Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Which is better?

List A

Brigade Detachment- 12 Command Points

2x Commander: 4x Fusion-320
Ethereal-45

Ghostkeel: Collider, 2x Fusion, Target Lock, 2x Stealth Drones-200
Ghostkeel: Raker, 2x Burst, Target Lock, ATS, 2x Stealth Drones-201
3x Stealths-90

6x5 Strikes-240

2x5 Vespid-150
2x5 Pathfinders-80
1x5=4 Marker Drones-52

Longstrike: Railhead, 2x SMS-215
Railhead: 2x SMS-195
Railside: 2x SMS, Multi-tracker-185

Total: 2000

List B

Battalion Detachment- 6 Command Points

3x1 Commander: 4x Fusion-480

Ghostkeel: Collider, 2x Fusion, Target Lock, 2x Stealth Drones-200
Ghostkeel: Raker, 2x Burst, Target Lock, ATS, 2x Stealth Drones-201
Ghostkeel: Raker, 2x Burst, Target Lock, ATS, 2x Stealth Drones-201

2x5 Strikes-80
1x10 Kroot-60

1x9 Vespid- 135
1x10 Pathfinder-80
1x5 Marker Drones-65

Super-Heavy Auxiliary Detachment- 0 Command Points

Stormsurge: Pulse Driver, 4 D Missiles, Cluster Rockets, 2x SMS, 2x Airburst, Shields, ATS, Target Lock- 498

Total: 2000

I'm leaning towards list B; both have 7 big threats, but B has a super-heavy. Although, 12 CP is no joke. That's a lot of re-rolls. Both lists are aggressive, both have Keels and Vespid as forward units than screen for the Fusion commanders and keep them alive and slagging tanks/monsters.

I'm not sure which is better but B is less micromanagement from the looks of things, maybe a faster game that way. Probably depends on if you're opponent is armed for anti heavy or infantry.

Couple of things I've spotted:

Longstrike is a HQ, not heavy support. List 1 therefore isn't legal.

Stormsurges don't require target locks. They already don't suffer penalties to hit for moving and firing heavy weapons. Give it an early warning override instead.

If you're fielding a stormsurge I think it might be a plan to give one of your commanders missile pods instead of fusion. Stand him beside the stormsurge and call Kauyon on turn 1, before nailing it down. You could potentially give the guy a drone controller instead of one of his missile pods and have the marker drones hang out near him.

Overall I like the second list better. I think that (somewhat strangely) Tau heavy support options are pretty weak, which makes the brigade hard to justify. My approach is to take multiple other detachments instead, which you can easily do given the number of commanders you want to take.

I'd probably drop the stormsurge in exchange for more commanders and ghostkeels, and perhaps more troops to make a second brigade.