Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

Lord-Loss wrote:Paul, lets hear those theories.

They are all just hypothesii really(Is that the correct way of saying it? ).

These are the most important thoughts of mine at this point.

Symph has more or less made up his mind about mine, halos, and IG's guilt. I am not entirely sure about him, maybe he is just rabid townie overconfident in his deductive abilities, Jumping on an obvious culprit. One argument supporting this theory is, obviously, that he has more or less no backup. If he was a baddie, maybe he'd have a couple of people agreeing with him? Now there is always the possibility they are bidding their time for a late day bandwagon, of course.

Alternatively, He could be a cultist, trying to hide behind the larger target of Halo. I think the chief argument for this theory is this sudden swing in behaviour, which could mean he is possessed (Yes I know Symph, that you have explained this to be your 'serious face').

Alternatively alternatively, He could be absolutely right. Halo could be a cultist. IG could be one. I'd be an idiot if I claimed I couldn't be. But there are several possibilities here.I could be a cultist trying to throw halo and IG in a bad light by 'accidentaly' slipping up. Or Halo could be guilty and I just an idiot.

I'll throw in a random thought here: EDIT: this random thought of mine proved to be certainly wrong. Sorry for any inconvenience.

Then there's Halo's trap about the flaw in symphonius logic. Symph dismissed it, I don't know if you have, but I sure haven't. And besides, their exchanges up to this point can be broken down into Halo attempting to use logic and Symph calling him cultist.

I am leaning towards symph at this point, but I am unsure. Bandwagoning on GND was obviously a mistake. I wonder if choose the wrong side in that matter. What would have happened if IG had been lynched? Or Halo? Most of all, I am baffled, and to some extent insulted, that noone wanted to lynch me. The attentionwhore in me wonders what separeted me from GND. I didn't contribute more, that's one thing for sure.

That's just of the top of my head. Sorry if I bored you with reading this, LL.

Mistake post. For a minute there I thought my rant had disappeared.

We ALL know that Karon had a role, be it heretical or puritan.

Someone understands the serious face!

If no one votes for halonachos, then i'll lynch ya. ;p

My logic is flawed, let me run this off to you guys one last time, nice and simple:

IGLannister was going radically off-topic.

I claimed that people BrotherStynier was voting for were citizens. (Big AFAIK after it, one of my most uncertain statements)

BrotherStynier voted for IGLannister, which came up to me after I posted the above.

BrotherStynier knew that while he would tip the balance to kill IGLannister, he had more than enough time to take the vote back, and vote for someone else, saving IGLannister.

BrotherStynier was night killed.

New theory time on IGLannister, he might have nightkilled BrotherStynier, IGL was certainly opposed to BrotherStynier at this point, no one else was aside from Lord-Loss (Or bishop gore?)

This seems to fit in exactly with my theory of IGLannister being a cultist, while BrotherStynier WAS a daemon.

More evidence on the big ol' pile.

He did? How embarrasing, I missed that. My bad.

Mr. Symphonius, I find your overuse of the taunting orkmoticon distasteful and suspicous, Almost as if you were mocking me for something we don't know.

But Thanks for filling in with your side of that argument, I guess that makes That point a tie between you and nachoes?

Oky, went back and doublechecked.

Yes, Karon had a role and it was redistributed, so we can be sure that all the cultists are still there, and that makes that little side note of mine on Halo completely redundant. Thanks for pointing that out symphonius.

Alright I'm back. Minor Internet issues. Sorry for the delay.

I suspect Paul, because he has powers to see the future and he is using them to attack only one person. Or else the future is clouded by the Spacers Guild...

I actually suspect Lord-Loss and Halo. But now Halo is voting for me, so I guess I must be wrong about that. A cultist would never vote for me. Or would they?

Good luck with that pressure vote Halo.

I can't help that, it's an addiction, I'm a victim!

So confused... *Shakes head*

BishopGore wrote:I suspect Paul, because he has powers to see the future and he is using them to attack only one person. Or else the future is clouded by the Spacers Guild...

I actually suspect Lord-Loss and Halo. But now Halo is voting for me, so I guess I must be wrong about that. A cultist would never vote for me. Or would they?

Good luck with that pressure vote Halo.

It's not a pressure vote, I swear. I'm not trying to put any pressure on you or anything you know. You are lowest on my list of possible evil people and highest on my possible role townie list. I just want you to talk more like you did during day phase one.

That night kill for stynier is suspicious though. However, there are a couple of ways that could've worked out.

If you want me to talk more then it is a pressure vote. However I'm posting and that somehow means it worked. The peer pressure got to me.

We're so far in and I'm very confused. There's a lot of people that don't fit right, but the sheer number of bad guys in the town has me reeling a bit, a third of the people out there are evil, that's a massive amount of them. They don't need to work together as a group, they can work in cells and have conflicts between them because they have the numbers to sway votes very quickly in their favour.

This has all already been said, so this is a bit of a none post.

In other news: I am a cat. Meow.

See this Paul? This is MY Gom Jabar...

In related news, I'm lost too. I really don't know who to suspect at this point. I still have a mild suspicion of Scott, and maybe Symph. But in all honesty, I'm unsure of what to do.

Also, I'm a cat too. An orange cat. With white feet.

Might be due to my not being on for a few days, or it may be the PTSD resulting from all the grilling. Either way I'm lost.

Paul Atreides wrote:He did? How embarrasing, I missed that. My bad.

Mr. Symphonius, I find your overuse of the taunting orkmoticon distasteful and suspicous, Almost as if you were mocking me for something we don't know.

But Thanks for filling in with your side of that argument, I guess that makes That point a tie between you and nachoes?

What, I am an orkmoticon spam master!

Seriously guys, how the hell are you getting Symph? (Oh! He struck again!)

Silence, daemon!

1234 posts. Sweet.

How many people are there thats supposed to be playing/talking etc?

More then there is talking. It ticks me off, people should talk more even if they've got nothing to say.

Say, are people allowed to communicate with each other via PMs about the game or are we strictly limited to this thread?

No, I believe we're limited to this thread, it sucks, doesn't it?

Anyway, do you want us to talk even if we have nothing to say? Because then wouldn't we just clutter the conversation?

We're on 25 pages and we're barely into Day 2. This conversation is so bloated and gassy it would explode if you lit a match under it.

I was also wondering why everyone kept called you symph. But I didn't really care that much.

Soon they'll be calling me Bimshop. Lormd-Loss. Hamlonachos.

Does this count as off topic? Maybe I should put something in that's on topic.

VikingScott has remained talkative and sensible, whilst I thought he would be another Shas'O. Glad he's not.

Wasn't Arheiner supposed to be playing this too?

And BishopGore I've noticed your playstyle has differed from the other two games that i read with you in. Is that down to the amount of players or something else?

Arheiner hasn't talked much in the first day either, hope he doesn't have a role...

BishopGore probably thinks we're all ruining the game, on account of the all the posts, that have little meaning.

Not_U
Can you put up a list of all the players please so we know who is posting and who isn't

^^ Perhaps a list with names of players that haven't posted in two days in red? ^^

That I think we can agree on.

Nope, now we have to make it dark blue. Can't be agreeing with halonachos can I?

Actually I prefer mauve. But that's me.

Inquisitor_Syphonious wrote:Nope, now we have to make it dark blue. Can't be agreeing with halonachos can I?

I'm sure paul has my back on this one.

I'm not sure about Bimshopgore, he seems to be posting more but not scum hunting.


Discussion has grinded to a halt..