The simplest option I would suggest is to get hold of some Oyumaru. It's also sold as instant mold (for a bit more money).
It's a re-usable silicone-based moulding material. Drop it in hot water for 3mins and then press around the object either in 2 steps or in one and then cut in half, to make a two-part mould.
Remove the original and then press in some
GS or similar putty.
Repeat.
The copies won't be plastic, may be slightly heavier, but you won't get an easier method.
and then you can keep the Oyumaru to replicate anything else in the future.
Although it is the "gateway drug" of the casting world and will soon lead to you making your own models and casting with "proper" silicone and resin.