dkellyj wrote:CreepyCrawly wrote:Painting was scored out of 20 on the rubric, then your scored out of 20 was doubled to give 40 points possible. For instance, I scored an 8 out of 20, and I received 16 "paint points" towards my overall score.
So instead of 18 out of 40 its 9 out of 20...still less than 1/2. It would be interesting to see pics of the top armies that still score that low and what the rubric/judge was looking for.
I don't have pictures, but here's the scoring sheet.
Player#:___ Player Name: _____________________ Club Name:__________________
Basing: (0-2 points)
0 points: Basic sand, flock, gravel. You meet the requirements to play, not much more.
1 point: Drybrushed sand and flock, painted pattern, drybrushed resin.
2 points: Sculpted bases, intricate resin bases, overall army theme. Bases have been painted to a high level, or have multiple levels of drybrushed efects and basing materials for a natural look. Water Effects or sculpted flames. Time has obviously been spent on each model's base.
Coherency and Theme: (0-3)
1 point: Army is correctly put together. No huge gaps, or broken pieces. While each piece is put together correctly, they may not match well with models in the unit, or with other models in the army. Judge should use his judgement about this, as some armies vary quite a bit over their range, and others are very regimented. (an army that would score a 2 or 3 but has broken models would lose 1 point off that score).
2 points The army has an over all theme to the paint scheme, with the same color pallet.
3 points: The army has the same paint scheme, with consistant quality and work across the army. It ties in well together, and presented as a whole, is more than the sum of it’s parts. Camo patterns, squad markings, conversions, can all play a part in this.
Highlighting, Washes, Blending, and overall army quality. (0-7 points possible.)
0 points: Why is this army here? It's not fully painted. No, primer isn't a color!
1 point: The army is fully painted. It lacks most highlighting. It might have a wash put over it or be dipped. Might have a couple models that aren't really fully painted.
2 points: The army has dry brushing or some highlighting done to it. Possibly just on characters. It's a decent tabletop army. Much better than what you see at the typical gaming store, but still not really ready for taking to a
GT. Could be obviously be base coated and dipped with some details done. Could also be a work in progress with just base coats and a wash. Little fine detail.
3 points: Complex dry brushing with several colors, or highlighting with more than one layer. Use of washes. Some detail work done on most models. Characters have had highlighting and fine details added. An average army that you see at a large tournament or
GT.
4 points: Several layers of highlighting with smooth transitions. No clumsy drybrushing. Detail work done on most models: teeth, fangs, claws, skulls, shoulder pads, etc. Characters stand out from the rest of the army. Better than average tournament army. Could also be an army that would score a 5 or 6, but has some obvious flaws that knock it down some.
5 points: Skilled use of blending, washing, and highlights. Good attention to detail. A high quality tournament army.
6 points: As number 5, but to a higher level. You could see this army could easily compete for best painted at most tournaments.
7 points: Superb level of painting. Every model has had a lot of time and attention. All small detail work has been done on each model.
Character models have had hours of work done on each one and stand out. You could easily see parts of this army entered in
Golden Demon and making at least the first cut. Armies will rarely get this score.
Fine details, free hand, banners. (0-3 points.)
0 points: Little work has been done on details. Maybe simple white on teeth or claws. Army is finished, but not much work has been
done on each model individually.
1 point: Small details painted on most models. Fangs, claws, eys, belt buckles. etc
2 points: Nicely painted banners, icons, eyes, and simple freehand work. Rivets on vehicles stand out, searchlights painted like glass
Shoulderpad icons, vehicle numbers, tatoos or warpaint,
3 points: Incredible detail, extreme freehand on banners, tatoos, or flame effects. Eyes painted on all models. Fangs and teeth have
multiple layers. Wiring, rivets, and damage on vehicles stands out.
Modeling and Conversions (0-3 points)
0 points: Not much done to the army. Very vanilla out of the box. Maybe a couple of small things, but not very generic and minimal..
1 point: Some models have been reposed or had extra equipment added. Character or general has custom work. A vehicle has had
some bits of work done to it. Minor greenstuff work. Head or weapon swaps. Trophy racks, etc.
2 points: Either most of the army has had minor work done to it, or the army has some pieces that have had major conversions done to
them. Custom models, large amounts of good quality sculpting.
3 points: Major conversion work has been done to the army, and it's very obvious at a glance. Vehicles has extra armor, battle damage,
and unique elements.
Note: Conversion probably is the most wide open of catagories, ecompassing many different things. Subtle variations to high elves or necrons might be harder to pull off than flashy things on Orks or Chaos. Judges may use their discretion to give points in this catagory for a number of things that just don't fit elsewhere. An example might be a full army of forgeworld Deathkorp models.
Display Board (0-2 points)
0 points: No display board, or something you just use to move models around with. Does not match your army, little work done.
1 point: A Basic board. Sand gravel and flocking, hopefully matching the army. Does the job, looks good.
2 points: A themed display board with scenic elements that match the army, and adds to the overall effect when displayed with the army.
Even a fabulous display board is only worth 2 points, so these may have a wide range of skill and looks. For more points, you
should work on your army.
.....Bay Area Open GT 2013 - Best Tyranids 
