Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

A charmed shield negates the first hit on a 2+.

What if I have killing blow and a do 1 wound and 1 killing blow wound in the same round of combat? Which wound is the first wound?

They both happen at the same time, so your only choice is to randomise OR believe they fall under page 10, sequencing, in which case it is owning players choice.

The wounds do not matter charmed shield discounts HITS not WOUNDS

Johnny-Crass wrote:The wounds do not matter charmed shield discounts HITS not WOUNDS

I think the issue here is they rolled hits THEN wounds before letting the opposing player use their Charmed Shield effect. In which case, randomizing between ALL hits (whether they wound or no) for the Charmed Shield is rule of day.

The question of timing is more applicable to the case of (for example) a successful poison and one generic hit.

Which has the same answer: either you beleive it falls under p10 Sequencing, or you roll off. There is no other option

Right, I agree. Just trying to point out a circumstance where the question (and your answer) are more applicable.

If you have a charmed shield, tell your opponent before attack dice are rolled. The dice can then be rolled one at a time until a hit is scored.

Duke_Corwin wrote:If you have a charmed shield, tell your opponent before attack dice are rolled. The dice can then be rolled one at a time until a hit is scored.

But that is not how it works at all. All attacks are made simultaneously in the case of one model attacking him

Duke_Corwin wrote:If you have a charmed shield, tell your opponent before attack dice are rolled. The dice can then be rolled one at a time until a hit is scored.

Except you dont roll attacks like that. ALL attacks at the same Init happen at the same game-time, regardless of how you roll them

One hit is picked randomly then?

....or you decide page 10 applies, which i dont think it does, in which case the player whose turn it is chooses

Given these as options 3 times now, as there is no specific rule i can find.

nosferatu1001 wrote:....or you decide page 10 applies, which i dont think it does, in which case the player whose turn it is chooses

Given these as options 3 times now, as there is no specific rule i can find.

I think Page 10 is the answer. Only because I cannot find a reference in 8th that does tell you to randomize for any type of situation like this.

-Matt

nosferatu1001 wrote:Which has the same answer: either you beleive it falls under p10 Sequencing, or you roll off. There is no other option

Tottal agreed!

The 2+ save should have occured immediately after the to-hit rolls were made and due to the fact that they occured at the same initiative it should randomize between the attacks unless they were all the same then it doesn't really matter.