Thanks for your great range of replies everybody - nice to know people can at least sometimes, have a discussion without it turning into a fan war eh?
If you have any comments you think are especially worthy I'd really encourage you to
put them on the original article as well.
Anyway - as you gathered from the original post, my suggestion is a subscription to an HTML based solution that covers all of the things we get out of codexes, as well as all the benefits of things like army builder and White Dwarf, without any of the drawbacks.
I'll be publishing more proposals on my own blog
tetsugaku.info and on my professional portfolio
The Tall Designer as I come up with them. Ultimately I'm going to have a detailed case study of how to build an open, accessible, usable system, based on web standards that serves the needs of gamers whilst making
GW the profit that they deserve for creating the games and rules.
Who knows, it might even happen.
Cheers!