gmaleron wrote:Understand some of what you mean but some of the other stuff you mention kinda confuses me, for example:
Vanquishers and punishers dont mix, 24 inch range is easy to avoid in vanguard or longways deployment.
Split Fire order solves this problem of not being able to shoot same target but do understand the range restriction and have thought about taking Exterminators instead. However you then mention this:
Then have the vanquishers with las and multimeltas hanging back with the primaris psykers.
You just told me that they dont mix because of range issues so why give them Multi-Meltas? If I did that might as well keep them with Punishers.
Use the points gained by dropping the 2 russes to give your troops camo, grenadiers and plasmaguns. You can go to ground in area terrain for a 2+ and most ignore cover weapons only have AP5 or worse.
This I actually like and understand, why x1 Squad has it so they can hang back on an objective while others advance on objectives. Lack of points only reason why, and no Special Weapons to save points for more Tanky goodness!
Swap the vendetta for armoured sentinels (3 in individual units is good) to use as countercharge/tarpit units.
Dont agree with this as if I lose the Vendetta I have no
AA capability with this list at all. Now realize im not arguing all your points as I do appreciate the advice, just discussing the list which is the whole point.
The best thing about 24' range tanks with tank commanders is that you get them to go flat-out to get them into a good position if your opponent stays out of range. So that is great if you need to get your punishers up the board. But you will then loose you vanquisher fire, which is something you want first turn, especially if I have a ravager, or manticore or something similar that is a huge threat to your army. Putting a punisher and demolisher together is good because if you need to flat-out them you arent sacrificing any firepower. Your vanquishers can then go to work straight away.
The vanquishers would still be advancing, and sponson multimeltas a cheap and good. Mixed with primaris psykers they are great, they are even decant against fliers.
How about something like:
Tanks Commander - Punisher w Heavy Bolters + Demolisher
Tanks Commander - Punisher w Heavy Bolters + Demolisher
Primaris
Primaris
Vets - Camo, Carapace, 2 Flamers, Heavy Flamer
Vets - Camo, Carapace, 3 Plasma
Vets - Camo, Carapace, 3 Plasma
Vets - Camo, Carapace, 3 Plasma, Flakk Missiles
Vets - Camo, Carapace, 3 Plasma, Flakk Missiles
Vendetta
Vanquisher - Lascannon, Sponson Multimeltas
Vanquisher - Lascannon, Sponson Multimeltas
Probably still not enough tanks for you :-)
Better yet put your list together and try it out using some proxies to see hoe it works.