Switch Theme:

Cease & Desist letter sent to Dakka on behalf of Resin Forge & its owner Daniel Mandelbaum  [RSS] Share on facebook Share on Twitter Submit to Reddit
»
Author Message
Advert


Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you:
  • No adverts like this in the forums anymore.
  • Times and dates in your local timezone.
  • Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance.
  • Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely.
  • Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net.
If you are already a member then feel free to login now.




Made in be
Impassive Inquisitorial Interrogator




TERRA

@Howard A Treesong:

Well, I'd say either he's very good at finding and picking out gullible people or he's very good at brainwashing them. In both cases he would have been better off founding a sect than going into the miniatures business.

Here a relatively fresh example of one of his staunch defenders (who nevertheless had chosen to cancel his own HH weekender order due to "sudden financial restraints"):

DLtEM:
I have read a lot of the facebook and dakka threads, and there are instances of people claiming they have no stock and just try and scam you, which there is no concrete evidence for.

I personally do think that there are sides. There is RF, terrible communication and all. And everyone on dakka and lex with the witch hunt.
I don't know if there are multiple admins on Lex, but there are definitely some instances of the "unbiased reporter" instigating the conflict. Just stating that you are unbiased doesn't make you unbiased.
I can make as many claims as I want, and that doesn't make them true.
If I go on a random forum and claim that I bought ten trillion dollars worth of dark age technology from Dan Abnett and that I only received half of it, that doesn't make it true.
RF definitely could have handled the situation better, but so could lex and dakka(and subsequently all the people that involves as I know it is not just one entity).

I guess I would like to say that I am done with this huge witch hunt. It has already taken more of my time than I would have cared for it to.


So to everybody their own

   
Made in es
Fresh-Faced New User




Hi guys, I'm new here. I've been reading about this drama going on since Lex posted it on facebook and have followed this and the previous deleted thread.

I wanted to write my opinion since Dome has started posting here because maybe you guys need the perspective of someone not involved with either party but who "could" be a potential costumer of RF and has found about this thread. Maybe that will give you insight as to what you are thinking is important to let the people new to this issue know and how to put a clearer case on the matter.

First of all I don't know any of you and even if you all lot sound really convincing and mature about this I have to take your word on most stuff that you said. I've read most of the two threads and what you claim as evidence of this guy Daniel as "allegedly" having scammed people in the past, to me that I wasn't there when he did that is just testimonies. In fact the only one I can recall after reading a great deal about it is the case about this forum poster that was recently finally refunded his money. Again what I read in this thread was only his side of the story with no proof about his case. WhichI believe of course but then again, I wouldn't expect everyone else would. I'm sure he did post the evidence somewhere at some point in time but that is lost to me since I couldn't see the reference anywhere, just his posts talking about it.

I read the first post of the old thread, it contained a summary of what this guy has done in his previous endeavours, which, to the point in case, is the most important part of the discussion because he has not done anything "bad" as part of RF "yet". To outsiders going over 40 pages of talking how bad his grammar is (which it is), how terrible a PR mess this is (again I agree) does not help anyone believe anything rather than you guys are pretty serious about watching every step he takes but nothing more. To some it might even look like this is a witch hunt with not enough proof to have a solid motive (again, not my case).

My advice to you guys is this: I know it's hard and many of the old post are gone (I clicked the links when I found the old thread, some weredead) or are too long to read again about the old cases. Make a summary of the people you know have "allegedly" been scammed in the past, add as much facts to it as you can, make it undeniable. That will speak for itself and people like Dome will only be able to come here and say "well they didn't wrong ME, so I think they are fine", which is a terrible selfish thing to say imo, but it will be clear that is their only position since facts will really be out in the table and not just in the memories of those who were round when the "alleged" scams actually happened.

To actual, potential customers, seeing how people were "allegedly" ripped off buy this guy will be more than enough to be scared away, even more than proving if the guy went or not to the weekender or if he got the fulgrims one way or another. I see you are trying to find a potential scam on his acts, but don't forget that it may not happen and you are using all your energies on something I think might not be as useful as pointing out the facts of the past.

I apologise in advance if I overlooked this threads and failed to read those facts (and by facts I don'tmean posts about people saying "I was scammed", I mean proof of it), I just wanted to express my point of view for you to make a stronger case about this.

Also nice to meet you guys, I'll be lurking a bit around the rest of the threads now that I've found you (I'm relatively new to the hobby)

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 08:35:24


 
   
Made in ca
Blood Angel Chapter Master with Wings






Sunny SoCal

I really, really don't get the 'claims' business...

Do we have 100% incontrovertible proof or everything we state suspicions on? No.

BUT

There is an absolute crap ton of stuff that is proven, and not only that, admitted to at various points by Mandelbaum himself! Don't take our word for it, take his lol!

He did leave many customers high and dry. He did use various aliases. He did use the excuse of a fictional wife and child both dying of cancer. He did use the good reputation of others to hide himself and commit further unscrupulous actions against customers. He did pretend to be his mother with me personally. He has harassed a dozen or more people by e-mail and phone. He did call someone's work to try and get them fired. He did participate In a fraudulent c and d.

None of this stuff is up or debate, it happened and is corroborated. Is it proven in a ourt of law? No. But it doesn't mean rock solid evidence and his own confessions aren't there. Alleged is just a technicality on most of this stuff.

Get a clue people. If you are going to trust RF do it because you think the guy is reformed, not because you think the history above is somehow in question. Read the bloody evidence for the love of Pete.


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Edit, just saw the above post which went up while I was writing... A list of people still outstanding or harassed is a pretty good idea IMO...

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 08:02:20


   
Made in au
[MOD]
Not as Good as a Minion






Brisbane

 MajorTom11 wrote:

Edit, just saw the above post which went up while I was writing... A list of people still outstanding or harassed is a pretty good idea IMO...


If nothing else it will stop any claims that all this thread has is 'speculation on past problems he has had', turning it instead into 'a list of people who he has scammed that we have proof of'. Or this sort of thing
I've read most of the two threads and what you claim as evidence of this guy Daniel as having scammed people in the past, to me that I wasn't there when he did that is just testimonies. In fact the only one I can recall after reading a great deal about it is the case about this forum poster that was recently finally refunded his money.

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 08:12:17


I wish I had time for all the game systems I own, let alone want to own... 
   
Made in gb
Feldwebel




Tamworth, UK

The other issue is that part way through, this evolved into checking the veracity of RF's claims they were going to the HH Weekender, with the intention of bringing back. 'Luggage full of FW minis' (their words).
Once checking and questioning as to whether this would be happening, the obfuscation and cries of abuse from MandelBonder started in earnest.

He has still as of today yet to prove he, or any of his personalities attended the weekender - he's claimed he has done so through the FW email, which is untrue. He's claimed that he did so by posting boxes allegedly full of FW bits, which again is untrue.

This isn't a witch hunt. If it was, the net would be casting around for others.

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 08:50:46


 
   
Made in es
Fresh-Faced New User




 MajorTom11 wrote:
I really, really don't get the 'claims' business...

Do we have 100% incontrovertible proof or everything we state suspicions on? No.

BUT

There is an absolute crap ton of stuff that is proven, and not only that, admitted to at various points by Mandelbaum himself! Don't take our word for it, take his lol!

He did leave many customers high and dry. He did use various aliases. He did use the excuse of a fictional wife and child both dying of cancer. He did use the good reputation of others to hide himself and commit further unscrupulous actions against customers. He did pretend to be his mother with me personally. He has harassed a dozen or more people by e-mail and phone. He did call someone's work to try and get them fired. He did participate In a fraudulent c and d.

None of this stuff is up or debate, it happened and is corroborated. Is it proven in a ourt of law? No. But it doesn't mean rock solid evidence and his own confessions aren't there. Alleged is just a technicality on most of this stuff.

Get a clue people. If you are going to trust RF do it because you think the guy is reformed, not because you think the history above is somehow in question. Read the bloody evidence for the love of Pete.


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Edit, just saw the above post which went up while I was writing... A list of people still outstanding or harassed is a pretty good idea IMO...


Yeah, I get it, the guy is a jerk. But what I think is important is that people paid for something they didn't get. That's the proof I was refering to, and the one that I missed to see except for the cause of (I don't remember your nick, sorry!) the guy who recently got refunded. You guys keep saying "tons of people "allegedly" got scammed in the past" and "go and read the evidence". Please do point me that way, cause that's what I want to read. Again, not that I don't believe it when you say "people were scammed", but you talk about that evidence that got lost for me in the whole debate about how stupid and bad businessman this guy reallly is, which seems pretty obvious already.

Edit: my keyboard doesn't like spaces between words

This message was edited 2 times. Last update was at 2013/06/03 08:36:01


 
   
Made in jp
[MOD]
Anti-piracy Officer






Somewhere in south-central England.

May I remind people that the board's policy is not to refer to Resin Forge or Daniel Mandelbaum as a scammer or thief as he has not been in court on such charges.

I'm writing a load of fiction. My latest story starts here... This is the index of all the stories...

We're not very big on official rules. Rules lead to people looking for loopholes. What's here is about it. 
   
Made in gb
Feldwebel




Tamworth, UK

Kilkrazy - apologies, post edited to reflect correct posting guidelines.

Back OT - RF have announced that they will be releasing LLC details shortly, and that 'a former owner has left'.

We wait with baited breath....

But still no sign of any form of actual 'hard' proof of attendance to the HH weekender, nor of 'luggage a filled with FW stock'....
   
Made in jp
[MOD]
Anti-piracy Officer






Somewhere in south-central England.

It will be a big step for them to give a business registration number.

I'm writing a load of fiction. My latest story starts here... This is the index of all the stories...

We're not very big on official rules. Rules lead to people looking for loopholes. What's here is about it. 
   
Made in be
Impassive Inquisitorial Interrogator




TERRA

Long text ahead. From private message on Facebook. DW acting as communications mediator between Lexicanum and Resin Forge.


DW:
Hi guys,
I, like yourselves, want to bottom out the whole Resin Forge saga. I've had a great service from them on two occasions.
I have spoken with Resin Forge and I've told them the only way to get things back on track is to fully satisfy your concerns.
Could you please give me a few bullets covering exactly what you want answers to or addressed.
I will provide this list to Resin Forge with the idea that they answer them all.
Regards,
DW
----------
LEXICANUM:
Since we report on Dakkadakka's viewpoints it's basically the same list.
- business registration number/ tax number (only that will allow an independent check of who are owners)
- physical business address + official statements as to the names of former and current owners in an absultely clear way (not the usual jumping around without making a real statement)
- proof that they visited the Horus Heresy weekender (photos not taken from other people's pages)
- clear and precise statements as to if and till when Daniel Mandelbaum was co-owner of Resin Forge.

This would be the minimum questions to be answered.

You can also give uy the contact addresses that he gave you (physical addresses, not e-mail or phone).
----------

DW:
Hi Lex. Here is the response from Resin Forge:
- business registration number/ tax number (only that will allow an independent check of who are owners)

Done once we have Daniel officially removed as co-owner. That way the tax and business info match. If we list it now people will say he has never quit and wont. With proof showing he's gone, that ends that topic.


- physical business address + official statements about the names of former and current owners in an absolutely clear way (not the usual jumping around without making a real statement)

We are changing over addresses to a PO box which can be checked at the post office about who's name it is in. Lex says PO boxes are bad but frankly, after the harassment Daniel got, even if you all feel it's deserved, we do not wish the same. PO boxes can be tracked but it keeps drama away from our homes. We will discuss our results. Official statements have been provided on both Jason and I. First and last name in the C&D as well as my own paypal.

We were scammed by the very law firm but we told them to put all 3 owners to be OPEN AND HONEST. We did not hide anyone. We will not provide pictures of IDs as Daniels mother did that last year before she passed away and was still told he's fake. Then upon the very day she died this year, people talked about her badly. Then again on mother's day when people sent her dead lowers with her obituary picture stating rot in hell and other horrid things. Now they act like he plays the move psycho. No wonder he quit after kens claims was resolved by me and my personal account tied to RF.


- proof that they visited the Horus Heresy weekend (photos not taken from other people's pages)

This one will not happen. Pictures show Kim and Jason and we will NOT show what they look like. Even FW itself agreed to not show who we sent and told us flat-out they do not show list of people who were there. That's a clear violation of privacy. This topic also has ZERO to do with how we have made every order or refunded 3 people 2 of which we won the paypal dispute but refunded anyways. Jean, Midget Overlord as he goes by on dakka stated bluntly he talked to Jason and Daniel. Paypal is in my name. 3 owners. done. You also fail to mention the 8 people who wanted to sell us fulgrims. We didnt get really any extras but since we made less then a handful of sales total, it didnt matter.


- clear and precise statements as to if and till when Daniel Mandelbaum was co-owner of Resin Forge.

Once we find a law firm here that can write up the papers for a cost we can afford (soon) we will post those gladly showing Daniel has left the company for good. Thats documents that can be verified. Same goes with Business regestration. We need to remove him from it before showing hes gone, obviously. This would be the minimum questions to be answered. I assume for now as you always want more proof, which at this point we want this to end so ask away. But do not give us no time to provide what you want. We have lives and family too that take up our time as well.


You can also give uy the contact addresses that he gave you (physical addresses, not e-mail or phone).

No idea what this means.

----------

DW:
Again from Resin Forge:
-You can also give uy the contact addresses that he gave you (physical addresses, not e-mail or phone).
No idea what this means.

---------

DW:
Again from Resin Forge:
If he wants alternate proof for something we refuse to show, we are open to hear it.

----------

LEXICANUM:
That's free to publish?

"You can also give uy the contact addresses that he gave you"
That's addresses to which parcels by people who gave Mandelbaum models to convert were sent to. You can also ask if they will continue using the Mandelbaum office space PO boxes for business. And the Mandelbaum phone number to "contact" people who disagreed with them (aka continue to call up people's workplaces to get them fired).

Also: they don't have any pictures of any models from the HH weekender that does not show the two owners who went? Hiw did they manage that? Did they creep into the showcases? Did they jump in front of the powerpoint presentation? THat is kind of hard to believe somehow, what do you think?
---------

DW:
Resin Forge asked me to send you this from a e-mail from Tris at Forge World
ATTACHED ALREADY KNOWN SCREENSHOT OF FW MAIL
----------

DW:
Just sending your comments to Resin Forge
----------

LEXICANUM:
PLus let's make one things absolutely clear. You can also go and check that in all our past posts and on the Dakka thread. Nobody did say that Resin Forge was scamming people. It was and is all about the by now self confessed fact that Daniel Mandelbaum is/ was involved in that company that all that stuff came up. Daniel Mandelbaum has a mile long string of fraud allegations against him and the purpose was and is to protect people from falling for his tricks again. And although Resin Forge always claims that Dakka or others doubt they have real customers that got their stuff this is simply not true. The doubts were neither referring to their general stock, nor to the existence of all their customers, but quite specifically to the promises to get new customers for bringing stuff from the HH weekender.

And just as a sidenote: all the previous businesses or Daniel Mandelbaum also had satisfied and loyal customers. Until at some point all blew up and he disappeared.
----------

DW:
Resin Forge say comments can be published

My personal opinion is what does it matter about them being present at the event or not. They were able to fulfill most of the relevant requests and dealt professionally with those they couldn't. Just an opinion. Happy to discuss
------------

LEXICANUM:

That email [(NOTE: referring to FW email)] doesn't prove they went to the HH weekender, it just says that people from their "group" (why "group"? It should be a "business" or "company" or sth like that?) ordered products from Forgeworld. Which was not questioned.
-------------

DW:
I thought there was some question about actually having stock?
-------------

LEXICANUM:
No. That is what Resin Forge tries to make everybody believe. The question was and is that they claimed to go to the HH Weekender. Seriously, we are not lying to you. Resin Forge made that one up in order to present themselves as victims or whatever. If you would like to have a look at the Dakka thread you would see how often people said that it was about the HH weekender.
---------------

DW:
I'm not saying your lying dude
-----------

LEXICANUM:
It's just that it really gets on my nerves how this person/ persons manages to turn every frikkin't statement around. We just asked for denial or confirmation that Daniel Mandelbaum was behind Resin Forge in the beginning. And then they went ape on us. Really incredible.
-------------

DW:
Ok. I've not spoken directly to Resin Forge on this point but could this not be a confused point. I thought they honoured all requests for bits related to the event? Did someone not get what they requested and then not receive a refund?
---------------

DW:
Response from Resin Forge
Ok, one moment while I put them into a wordpad to actually read. Also, just looking over it, there are questions, mainly on Daniel, some we can talk about others we will not, simply because he is no long a part of the company and wont be 100% once the legal documents are signed. All of which will be from a Dallas Law Firm which can be verified. We want all information to be easily verifiable.

You can send that but ask him to wait while the rest is gone over closely to have proper responses.

-----------

DW:
Response from Resin Forge
At least in the interest of good will in these talks.

------------

LEXICANUM:
We haven't seen any proof that they ever went to the event. Or that they delivered any goods from the event. Which does NOT mean we say somebody did not get refunden. We just generally doubt that Resin Forge ever went to the event.

*refunded

@"You can send that but ask him to wait while the rest is gone over closely to have proper responses.": too late, already went out to the Dakka people after the first "ok".

-----------

DW:
Could it not be that when they said they would attend they meant they would have a presence in getting stock? I know they asked customers who were attending if they would be willing to help them get the items. Maybe a mistake to use those terms in hindsight

Ok can you take it down in while this is all sorted as a gesture of good will to get to the bottom of this?

Responses to all points are half complete

Sorry for the confusion

Do you mind me asking where in dakka this is going?
-----------

LEXICANUM:
Well, you can't get back messages. As you will notice, we did not put it up yet on the thread and FB page. That does not mean that we will stick to a seconf version if there are important changes of content.

As for them going to HH weekender
hhconfirm-cens.jpg
They also promised coverage of the HH weekender.
HHcoverage.jpg
Here: they clearly avoid the question here
hhorno.jpg
And here the completely clear statement that they were
going to the weekender
resinforgeweekender1.jpg

And in the first statement that you forwarded us they
say themselves:
"- proof that they visited the Horus Heresy weekend
(photos not taken from other people's pages)

This one will not happen. Pictures show Kim and Jason and we will NOT show what they look like. Even FW itself agreed to not show who we sent and told us flat-out they do not show list of people who were there. That's a clear violation of privacy. "


Does that convince you that they were telling their customers they were going to the weekender?
----------

DW:
Ok. By what you've posted it does appear they intended to attend and said as much.
----------

LEXICANUM:
Yep. So people want to see proof.

And they want to see proof because they don't believe that Daniel Mandelbaum has given up his old ways where would always construct such stories etc.

----------

DW:
I see the problem. What I'm not sure about is it's significance. Yes, they should not have said this if they did not intend to attend. But this issue seems to be purely about attendance at the event. But this did not lead them to promise stock they could not provide. Infact they were specific there would be limits
------------

LEXICANUM:
You see, this whole pile of gak started because Resin Forge refused to admit that Mandelbaum was in the boat (if not the captain of the boat). People by know even doubt the existence of the other "co-owners".

Did you read the Dakka thread? It would really, really help I think.

The relevance if they attended or not is that you can't say you run a legit business if you are accused of being a pathological liar. That starts with getting stuff from an event halfway across the globe and ends as the last times with people getting ripped off because they believed that his wife and kids died and therefore they did not claim their money back in time etc. This really is a general issue. Resin Forge does not seem able to make honest statements or not to contradict itself constantly.
----------

DW:
I've received answers from Resin Forge to the points. They just need to correct a mistake and I'll forward it.

-----------

LEXICANUM:
No hurry. BUt as for you, please, please have a look at this:
http://www.dakkadakka.com/dakkaforum/posts/list/526190.page

Ignore the "hate posts" in between, but please skim through. You will understand much better what is going on when having the complete story and not only what Resin Forge decided to pick out and publish on their page (not to mention what they decided to delete!).
LINK: Cease & Desist letter sent to Dakka on behalf of Resin Forge & its owner Daniel Mandelbaum -...
----------

DW:
Ok dude. Thank you. Answers incoming

"You can also give us the contact addresses that he gave you"
That's addresses to which parcels by people who gave Mandelbaum models to convert were sent to. You can also ask if they will continue using the Mandelbaum office space PO boxes for business. And the Mandelbaum phone number to "contact" people who disagreed with them (aka continue to call up people's workplaces to get them fired).


That is a clear no. We will not be using his address or even one close to him. Daniel used either his home address or his own personal business address which was a Suite, not a PO BOX. We will most likely use a PO BOX as after this whole drama with everyone, including Daniel, we do not want personal home addresses given out. In the US that is perfectly legal for a small company. We will list this PO BOX number which can easily be tracked by postal workers as to who owns it. We will also not be using his phone number any longer. His number he said will not change simply for people to reach him if they should have any claims against him. We also did not agree for him to call that persons place of work. We wanted Jason to be the one who is much calmer and was the one to deal with Midget overlord on dakka which we resolved even with a USPS mistake and tracking that simply did not update. (This can be easily looked up on page 2 of that thread.)


Also: they don't have any pictures of any models from the HH weekender that does not show the two owners who went? Hiw did they manage that? Did they creep into the showcases? Did they jump in front of the powerpoint presentation? THat is kind of hard to believe somehow, what do you think?


There are a total of 11 pictures but in all 11, the 2 staff are shown. Crowds were thick around the cases and once again, the staff that was there are small. And honestly scared over all the internet hate towards Daniel. Believe it or not, its the simple truth. Its also worth pointing out, the trip was not for the event. It was a trip planned in advance and then as the event was near the date planned, it was tossed in. The real trip was to simple visit friends.


Plus let's make one things absolutely clear. You can also go and check that in all our past posts and on the Dakka thread. Nobody did say that Resin Forge was scamming people. It was and is all about the by now self confessed fact that Daniel Mandelbaum is/ was involved in that company that all that stuff came up. Daniel Mandelbaum has a mile long string of fraud allegations against him and the purpose was and is to protect people from falling for his tricks again. And although Resin Forge always claims that Dakka or others doubt they have real customers that got their stuff this is simply not true. The doubts were neither referring to their general stock, nor to the existence of all their customers, but quite specifically to the promises to get new customers for bringing stuff from the HH weekender.


That may be true but the Lex fans used the word scam, ripoff, con, thief and many more over and over with rarely a censor. We do screen cap as well. Daniel's history was much more then we had thought. When we did find out we were not going to ditch him or the community just to leave the "hordes" left hanging. We set up a phone line and got 1 call which we are working to prove but records from then are hard for both sides to find. Even then and even with Daniel leaving we wish to continue to work with that person. We also worked with ken from Dakka ourselves. We have always treated our customers right and if a co owner had claims against him, we did check into them.

There is a bunch of internet rumors but none of those people step up

As for our new customers as you put it from the HH weekender, you have always grossly over estimated it. We sold at cost, to less then a handful of people. We did that as a promo to build rep for RF. But because of Daniel, Lex, Dakka and others, we are all but ruined. We put savings into this. And now we are nothing but scum for trying to help people for Daniel.


And just as a sidenote: all the previous businesses or Daniel Mandelbaum also had satisfied and loyal customers. Until at some point all blew up and he disappeared.


We are not going anywhere. We warn people with custom orders when it gets to be day 30. We are also phasing out those very custom orders due to delays by FW.

We want loyal, repeat customers. Not to scam people and vanish. That's why we are still here.


----------

DW:
Resin Forge have asked me to confirm the text is in 3rd person as it is written as a company.
-----------

LEXICANUM:
Well, they had weeks to clear things up. Instead they decided to go the aggression way and deny everything until it was way too late. They were given ample opportunity beforehand to react and make a statement concerning Daniel Mandelbaum. And come on, now they act surprised that people who have been ripped of by Mandelbaum in we don't know how many aliases explode as soon as he is sighted again. Oh please...

As for our fans or likers: we don't tell what to do. And pointing out that it was Resin Forge who brought the Lexicanum into this in the first place for having posts taken down and then brazenly claiming that Lexicanum was a hate page that had the homepage of their legal counsel deleted. We asked a simple question if Mandelbaum was in RF or not. And by then ALL the gakload of problems were already out. So since May 7th or around there they did not deign to clear that up until now. And they were informed WELL beforehand that if they wouldn't bring proof from the HH weekender, nobody would believe them. Nevertheless they decided on purpose not to bring back evidence? Oh pleaaaaaase. That's like the story that all eight people who wanted to sell their Fulgrims to Resin Forge were influenced by unknown persons to change their opinions.


So ok, let's assume for a second that anybody would buy that thing with them being in every picture. What's the explanation that they did not post photos of the entry tickets? Their names are already known, so?

Also the screenshot titled "resinforgeweekender1.jpg" compared to this statement " Its also worth pointing out, the trip was not for the event. It was a trip planned in advance
and then as the event was near the date planned, it was tossed in. The real trip was to simple visit friends."

This does not really add up either. And you see that's the essence of almost all statements from Resin Forge with or without Mandelbaum. They are very difficult to make sense out as in every case they look quite sketchy. Add to that old Mandelbaum emails feature the same grammatical and spelling errors as the newer RF without Mandelbaum ones and you will understand that these explanations are not exactly going to convince a lot of people.

Also: no photos of the Fulgrims they brought back. The yknew everybody wnated to see pics and they did not manage to take a photo of any of the HH only products without the owners in them?
---------

DW:
All good points. So do you believe this Daniel is still involved? Do I suggest to Resin Forge that one of the only ways to make some positive movement forwards is to show evidence of attendance at the HH weekender?
-----------

LEXICANUM:
Still involved? How to ascertain that? Only time will show that I guess... If he is, sooner or later the same will happen as in all the other businesses he was invlovedin. If he's not, RF could work. Or not, they already damaged themselves quite a lot.

But for sure if they won't come up with proof they were at HH weekender and that tax number to show they are at least a registered business on the names they claim, people will continue to ask questions. Quite understandably. And should it - in the worst case - really come out at a later point that Mandelbaum continues to be invloved contrary to the statements of now that he is gone, well then they are really, really royally fethed in the public opinion. And quite possibly also in the legal one if the documents are not filled out correctly. BUt we'll leave that for the future.

If you want to know if we personally believe this whole story. Well. Mandelbaum in the past already created whole armies of fake identities and multiple personalities to play different roles. So it's difficult not to at least take into consideration that the two other owners could be made up. Another reason for an official document stating clearly who is now standing in with their name for the whole thing. No matter what we personally believe, we will publish the statement that Mandelbaum is gone as according to Resin Forge, than people will have to make up their mind. Of course every contradictory statement at a later point will immediately bring back everybody to the point where we are now - just way quicker.

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 12:30:21


   
Made in ca
Blood Angel Chapter Master with Wings






Sunny SoCal

Interesting...

But for the photos, that is the thinnest most desperate excuse ever though, honestly. Crop the pictures. Black out the faces. You guys have a computer right? There is free software lol, just download it and blank the faces out!

Also, weekender attendance is very relevant because they pre sold items that were impossible to guarantee based on them eing there, they took money from people in a less than honest way even if tey did go... If they didn't... Well that old be tantamount to fraud in my book, once again they would have money in their account under false pretenses. It is incredibly relevant to their honesty and business practices.

   
Made in be
Impassive Inquisitorial Interrogator




TERRA

Sorry for the very long post. But by posting the unabridged version we want to counter later claims that we "selectively" put information.

   
Made in us
Blood Angel Captain Wracked with Visions






 MajorTom11 wrote:
Interesting...

But for the photos, that is the thinnest most desperate excuse ever though, honestly. Crop the pictures. Black out the faces. You guys have a computer right? There is free software lol, just download it and blank the faces out!

Also, weekender attendance is very relevant because they pre sold items that were impossible to guarantee based on them eing there, they took money from people in a less than honest way even if tey did go... If they didn't... Well that old be tantamount to fraud in my book, once again they would have money in their account under false pretenses. It is incredibly relevant to their honesty and business practices.

Pretty sure most Windows computers have MS Paint installed as factory standard. That allows for cropping and blanking out faces.

 
   
Made in us
Longtime Dakkanaut





Florida

I know this is a hot topic right now and I've been following this thread since the beginning but this:

 Inquisitor S. wrote:
Did they creep into the showcases? Did they jump in front of the powerpoint presentation?


Made me literally lol.
   
Made in be
Impassive Inquisitorial Interrogator




TERRA

But for the photos, that is the thinnest most desperate excuse ever though, honestly. Crop the pictures. Black out the faces. You guys have a computer right? There is free software lol, just download it and blank the faces out!


There are also tons of browser-java-flash based freewares. There is no need to download and install. BUt let's NOT get sidetracked by this technical question, I think everybody agrees that editting a photo should be a matter of minutes at most.


   
Made in gb
Ferocious Blood Claw




Gran Brettan

Well either way i think we are approaching End Game (Meddlebonder has gone and we wish RF all the best or Time to watch for the rabbit as it bolts for the new hole)

We dont serve no Mint Julip here !! 
   
Made in us
Decrepit Dakkanaut






New Orleans, LA

 insaniak wrote:
Resin Forge wrote:It shows that our staff has been customers for years, even before Resin Forge started. It shows we call on orders, check on customer updates, and frankly, it shows we run a legit company.

It shows the first of those. I'm still a little puzzled as to how it proves anything else.


Exactly. I'm not sure how Dan is proving anything with these.

I just logged into FW to check: I've made 10 FW orders for my gaming group since Sept 16, 2010 totaling 1790 British Pound Moneys (~$2700 American moneys). I have an email from each of these orders.

That doesn't mean I own a legitimate business, nor does it prove how handsome I am.

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 13:38:55


DA:70S+G+M+B++I++Pw40k08+D++A++/fWD-R+T(M)DM+
 
   
Made in us
Blood Angel Captain Wracked with Visions






 kronk wrote:
Exactly. I'm not sure how Dan is proving anything with these.

I just logged into FW to check: I've made 10 FW orders for my gaming group since Sept 16, 2010 totaling 1790 British Pound Moneys (~$2700 American moneys). I have an email from each of these orders.

That doesn't mean I own a legitimate business.

It does now. Welcome to the world of high powered business


In all seriousness though if Resin Forge to take steps to distance themselves from what has happened previously, can demonstrate that they are a legitimate business etc. then it may so some way to repairing the damage done, as well as act as a cautionary tale to always make sure you know who you are involving yourself with.

This message was edited 2 times. Last update was at 2013/06/03 13:40:21


 
   
Made in jp
[MOD]
Anti-piracy Officer






Somewhere in south-central England.

Yes, a bit of a text wall there. I was unable to get through to the end.

Hi Lex. Here is the response from Resin Forge:
- business registration number/ tax number (only that will allow an independent check of who are owners)

Done once we have Daniel officially removed as co-owner. That way the tax and business info match. If we list it now people will say he has never quit and wont. With proof showing he's gone, that ends that topic.


They ought to publish their current reg number to show they are a legally constituted company now with Mandelbaum as a director/partner. When registered again without Mandelbaum they can publish the changed registration, or tell people it is done, which will not show Mandelbaum as a director.

To be clear, it is the business registration number required by Texan law that will help people.

I'm writing a load of fiction. My latest story starts here... This is the index of all the stories...

We're not very big on official rules. Rules lead to people looking for loopholes. What's here is about it. 
   
Made in be
Impassive Inquisitorial Interrogator




TERRA

Well either way i think we are approaching End Game (Meddlebonder has gone and we wish RF all the best or Time to watch for the rabbit as it bolts for the new hole)


Assuming we do see something that actually looks halfway like a legit document showing who onws RF. Waiting for it


Automatically Appended Next Post:
Statement from Resin Forge as published on their Facebook page:

Here is a pretty picture to go along with a simple reminder for our customers and future customers.

The customer service number has been pushed down pretty far down. However it is now also listed in the about us section which we will also shortly have our LLC info showing the 2 remaining owners, company address, as well as the UK laws (we are US based, however we will comply to UK laws) that require a company to do those very things. Our customer service number is 1-214-632-6446, 9am - 9m Monday - Saturday. If we are on the phone with a customer or are unable to pick up right then, we will call you right back ASAP.

On a lighter note, what Mechanicum style unique ranged weapon would this robot have?

PS the number has nothing to do with being left up because of the former owner who quit. Its there for our own customers. If someone does have a problem with the former co owner, call us, or email us. We will provide contact info for him.


This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 13:57:06


   
Made in gb
Feldwebel




Tamworth, UK

They don't need to post photos - all they need are:
Flight tickets / boarding passes
Receipts of sale from the HH Weekender...
Either of those would prove they were there - combine with a current Co. registration and BLAMMO! Case closed on whether its MandelBonder on his own or not.
   
Made in us
Blood Angel Captain Wracked with Visions






Please forgive my ignorance of such things, but wouldn't a company formed in the United States be beholden to US law rather than UK law?

 
   
Made in be
Impassive Inquisitorial Interrogator




TERRA

They don't need to post photos - all they need are:
Flight tickets / boarding passes
Receipts of sale from the HH Weekender...
Either of those would prove they were there - combine with a current Co. registration and BLAMMO! Case closed on whether its MandelBonder on his own or not.


Well, I assume you mean photos or scans of said documents. I am not going to believe in typed up stuff.


   
Made in gb
Feldwebel




Tamworth, UK

Precisely. I meant photos of persons, rather than items.
I still find it amazing that they were claiming they would be 'covering' the even but then managed zero photos of ANYTHING.
Hell, even at the busiest GD when I was volunteering I came away with some cracking pictures without anyone but the mini is in them...

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 14:23:43


 
   
Made in jp
[MOD]
Anti-piracy Officer






Somewhere in south-central England.

 Dreadclaw69 wrote:
Please forgive my ignorance of such things, but wouldn't a company formed in the United States be beholden to US law rather than UK law?


Yes. In fact a company in Texas is beholden to Texan law, which requires that it be registered.

I'm writing a load of fiction. My latest story starts here... This is the index of all the stories...

We're not very big on official rules. Rules lead to people looking for loopholes. What's here is about it. 
   
Made in us
Blood Angel Captain Wracked with Visions






 Kilkrazy wrote:
Yes. In fact a company in Texas is beholden to Texan law, which requires that it be registered.

That's what I thought. It seems strange that a small Texan run business which operates on little to no profit margin would try to obey UK law, and possibly make a rod for their own back, by raising the possibility of having action taken against them in UK courts and having the added financial burden of employing legal counsel in the UK, as well as having to travel there when compelled to appear.

 
   
Made in us
Excellent Exalted Champion of Chaos






Lake Forest, California, South Orange County

 Kilkrazy wrote:
 Dreadclaw69 wrote:
Please forgive my ignorance of such things, but wouldn't a company formed in the United States be beholden to US law rather than UK law?


Yes. In fact a company in Texas is beholden to Texan law, which requires that it be registered.


In almost every state in the US, DBA registration is mandatory within 30 days of opening a business.


Also(forgive my own ignorance here) but weren't Fulgrims handed out at the time of purchase at HH? Why do people keep saying they "ordered" them at HH? I assumed they had stock on hand that they were selling.

Furthermore, quite a few things in the chain letter to Lex are sketchy. I've received no official apology for the behavior of Resin Forge in regards to the harassment of myself and my coworkers.

RF claims that Daniel quit, which I find rather odd. Why wouldn't they have fired him? Why did he quit? There is no proof that he is gone, and just leaving his name off some LLC paperwork doesn't mean that he is out of the picture.

None of the excuses RF has given hold any weight. They are all stall tactics. I've requested several times now that Kim call me up and straighten this all out, yet no call has been made.

RF dodges too many questions to be taken seriously.

"Bryan always said that if the studio ever had to mix with the manufacturing and sales part of the business it would destroy the studio. And I have to say – he wasn’t wrong there! ... It’s become the promotions department of a toy company." -- Rick Priestly
 
   
Made in us
Decrepit Dakkanaut






Leerstetten, Germany

Let them file a LLC without his name on it if he is still part of it all. I'm sure the Sec of State for Texas would love to see fraudulent documents being filed.

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 14:43:23


 
   
Made in us
Blood Angel Captain Wracked with Visions






 Aerethan wrote:
Also(forgive my own ignorance here) but weren't Fulgrims handed out at the time of purchase at HH? Why do people keep saying they "ordered" them at HH? I assumed they had stock on hand that they were selling.

I believe that the Fulgrim figures were available in a limited quantity, and when stocks ran out they could then be ordered at the event for dispatch later.

 Aerethan wrote:
RF dodges too many questions to be taken seriously.

That I think is a serious problem for any business when questions arise about it's conduct, etc. Allowing questions to remain does not build trust as the longer it goes on the more they look like they have something that they are attempting to hide. And in the absence of clear and unequivocal statements people will make such inferences as they see fit with whatever evidence is available.


Automatically Appended Next Post:
 d-usa wrote:
Let them file a LLC without his name on it if he is still part of it all. I'm sure the Sec of State for Texas would love to see fraudulent documents being filed.

If he was retained as an outside contractor /consultant/etc. would he still be on such documents?

This message was edited 1 time. Last update was at 2013/06/03 15:00:13


 
   
Made in us
Decrepit Dakkanaut






Leerstetten, Germany

I think they should bring him back. The responses have become much more like Mandelbaum ever since he has left. Maybe they will be less Daniel like if he returns to the company...
   
 
Forum Index » Dakka Discussions
Go to: