Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

I have two slightly different competitive lists but I'd like some help deciding which one is better.

List 1

CAD

HQ
- Farseer Skyrunner - 115

Troops
- Windriders (4) - 108
-- 4x Scatter Lasers
- Windriders (3) - 81
-- 3x Scatter Lasers
- Windriders (3) - 81
-- 3x Scatter Lasers

Lord of War
- Wraithknight - 335
-- Ghostglaive and Scatter Shield, 2x Starcannon

CAD

HQ
- Farseer Skyrunner - 115

Troops
- Windriders (4) - 108
-- 4x Scatter Lasers
- Windriders (3) - 81
-- 3x Scatter Lasers
- Windriders (3) - 81
-- 3x Scatter Lasers

Lord of War
- Wraithknight - 335
-- Ghostglaive and Scatter Shield, 2x Starcannon

Aspect Host (+1BS)

- Warp Spiders (7) - 143
-- Exarch
- Warp Spiders (7) - 143
-- Exarch
- Warp Spiders (6) - 124
-- Exarch

---1850


List 2

CAD

HQ
- Farseer Skyrunner - 120
-- Singing Spear

Troops
- Windriders (4) - 108
-- 4x Scatter Lasers
- Windriders (3) - 81
-- 3x Scatter Lasers
- Windriders (3) - 81
-- 3x Scatter Lasers

Lord of War
- Wraithknight - 310
-- Ghostglaive and Scatter Shield, 1x Scatter Laser

CAD

HQ
- Farseer Skyrunner - 120
-- Singing Spear

Troops
- Windriders (4) - 108
-- 4x Scatter Lasers
- Windriders (3) - 81
-- 3x Scatter Lasers
- Windriders (3) - 81
-- 3x Scatter Lasers

Lord of War
- Wraithknight - 295
-- Ghostglaive and Scatter Shield

Shroud of Kurnous
- Hemlock Wraithfighter - 185
- Crimson Hunter - 140
- Crimson Hunter - 140

---1850

So which of these two lists are better?

I like flyers personally, however I would ask what your meta is like. If you have the presence of flyers to justify the 3 in your second list, i say own the skies. But if you are mostly seeing 1 or no flyers in opponents lists, the spiders are probably better.