Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you:
No adverts like this in the forums anymore.
Times and dates in your local timezone.
Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance.
Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely.
Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net.
If you are already a member then feel free to login now.
2014/11/07 19:01:41
Subject: Psychic Shriek. Do you roll to hit? HIWPI Poll
FlingitNow wrote: Where's your permission to stop the process at step 4 on a miss?
Check page 30 paragraph 2 as that tells us to do all 7 steps. So page and paragraph where a miss stops the process please or is that yet more made up rules?
Just because nothing happens at steps 5-7 for attacks that do not hit does not mean those steps are not performed.
How to resolve Psychic Shriek is still an open issue. If you want to open up a thread to discuss it, feel free to do so. This thread is not the place for rules discussion.
2014/11/07 23:45:37
Subject: Psychic Shriek. Do you roll to hit? HIWPI Poll
FlingitNow wrote: Where's your permission to stop the process at step 4 on a miss?
Check page 30 paragraph 2 as that tells us to do all 7 steps. So page and paragraph where a miss stops the process please or is that yet more made up rules?
Just because nothing happens at steps 5-7 for attacks that do not hit does not mean those steps are not performed.
How to resolve Psychic Shriek is still an open issue. If you want to open up a thread to discuss it, feel free to do so. This thread is not the place for rules discussion.
That has no direct relation to ps, it is just confirming that blaktoofs assertions are unfounded, and directly contradicted by the rules.
Blaktoof - to correct your misunderstanding / poor recollection, you were asked to prove that assertion first well before the thread was locked, and never did.
2014/11/07 23:48:41
Subject: Psychic Shriek. Do you roll to hit? HIWPI Poll
FlingitNow wrote: Where's your permission to stop the process at step 4 on a miss?
Check page 30 paragraph 2 as that tells us to do all 7 steps. So page and paragraph where a miss stops the process please or is that yet more made up rules?
Just because nothing happens at steps 5-7 for attacks that do not hit does not mean those steps are not performed.
How to resolve Psychic Shriek is still an open issue. If you want to open up a thread to discuss it, feel free to do so. This thread is not the place for rules discussion.
That has no direct relation to ps, it is just confirming that blaktoofs assertions are unfounded, and directly contradicted by the rules.
Blaktoof - to correct your misunderstanding / poor recollection, you were asked to prove that assertion first well before the thread was locked, and never did.
If you want to open up a thread to discuss it, feel free to do so. This thread is not the place for rules discussion.
2014/11/07 23:52:26
Subject: Psychic Shriek. Do you roll to hit? HIWPI Poll
It is a place to correct inaccuracies however. If you disagree, maybe start your own thread. Or, instead of posting off topic, maybe hit the yellow triangle of friendship instead.
This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2014/11/07 23:53:00
2014/11/07 23:58:48
Subject: Psychic Shriek. Do you roll to hit? HIWPI Poll
nosferatu1001 wrote: It is a place to correct inaccuracies however. If you disagree, maybe start your own thread. Or, instead of posting off topic, maybe hit the yellow triangle of friendship instead.
You are off-topic. Blaktook posted per thread purpose. Take your discussion of inaccuracies elsewhere.
You're off topic, no you're off topic, nuh-uh yuh-huh
If you can't play nicely, you don't get to play. Some of you probably need to step away from these sort of discussions for a couple of hours/a day and calm down, because some of you are skirting warnings
I wish I had time for all the game systems I own, let alone want to own...
