Asterios wrote:BrianDavion wrote:Asterios wrote:
Crazyterran wrote:Lol, people thinking Guilliman did anything wrong. Back to 4chan with you!
The Imperium lasted ten thousand years on the back of him and Malcador. Could you imagine if Huron got a Legion's worth of Marines and then went rogue?
Compartmentalizing things, especially after the reveal of the ruinous powers, was a good thing. If what
FW said is canon (that members of the loyalist legions went traitor/chaos and vice versa) then Guilliman would know that the only way to ensure another Legion doesn't fall is to split them up, especially if him and his loyal brothers start dying off.
Out of universe, we wouldn't have all these cool successors like the Minotaurs, Raptors, Soul Drinkers (another good example of why things had to be split), etc. Not even mentioning that it's been
GW's fluff since the beginning.
who said Gulliman did anything wrong? as far as he'll see it, the Imperium has corrupted his fathers dream.
except sitting back in a huff because things have changed isn't in Gulliman's character, he'd not the pratical realities of the situation, develop ideas to change it so it could be better and move to impliment them in a realistic fashion. the
HH novels keep talking about Gulliman and his tendancy for "the pratical and the theoretical" he just doesn't seem the type to be in a huff.
He's more the type to save terra and the
IoM and THEN suggest reforms and changes
you would be surprised, Gulliman will try to change things but the
IoM will not wish to change, so he will leave the
IoM to fend for itself while setting up Ultramar for defenses against any and all who come calling.
would I now? do you have some deep insight into
GW's plans that allow you to state your opinion as fact? we both agree, Gulliman will try to change things, we both agree, Gulliman will meet resistance. where we DISAGREE, is what his response would be. I belive he'd take a long view, address what he can now, including stop the complete collapse agaiunst chaos, while doing so he'd slowly, and carefully begin steps for incremental changes etc. including taking steps to place people sympathetic to his views on the council. he'd be willing to abandon terra if it made sense sure, but he's not gonna sulk off to go elsewhere just because of a bit of beurcratic interia.