I will start with thanking everyone who has posted interesting off-topic stuff other than tabletop gaming.
I had been sucked in many times and now it is my turn.
Plain and simple: did you REALLY like Diablo 2 and how the tone and character of it was?
Path of Exile is the game for you.
It is free. Yes, I know, sounds strange, not crippleware? Need microtransactions so it works fully? No, none of that.
It is in Beta but like Minecraft, it works like a full game.
Most of the things I liked about Torchlight 2, Diablo2 and 3 is pretty much there.
It does work on a remote server like Diablo3 but any server "issues" had no effect on me unlike D3.
Main differences in a nutshell:
It is a very DARK game not so good for the under 10 crowd.
I have not been frustrated with any element of the game other than when areas get REALLY hard which is a good thing...
I have played computer games since home computers/game systems became available and never stopped since.
I have my kids to keep me "stuck in" even if I get all crusty and say "they don't make em like they used to".
This is the first time I felt really good about a game: made by gamers, for gamers and they have a GOOD plan on how to make money: You only pay for beauty items to jazz up your spells/abilities or armor.
Grinding Gear Games is who made it.
The download is huge: ~4gig but it shows in the result.
Anyway, try it, let me know ESPECIALLY if you do not like it, I would like to know what type of person would not like the isometric scrolling hack and slash games.
Just trying to give back, if you get addicted I will not accept responsibility.