Totalwar1402 wrote:Although, theres no reason why an Inquisitor wouldnt requisition a Confessor and his gaggle of Penitent engines. If they were on hand and you were an Inquisitor, would you leave them in the Cathedral?
Thanks for the input, and I agree. The Witch Hunters codex did included Priests (Preachers) and Penitent Engines. However, I think that the Confessor/Conclave are pretty similar to the Inquisitor/Henchmen and having both options open would be a bit redundant. Removing the Confessor and friends also keeps the list streamlined and focused on Inquisition and Sisters of Battle rather than Inquisition +
SoB + Other Ecclesiarchical Elements. Additionally, early concensus seems to indicate that Jacobus and the Conclave are some of the codex's more powerful options. Giving them the axe is going to help further define the list, as it will stand apart a bit from the 'usual'
SoB list (as if there were enough Sisters players for there to be a usual list

). However, I was also thinking of getting a Confessor/Preacher type character in there as members of the Inquisitor's warband (along with a Sister Dialogous, and Sister Hospitalier). That would keep some of the Ecclesiarchical flavor in there, and help further develop the Warband as a swiss-army-knife unit.
All that being said, this variant still fails to deliver an effective 'Penitent Engine' replacement, so cutting the Engine out might be uncalled for- hopefully I can get a game in with them soon and see how it all pans out. Unfortunately, I don't have a Penitent Engine, so I won't know what I'm missing. I'm convinced that the day after I order a Penitent Engine or three,
GW will unveil an all new plastic one...