I would not call it exacly that. In fact it is quiet handy to strike with S5 AP2 at Initiative 3 (I.e. well before most other
AP 2 on non
IC.) The old rule wasn't that good, as you need to be nearly fully sourrounded to get the best of it and you were attacing at same time as Powerfist, which mostlikely ended the fight in mutual destruktion. Now with the New rule, you strike first and live to see the end of the fight.