Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Because of my excellent organisational skills.

 Manchu wrote:
So MDW, you wanted the wolf/wolves to win? That explains your posts. But it doesn't explain why people voted for you. I was so confused by the villagers' play style in this game ...

Not surprisingly, several of those who banded together are friends/frequent online chat buddies/DOOMFART associates.

There was no cult involved.

No cults here, no sirree.

No Werewolf worshipping cultists no sir.

Wait, so there were TWO werewolves?

Why did you guys vote for the werewolf cultist?

DOUBLE POST EDIT

 Manchu wrote:
Why did you guys vote for the werewolf cultist?

I voted to harvest barley. I was suspicious of the alliance between the group (but tried to join in nonetheless).

It was too late I figured out purplefood was a werewolf.

The most votes for MrDWhitey occurred due to them being associated outside the forums.

Simply put the more cohesive group "won" the game.

 WarOne wrote:

 JB wrote:
Wait, so there were TWO werewolves?

Not surprising as we lost two people in one night earlier in the game.

Well, on to the next village.

Can we name it Yaksfacenhoff?

Nobody read the OP very thoroughly, it seems.

 WarOne wrote:

 Manchu wrote:
Why did you guys vote for the werewolf cultist?

I voted to harvest barley.

It was too late I figured out purplefood was a werewolf.

The most votes for MrDWhitey occurred due to them being associated outside the forums.

Simply put the more cohesive group "won" the game.

Neither I nor Purplefood were werewolves.

 MrDwhitey wrote:

 WarOne wrote:

 Manchu wrote:
Why did you guys vote for the werewolf cultist?

I voted to harvest barley.

It was too late I figured out purplefood was a werewolf.

The most votes for MrDWhitey occurred due to them being associated outside the forums.

Simply put the more cohesive group "won" the game.

Neither I nor Purplefood were werewolves.

Indeed, Alex and I take that crown. *performs stage bow*

 MrDwhitey wrote:

 WarOne wrote:

 Manchu wrote:
Why did you guys vote for the werewolf cultist?

I voted to harvest barley.

It was too late I figured out purplefood was a werewolf.

The most votes for MrDWhitey occurred due to them being associated outside the forums.

Simply put the more cohesive group "won" the game.

Neither I nor Purplefood were werewolves.

For all intents and purposes though, sabotaging the game for the werewolf side counts you against the rest of the group. Not much better than the werewolves.

Of course, its all a game and we move on !

 WarOne wrote:

 MrDwhitey wrote:

 WarOne wrote:

 Manchu wrote:
Why did you guys vote for the werewolf cultist?

I voted to harvest barley.

It was too late I figured out purplefood was a werewolf.

The most votes for MrDWhitey occurred due to them being associated outside the forums.

Simply put the more cohesive group "won" the game.

Neither I nor Purplefood were werewolves.

For all intents and purposes though, sabotaging the game for the werewolf side counts you against the rest of the group. Not much better than the werewolves.

Of course, its all a game and we move on !

In all fairness, they didn't know I was a werewolf until last night, when we'd already won. I simply used their plans to cover our tracks.

Well that sets the record straight.

On to the next game!

I knew that it was possible to have two werewolves but the low body count lulled my suspicions.

There was probably little chance that anyone but Dwhitey was ever going to be the Braumeister.

I'm assuming the other werewolf would be Alex_Awesomest?

 JB wrote:
I knew that it was possible to have two werewolves but the low body count lulled my suspicions.

There was probably little chance that anyone but Dwhitey was ever going to be the Braumeister.

It actually benefits the Werewolf(s) to not attack every night. Yes, killing people gets you closer to winning the game, but it also depletes your buffer of suspicion.

WarOne wrote:I'm assuming the other werewolf would be Alex_Awesomest?

Avatar 720 wrote:

 MrDwhitey wrote:
Neither I nor Purplefood were werewolves.

Indeed, Alex and I take that crown. *performs stage bow*

You'd be correct in your assumption.

His going away for the weekend really helped both throw suspicion off of him and lend credence to the belief that there was only one werewolf.

Nobody having read this part:

the Werewolf or Werewolves must send a PM to the moderator with the name of the living player they want to kill that night (one per night regardless of the number of Werewolves); if the moderator only receives one PM, the player named in that PM will be considered the target

of the OP helped a lot, too. For those in game 2, 1 kill does not = 1 werewolf.

 JB wrote:
There was probably little chance that anyone but Dwhitey was ever going to be the Braumeister.

There was no rational reason for this but no even attempted to argue that.

 Platuan4th wrote:
It actually benefits the Werewolf(s) to not attack every night.

The wolves attacked every night.

the Werewolf or Werewolves must send a PM to the moderator with the name of the living player they want to kill that night (one per night regardless of the number of Werewolves)

 Manchu wrote:

 Platuan4th wrote:
It actually benefits the Werewolf(s) to not attack every night.

The wolves attacked every night.

the Werewolf or Werewolves must send a PM to the moderator with the name of the living player they want to kill that night (one per night regardless of the number of Werewolves)

I know, I meant in general for games of Werewolf/Mafia.

 Avatar 720 wrote:
Nobody having read this part:

the Werewolf or Werewolves must send a PM to the moderator with the name of the living player they want to kill that night (one per night regardless of the number of Werewolves); if the moderator only receives one PM, the player named in that PM will be considered the target

of the OP helped a lot, too. For those in game 2, 1 kill does not = 1 werewolf.

You are correct in assuming that I missed that part.

 Manchu wrote:

 JB wrote:
There was probably little chance that anyone but Dwhitey was ever going to be the Braumeister.

There was no rational reason for this but no even attempted to argue that.

There is a very rational reason but it is no longer relevant in Game 2.

 JB wrote:
There is a very rational reason but it is no longer relevant in Game 2.

Pray tell?

So now let us commence the slaughter yet again.

This was way too much fun the first go around.

Now that it's over, I assume us normies can post here...I suspected Whitey if being a werewolf from the beginning: anyone who called him turned up dead. It was too suspicious, and maybe that's why everyone let him slide: he was so obvious that it couldn't be him. I still would have lynched him day two.

I would wish to join in the next slaughter.

 timetowaste85 wrote:
Now that it's over, I assume us normies can post here...I suspected Whitey if being a werewolf from the beginning: anyone who called him turned up dead. It was too suspicious, and maybe that's why everyone let him slide: he was so obvious that it couldn't be him. I still would have lynched him day two.

Read the DCM thread, there's a reason for that.

Also, vote me Braumaster for the next town, I have halberds and pole arms for our guards and not wimpy swords that require you to get within reach of stinky dogs!

Platuan4th, a Braumaster that cares!

 Manchu wrote:

 JB wrote:
There was probably little chance that anyone but Dwhitey was ever going to be the Braumeister.

There was no rational reason for this but no even attempted to argue that.

It was important that he stayed braumaster, mainly for the continued existence of mine and Alex's cover. He always had at least 4 votes (himself, purple, alex, and me) and we relied on the complete lack of organisation amongst the other villagers to keep him in. So long as we voted in a braumaster and harvested crops, we'd instantly be under less suspicion. Losing three villagers in the first day/night pretty much sealed that entire part of the plan. A braumaster wasn't necessary, but whitey and purple's continued existence was, for whitey could be voted in again later. With the three deaths in the first day/night, and 4 votes secure on whitey's side, neither he nor purple could ever be hanged unless alex and me withdrew our support. We controlled their existence.

 Avatar 720 wrote:
the complete lack of organisation amongst the other villagers

This is what baffled me.

 Manchu wrote:

 Avatar 720 wrote:
the complete lack of organisation amongst the other villagers

This is what baffled me.

Some of us simply wanted to do our own thing for the sake of the thing. I was so enwrapped in pretending to be a horrible writer and harvest of barley that I barely paid any mind to the politics of the village.

kronk wanted to be drunk.

2 others died way too early to have any impact.

Let that be a lesson: vote or be lynched/mauled by werewolf.

I mainly hoped that people would immediately think d-usa is in on something because he opposed what was, at the time, a majority vote for braumaster, and would instead vote for whitey to secure the position. With CustomLime - d-usa's most vocal supporter - ending up dead, it seemed fairly logical that people would assume that siding with him meant death. After day/night 2, whitey's vote for braumaster could never fail.

EDIT: To add to the siding with d-usa = death, it was clear that the hunter had his eyes set upon d-usa's side, too, since he was the one who offed CustomLime. That couldn't have lent them much legitimacy.