Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

So if you want to field a WK that isn't the CC one or the Hellstorm template one, which would you bring?
Overall, I like the Wraithcannon WK to take out AV targets or MCs. This WK is a staple of most of my lists and I don't field much else that can deal with AV13+ targets
However, I finally got ahold of the Skatach WK rules and I really want to try out the Inferno Lances.

Everyone knows the potential of the ranged-D WK, but I look at the Inferno lances and thing that they could achieve a similar result without the "win big, lose big fishing for 6"
I also sometimes find myself without a great target for 2 single D shots. Multiple Str8 shots might gone in handy in more situations without losing too much ability to take out another Knight.
The other thing I like about the Inferno lance WK is the split fire. Yes the Wraithcannon Knight can split fire as well, but with only 1 shot per gun, I often find myself shooting the same target to ensure damage to a particular target. The Inferno lances have a much better number of shots and I feel more comfortable splitting fire.

Guide or Prescience seem to go farther on the Inferno lances as well.
Often I either really need to twin-link the WC WK, or both shots hit anyway.
The Inferno lances allow me to not always need to cast Guide/Prescience, but if I do, it will most likely show a result since a few shots are bound to miss.

Thoughts?

In a format with nerfed D, I prefer the infernos for the reasons you listed above. More shots and spread of ap1 across the table.

Something to consider is how much are those single shots going to help versus the 6 - 10 from the infernos? Against another wraithknight, cannons work well, but riptides, iknights, and gladius will be much more scared of the infernos. It's all about the consistency that you want to achieve. Infernos are solid and produce average hits while cannons can spike with 6s.

The other advantage of the Inferno Lance over the HWCs is that they are not D. We don't modify D in my area, so it can be pretty strong. Not have ranged D will be appreciated, as well as having a slightly more expensive WK that has to get closer to pop Knights and cannot instant-kill T5 models

It really is the best of both worlds: Competitive without being the TFG choice. I look forward to using it in my lists

Another thing to note about the Skathach is that it can take a Scatterfield with a ranged weapon, it might reduce your firepower but given the threat the Wraithknight poses just by being there it'll be a prime target and bullet soak, the the 5++ can be useful in keeping it alive for a bit longer.

I tried both and like the inferno cannons way more. They are super consistent compared to the wraith cannons. I find they feel less awful to play against as well. Having a wraith cannon roll a single lucky 6 just doesn't feel satisfying for either party. Plus I think it is mathematically better against most targets so it not only a superior choice competitively, but it will also end up feeling like more fun to play with and against.

Also the Skathach's ability to jump out of close combat is pretty amazing and well worth the points.

 coblen wrote:
Plus I think it is mathematically better against most targets so it not only a superior choice competitively, but it will also end up feeling like more fun to play with and against.

I feel the same way. I play in a semi-competitive, but mostly casual area, so not being ranged D will feel more appropriate & fun for both players.

 coblen wrote:
Also the Skathach's ability to jump out of close combat is pretty amazing and well worth the points.

I'm still waiting on the official FAQ to actually use this. I'll be glad to use the "jump into ongoing reserves" portion of the rule, but since RAW could result in not being able to jump out of CC (since you cannot voluntarily move while locked in CC, so how can to do any action that replaces movement) I'd rather not risk the argument.

 Imateria wrote:
Another thing to note about the Skathach is that it can take a Scatterfield with a ranged weapon, it might reduce your firepower but given the threat the Wraithknight poses just by being there it'll be a prime target and bullet soak, the the 5++ can be useful in keeping it alive for a bit longer.

Agreed, that is one of the coolest things about the Skatach Knights, particularly if I was using a Deathshroud since it has to get close for the template. I'll be using either a VSG, or more likely a Landing Pad. So I'll have a 4++ against shooting for the first turn or 2 with the Inferno Lance WK. I'd really only need the 5++ if I intend on using the WK aggressively, in which case I would use the Glaive/Shield WK.

-