Switch Theme:

Woman sues over vaginal, anal exams in El Paso drug search  [RSS] Share on facebook Share on Twitter Submit to Reddit
»
Author Message
Advert


Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you:
  • No adverts like this in the forums anymore.
  • Times and dates in your local timezone.
  • Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance.
  • Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely.
  • Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net.
If you are already a member then feel free to login now.




Made in us
Incorporating Wet-Blending






Glendale, AZ

http://www.elpasotimes.com/latestnews/ci_24750069/woman-sues-over-drug-search-after-crossing-at

A New Mexico woman claims in a federal lawsuit that she underwent a brutal and inhumane six-hour full-body cavity search by federal officers that included anal and vaginal probes that made her feel like an "animal."

The woman, a Lovington, N.M. resident, also is suing University Medical Center, where she was forced to have an observed bowel movement, was X-rayed, had a speculum exam, vaginal exam and had a CT scan.

The suit claims the hospital "violated her" and then gave her the $5,000 bill.

The lawsuit names the El Paso County Hospital District's Board of Managers, University Medical Center, Drs. Michael Parsa and Christopher Cabanillas, two unknown supervising U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers and two other CBP officers only identified by their last names of Portillo and Herrera as defendants. The doctors and the agents could not be reached for comment.

The 54-year-old woman, who is not identified in the suit, is asking for an unspecified amount of money and to end the policy that gives federal agents and officers the authority to stick their fingers and objects up people's cavities when they search for drugs.

The lawsuit was filed Wednesday by the American Civil Liberties Union in federal court in El Paso on behalf of the woman who was stopped as she crossed at the Bridge of the Americas a year ago. Despite the six-hour search at the port and then later at UMC, no drugs were found.

The woman is identified as Jane Doe in the lawsuit.

According to the lawsuit, the woman was first frisked and strip-searched at the port of entry, where officers stuck their fingers inside her rectum and vagina. When that search came up negative, she was taken to University Medical Center.

"These extreme and illegal searches deeply traumatized our client," ACLU of New Mexico Legal Director Laura Schauer Ives said in the news release. "The fact that our government treated an innocent 54-year-old woman with such brutality and inhumanity should outrage all Americans. We must ensure that government agents never put another person through a nightmare like this ever again."

A spokesman for U.S. Customs and Border Protection said in a prepared statement that the agency could not talk about a specific lawsuit.

"As a practice CBP does not comment on pending litigation," the statement said. "CBP stresses honor and integrity in every aspect of our mission, and the overwhelming majority of CBP employees and officers perform their duties with honor and distinction, working tirelessly every day to keep our country safe. We do not tolerate corruption or abuse within our ranks, and we fully cooperate with any criminal or administrative investigations of alleged misconduct by any of our personnel, on or off-duty."

University Medical Center also declined to get into specifics of the lawsuit.

"Hospital policy is to obtain consent from all patients who receive medical services at UMC," spokeswoman Margaret Altoff-Olivas said in a statement. "Because this case involves litigation, UMC will not be commenting further."

The search took place at about 2 p.m. Dec. 12, 2012, when the woman was coming back from seeing a family friend, whom she calls "uncle" and tries to visit once a month.

As her passport was swiped, a CBP officer told her she was "randomly" picked for a secondary inspection, where Portillo and Herrera frisked her through her clothing.

"One of the agents ran her finger over Ms. Doe's genital area during the frisk," the lawsuit said.

Then the woman was told to squat as one of the officers "inserted her finger in the crevice of Ms. Doe's buttocks." The frisk did not show any evidence of contraband or drugs, the lawsuit said.

Then the woman was told to stand in a line with other people as a drug-sniffing dog walked by.

The officer with the dog "hit the ground by her feet, but did not hit the ground by any of the others in the line," the lawsuit said. "The dog responded by lunging onto Ms. Doe and landing its front paws on her torso."

Ives said she does not believe this was a proper signal to indicate a drugs were present, but officers used it to continue the search.

The woman was taken to another room and asked to take off her pants and crouch as her anus and vagina were examined with a flashlight, the lawsuit said.

The woman, now crying, was taken to University Medical Center after the strip search did not find anything.

"During the car ride to the Medical Center, Ms. Doe asked if the agents had a warrant," the lawsuit said. "One of them responded that they did not need a warrant."

While handcuffed to an examination table, the woman was searched again by both officers and Cabanillas and Parsa. She was given a laxative and had a bowel movement in a portable toilet in front of both officers, the lawsuit said.

Then the woman's abdomen was X-rayed, but there were no signs of drugs or any other contraband in the woman's body. A speculum was used to probe her vagina and Parsa's fingers were used to inspect both her vagina and rectum while the door to the examining room was left open, the lawsuit said.

At this point the lawsuit claims, "Ms. Doe felt that she was being treated less than human, like an animal."

The last test was a CT scan of the woman's abdomen and pelvis, which resulted in no evidence of illegal activity being found.

The lawsuit said after the CT scan one of the officers told the woman she could sign the medical consent form and CBP would pay for the exams, but if she did not sign, she would be charged. The woman refused to sign and eventually she was charged more than $5,000 for the examinations.

According to the lawsuit, she repeatedly refused to consent to any of the searches.

University Medical Center's search of patients policy states, "Associates, members of Medical Staff, Residents or Allied Health Professionals may search a patient only when necessary to comply with a search warrant." Under the subhead procedure, the policy states, "...unless a patient consents, an invasion of the patient's body to obtain evidence requires a search warrant."

A warrant was not obtained, the lawsuit said.

"However, in practice, the Medical Center staff and CBP agents routinely conduct invasive cavity searches without warrant, consent or sufficient suspicion to justify the searches," the lawsuit said. "When Ms. Doe expressed dismay about the unreasonable searches she suffered, a Medical Center employee responded that these procedures were routinely followed when an individual is brought in by CBP agents."

In a phone interview, Ives said searches like the one the 54-year-old woman went through are illegal and becoming common among law enforcement.

"When the less intrusive search didn't find any evidence of drugs, more intrusive searches should have not been used," Ives said. "Any one of those searches should have eliminated any suspicion of drugs. A second search should make it clear and at most a third search should have been the last."

She said: "The fact that this happened to a 54-year-old woman should outrage anyone. She did ask to talk to an attorney and she did ask for a warrant. I don't know what guarantees there are to our rights other than a lawsuit like this one that hold the government agencies responsible."

Last month, a Deming man sued Deming police officers who gave him three enemas, two anal probes and a colonoscopy after he was suspected of having drugs. The search found nothing, and lawyers for the man said the warrant used to conduct the search failed to show probable cause.

Aaron Bracamontes may be reached at 546-6156.

Mannahnin wrote:A lot of folks online (and in emails in other parts of life) use pretty mangled English. The idea is that it takes extra effort and time to write properly, and they’d rather save the time. If you can still be understood, what’s the harm? While most of the time a sloppy post CAN be understood, the use of proper grammar, punctuation, and spelling is generally seen as respectable and desirable on most forums. It demonstrates an effort made to be understood, and to make your post an easy and pleasant read. By making this effort, you can often elicit more positive responses from the community, and instantly mark yourself as someone worth talking to.
insaniak wrote: Every time someone threatens violence over the internet as a result of someone's hypothetical actions at the gaming table, the earth shakes infinitisemally in its orbit as millions of eyeballs behind millions of monitors all roll simultaneously.


 
   
Made in us
Fate-Controlling Farseer





Fort Campbell

I get the feeling this has been discussed recently.


Automatically Appended Next Post:
http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/list/561579.page#6219455

Completely different story. That sucks.

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/12/27 08:09:26


Full Frontal Nerdity 
   
Made in us
Last Remaining Whole C'Tan






Pleasant Valley, Iowa

I'm not a medical expert, so perhaps one of our more specialized Dakkaroos can enlighten us as to what a speculum can reveal that an x-ray would not.

 lord_blackfang wrote:
Respect to the guy who subscribed just to post a massive ASCII dong in the chat and immediately get banned.

 Flinty wrote:
The benefit of slate is that its.actually a.rock with rock like properties. The downside is that it's a rock
 
   
Made in us
Fate-Controlling Farseer





Fort Campbell

Maybe they thought she had lead lined balloons?

Full Frontal Nerdity 
   
Made in us
Douglas Bader






And, once again, the solution is simple: public execution for anyone involved in the abuse as a lesson to anyone else thinking of doing it again.

There is no such thing as a hobby without politics. "Leave politics at the door" is itself a political statement, an endorsement of the status quo and an attempt to silence dissenting voices. 
   
Made in de
Mekboy Hammerin' Somethin'




Lubeck

 Ouze wrote:
I'm not a medical expert, so perhaps one of our more specialized Dakkaroos can enlighten us as to what a speculum can reveal that an x-ray would not.


(Medical student, not a full doctor here)

X-Rays are generally regarded as highly useful, at least for proper medical applications, but they have their disadvantages. In this case, the devil could argue that the woman might have been smuggling some substance with the same density as either tissue or bodily fluids; something like that would most probably not show up on an X-ray properly, especially with a standard x-ray and not a CT scan. Apart from that, and I'm not an expert on that, X-Rays have to be adjusted for a certain "window" which determines what kind of tissue or bone results in higher extinction on the final x-ray picture. So different x-ray pictures have different windows in which they are actually useful to detect anomalies and pathological evidence, not every X-Ray picture shows the same, which could also be used to argue that further probing was necessary.

Apart from playing the devil's advocate there I deplore these procedures and in my opinion this is a far more harrowing thought than the "riot officers beating people with batons" cliché often discussed when it comes to the matter of "police state or no police state".

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/12/27 09:15:39


 
   
Made in br
Wolf Guard Bodyguard in Terminator Armor




For me the cincher is that all of these searches were performed without consent, and without obtaining a warrant or letting the woman speak to a lawyer, then they wanted her to sign for consent *after* the fact despite her repeated protests.

I'm no legal expert by any means, but it seems to me that every step in there was, even if not illegal, most certainly reprehensible.

That's just... words fail me. Public execution might be a bit harsh, but all involved (including the medical personnel!) should at the very least lose their jobs over this.
   
Made in us
Last Remaining Whole C'Tan






Pleasant Valley, Iowa

The real victim in all this was the US taxpayer, who is inevitably going to have to pick up the tab for all this free healthcare that Johnny Law was handing out willy-nilly, while working schlubs like me have to wait 6 months and drop a $30 copay to have a hobo wearing scrubs in the back of a dirty alley even do a cursory rooting-around in my demon hole. And don't even ask how much Jethro charges to watch me poop.

Thanks, Obama.

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/12/27 11:50:00


 lord_blackfang wrote:
Respect to the guy who subscribed just to post a massive ASCII dong in the chat and immediately get banned.

 Flinty wrote:
The benefit of slate is that its.actually a.rock with rock like properties. The downside is that it's a rock
 
   
Made in us
Fate-Controlling Farseer





Fort Campbell

 Ouze wrote:
The real victim in all this was the US taxpayer, who is inevitably going to have to pick up the tab for all this free healthcare that Johnny Law was handing out willy-nilly, while working schlubs like me have to wait 6 months and drop a $30 copay to have a hobo wearing scrubs in the back of a dirty alley even do a cursory rooting-around in my demon hole. And don't even ask how much Jethro charges to watch me poop.

Thanks, Obama.



I'm glad to see you are finally coming around to the right way of thinking.

Full Frontal Nerdity 
   
Made in au
Incorporating Wet-Blending






Australia

It says a lot about these cases that the officials involved have the audacity to rape people and charge them for the privilege.

"When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up."
-C.S. Lewis 
   
Made in us
Kid_Kyoto






Probably work

That's pretty monstrous. Think those involved will get anything worse than a paid vacation?

Assume all my mathhammer comes from here: https://github.com/daed/mathhammer 
   
Made in us
Martial Arts Fiday






Nashville, TN

What would motivate someone to do this?

"Holy Sh*&, you've opened my eyes and changed my mind about this topic, thanks Dakka OT!"

-Nobody Ever

Proverbs 18:2

"CHEESE!" is the battlecry of the ill-prepared.

 warboss wrote:

GW didn't mean to hit your wallet and I know they love you, baby. I'm sure they won't do it again so it's ok to purchase and make up.


Albatross wrote:I think SlaveToDorkness just became my new hero.

EmilCrane wrote:Finecast is the new Matt Ward.

Don't mess with the Blade and Bolter! 
   
Made in us
Kid_Kyoto






Probably work

Well, she could have been breaking the law. The clue was that the dog was given any sort of indication toward her whatsoever. As such, the police appear to have the moral obligation to demand her violation at all costs in the name of finding any possible way she could have been breaking the law as indicated by the dog. The ends justify the means, right?

Assume all my mathhammer comes from here: https://github.com/daed/mathhammer 
   
Made in us
5th God of Chaos! (Ho-hum)





Curb stomping in the Eye of Terror!

 djones520 wrote:
 Ouze wrote:
The real victim in all this was the US taxpayer, who is inevitably going to have to pick up the tab for all this free healthcare that Johnny Law was handing out willy-nilly, while working schlubs like me have to wait 6 months and drop a $30 copay to have a hobo wearing scrubs in the back of a dirty alley even do a cursory rooting-around in my demon hole. And don't even ask how much Jethro charges to watch me poop.

Thanks, Obama.



I'm glad to see you are finally coming around to the right way of thinking.

Took you long enough Ouze...

Demon hole?

Live Ork, Be Ork. or D'Ork!


 
   
Made in us
Fixture of Dakka




It is depressing how common these stories are becoming.
   
Made in us
Old Sourpuss






Lakewood, Ohio

Relapse wrote:
It is depressing how common these stories are becoming.

What makes it truly strange is that it's only ever happening in the Las Cruces and surrounding 60 mile or so radius (Deming, El Paso, etc...)

Wasn't there a link in the first few cases where the same dog that was indicating there might be drugs around?

Also, I am not a cop, but my buddy was K9 for the Cuyahoga Metropolitan Housing Authority and if the dog indicated there were drugs and nothing was found, he'd be on the hook for the damages to the 'suspect', his property, etc... So maybe that is why these officers are going to such lengths to try and find drugs? The dog indicates there might be something, but cursory searches don't show anything, but the dog is positive there is something drug related going on, so they take the person to a hospital to get checked out. Just an idea, probably doesn't have much credence to it.

DR:80+S++G+M+B+I+Pwmhd11#++D++A++++/sWD-R++++T(S)DM+

Ask me about Brushfire or Endless: Fantasy Tactics 
   
Made in us
Maddening Mutant Boss of Chaos





NorCal

Relapse wrote:
It is depressing how common these stories are becoming.


Agreed. Good thing we have reality show millionaires to discuss instead.

Veteran Sergeant wrote:Oh wait. His fluff, at this point, has him coming to blows with Lionel, Angryon, Magnus, and The Emprah. One can only assume he went into the Eye of Terror because he still hadn't had a chance to punch enough Primarchs yet.

Albatross wrote:I guess we'll never know. That is, until Frazzled releases his long-awaited solo album 'Touch My Weiner'. Then we'll know.

warboss wrote:I marvel at their ability to shoot the entire foot off with a shotgun instead of pistol shooting individual toes off like most businesses would.

Mr Nobody wrote:Going to war naked always seems like a good idea until someone trips on gravel.

Ghidorah wrote: You need to quit hating and trying to control other haters hating on other people's hobbies that they are trying to control.

ShumaGorath wrote:Posting in a thread where fat nerds who play with toys make fun of fat nerds who wear costumes outdoors.

Marshal2Crusaders wrote:Good thing it wasn't attacked by the EC, or it would be the assault on Magnir's Crack.
 
   
Made in us
Focused Dark Angels Land Raider Pilot




Magnolia, TX

I'm guessing no one had heard of the 4th amendment in NM.

Captain Killhammer McFighterson stared down at the surface of Earth from his high vantage point on the bridge of Starship Facemelter. Something ominous was looming on the surface. He could see a great shadow looming just underneath the waters of the Gulf of Mexico, slowly spreading northward. "That can't be good..." he muttered to himself while rubbing the super manly stubble on his chin with one hand. "But... on the other hand..." he looked at his shiny new bionic murder-arm. "This could be the perfect chance for that promotion." A perfect roundhouse kick slammed the ship's throttle into full gear. Soon orange jets of superheated plasma were visible from the space-windshield as Facemelter reentered the atmosphere at breakneck speed. 
   
Made in us
Last Remaining Whole C'Tan






Pleasant Valley, Iowa

jamesk1973 wrote:
I'm guessing no one had heard of the 4th amendment in NM.


That was the first thing that struck me, that both of these stories are from NM and just weeks apart.

 lord_blackfang wrote:
Respect to the guy who subscribed just to post a massive ASCII dong in the chat and immediately get banned.

 Flinty wrote:
The benefit of slate is that its.actually a.rock with rock like properties. The downside is that it's a rock
 
   
Made in us
Fate-Controlling Farseer





Fort Campbell

 Ouze wrote:
jamesk1973 wrote:
I'm guessing no one had heard of the 4th amendment in NM.


That was the first thing that struck me, that both of these stories are from NM and just weeks apart.


Well the first one supposedly had a warrant involved. This does seem extremely excessive though.

Full Frontal Nerdity 
   
Made in us
5th God of Chaos! (Ho-hum)





Curb stomping in the Eye of Terror!

I hope she sues everyone to thy kingdom come...

o.O

Jeeze-lou-eeze!

Live Ork, Be Ork. or D'Ork!


 
   
Made in us
Decrepit Dakkanaut






Leerstetten, Germany

 djones520 wrote:
 Ouze wrote:
jamesk1973 wrote:
I'm guessing no one had heard of the 4th amendment in NM.


That was the first thing that struck me, that both of these stories are from NM and just weeks apart.


Well the first one supposedly had a warrant involved. This does seem extremely excessive though.


Wasn't the first one a warrant that didn't cover the county the procedure was done in and that was also expired?
   
Made in us
5th God of Chaos! (Ho-hum)





Curb stomping in the Eye of Terror!

 d-usa wrote:
 djones520 wrote:
 Ouze wrote:
jamesk1973 wrote:
I'm guessing no one had heard of the 4th amendment in NM.


That was the first thing that struck me, that both of these stories are from NM and just weeks apart.


Well the first one supposedly had a warrant involved. This does seem extremely excessive though.


Wasn't the first one a warrant that didn't cover the county the procedure was done in and that was also expired?

Yep... that's what I remembered too.

It's AFU.

Live Ork, Be Ork. or D'Ork!


 
   
Made in us
Regular Dakkanaut




I don't think the full story is coming out here. I would be willing to bet that 1 she had been or was a known trafficker, 2 she probly is not a US citizen 3 I doubt she was treated as she says. As someone who is in Law enforcement there are bad apples out there yes., but most of the false allegations are just to try and hide something they did wrong. hopefully there will be more facts to come and who ever is in the wrong should be punished.
   
Made in us
Fixture of Dakka




mobirds4all wrote:
I don't think the full story is coming out here. I would be willing to bet that 1 she had been or was a known trafficker, 2 she probly is not a US citizen 3 I doubt she was treated as she says. As someone who is in Law enforcement there are bad apples out there yes., but most of the false allegations are just to try and hide something they did wrong. hopefully there will be more facts to come and who ever is in the wrong should be punished.


It will be interesting to find the truth of the story since this is the fourth such case I've read about in the past couple of months.
   
Made in us
Last Remaining Whole C'Tan






Pleasant Valley, Iowa

Do know you if the other 2 stories made the news? Were they also in New Mexico?

Speaking of questions: how can a medical professional perform a procedure on an unwilling patient? I would think a warrant would be irrelevant.




Automatically Appended Next Post:
I found a good article on it.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/11/11/anal-probes-and-the-drug-_n_4254600.html

This message was edited 2 times. Last update was at 2013/12/28 08:07:30


 lord_blackfang wrote:
Respect to the guy who subscribed just to post a massive ASCII dong in the chat and immediately get banned.

 Flinty wrote:
The benefit of slate is that its.actually a.rock with rock like properties. The downside is that it's a rock
 
   
Made in us
Kid_Kyoto






Probably work

mobirds4all wrote:
2 she probly is not a US citizen


For the purposes of what we're discussing here, does that matter? I know this is probably pushing on a nerve for a bunch of people here, and maybe I'm just not hip to the "ZOMG DRUGZ BAAAD" jive, and probably a pinko commie liberal to boot, but stuff like this strikes me as "basic human rights".


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Well, I guess technically it says she's a NM "resident", without actually declaring her a Citizen...

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/12/28 08:14:34


Assume all my mathhammer comes from here: https://github.com/daed/mathhammer 
   
Made in us
Douglas Bader






mobirds4all wrote:
I don't think the full story is coming out here. I would be willing to bet that 1 she had been or was a known trafficker, 2 she probly is not a US citizen 3 I doubt she was treated as she says. As someone who is in Law enforcement there are bad apples out there yes., but most of the false allegations are just to try and hide something they did wrong. hopefully there will be more facts to come and who ever is in the wrong should be punished.


It should be easy to find the full story. Was a warrant issued or not? If so, the case will be dropped pretty quickly. If not, then none of your speculation matters. Being a "known trafficker" or a non-citizen doesn't mean that the police get the right to do whatever they want to you.

There is no such thing as a hobby without politics. "Leave politics at the door" is itself a political statement, an endorsement of the status quo and an attempt to silence dissenting voices. 
   
Made in au
Incorporating Wet-Blending






Australia

 Peregrine wrote:
Was a warrant issued or not? If so, the case will be dropped pretty quickly.

If there was a warrant, the warrant was invalid, because a judge does not have the power to authorise an illegal search. All that would mean is that the judge along with the cops should be locked up like the rapists they are.

"When I became a man I put away childish things, including the fear of childishness and the desire to be very grown up."
-C.S. Lewis 
   
Made in us
Fate-Controlling Farseer





Fort Campbell

 AlexHolker wrote:
 Peregrine wrote:
Was a warrant issued or not? If so, the case will be dropped pretty quickly.

If there was a warrant, the warrant was invalid, because a judge does not have the power to authorise an illegal search. All that would mean is that the judge along with the cops should be locked up like the rapists they are.


What? The judge granting authority for the search makes it legal. On what grounds would you have declared the search illegal with a warrant? Just because a person refuses the search doesn't make it illegal.

Full Frontal Nerdity 
   
 
Forum Index » Off-Topic Forum
Go to: