarding number 2.
A while back somebody proposed rules for an Ulthwe supplement. While most would not be applicable, my suggestion for Black Guardians was as follows:
Black Storm Guardians - Storm Guardians gain the Furious Charge special rule.
Black Defender Guardians - Guardian Defenders re-roll failed To Hit rolls of 1 when firing. Note that this does not apply to any Warlocks or Independent Characters joined to the unit.
Originally Black Guardians had either +1 WS or +1 BS. Since this would make them better than Aspect Warriors, I think giving them a slight boost to their close combat and shooting is in order. I don't think that a re-roll To Hit of 1 is overly broken. Assuming 10 Guardians in range of a squad of Space Marines.
Before (BS3 -> BS4): 20 shots
BS3: 10 hits, 5 Wounds inflicted, 1.667 Wounds suffered.
BS4: 13.33 hits, 6.667 Wounds inflicted, 2.222 Wounds suffered.
An increase of .555 Wounds inflicted.
Now (BS4 -> re-roll 1's): 20 shots
BS4: 13.33 hits, 6.667 Wounds inflicted, 3.704 Wounds suffered (increase due to Pseudo-Rending)
Re-roll: 15.56 hits, 7.778 Wounds inflicted, 4.321 Wounds suffered.
An increase of .617. Note that the increase is higher solely due to Bladestorm. Without the rending-like ability, the re-roll inflicts 2.593 Wounds (0.371 increase).
|