yeah, I tried nuln oil for the first time about 3-4 years ago, and had that problem...and thought I hated
GW washes since then...only this year have I tried them again, and actually gave them a really good shake before using them, and now I think they're great
you really need to shake them every time before you go to use them...and really shake the heck outta them when you use it for the first time!