|
The plague flail seems like a complete non-option because of the low range, you basically only get to use it in melee and not when you charge on BS 4+ in your own turn, while the bileblade can be used on both turns, even if you charged. S8 is actually an important breakpoint because of the GUO's Psychic ability which lets him wound T9 vehicles (of which there are a lot) on 4+ with the bilesword, but only on 5s with the doomsday bell. Add to that the option of swinging 12 times against a horde and I think the bilesword will be better because of this guy's limited mobility allowing your opponent to choose to engage the GUO with a vehicle, rendering the bell mostly useless. Even a Rhino can survive ages against the bell. If possible don't finish assembling your model and take it for a test run with both or magnetize it in case the rules change in a year with the new codex coming out.
|