doctortom wrote:
Octopoid wrote:
JohnnyHell wrote:
BaconCatBug wrote:
JohnnyHell wrote:Please. Are you seriously arguing the
RAW means ‘once ever in your life’? We have a new low if so...
The same way people argue whether
RaW you subtract 1 from your hit rolls when you move and shoot heavy weapons.
Just because you don't like what the rule says doesn't change what it says.
IMHO you are very rude to accuse people who want to play by the rules as "low".
To pull the thread... so who tracks this “once ever in your life”? It’s ludicrous to pretend it makes any sense to use that interpretation, but you do you. And there’s no argument over the Heavy Weapon thing so whatever.
“No, you used the Stratagem a week last Tuesday, that’s it for the rest of your life!”
(Also I didn’t say what you said, nice bonus strawman there)
The problem is, it's not an "interpretation." It's what the rule says. Is it what
GW intended? Probably not, because of the aforementioned ludicrousness, but is IS what they SAID. Would I hold someone to that? No. IS it what the rule says? Yes. There's no interpretation to be done here.
If I were playing one of
GW's rules writers and I knew they had used the stratagem before, I'd probably hold them to it just to see their reaction and to see how fast it takes for them to
FAQ it.
Aww c'mon we all know the rule authors don't actually
play the game -- that's how we end up with one time use strategems in the first place!