Forum adverts like this one are shown to any user who is not logged in. Join us by filling out a tiny 3 field form and you will get your own, free, dakka user account which gives a good range of benefits to you: No adverts like this in the forums anymore. Times and dates in your local timezone. Full tracking of what you have read so you can skip to your first unread post, easily see what has changed since you last logged in, and easily see what is new at a glance. Email notifications for threads you want to watch closely. Being a part of the oldest wargaming community on the net. If you are already a member then feel free to login now.

I've been looking at lore videos, novel excerpts, reading the lexicanum, and I'm trying to see if I really understand Perty as best as I can. Because people like to meme him, but I see the character very differently. As inevitable tragedy that is shaped by equally his nature as well as his nurture.

Perty was born with a mind that saw only cracks, flaws, and inevitabilities. By nature, he was inclined toward distrust, perfectionism, and a gnawing need for recognition. By nurture, these tendencies were sharpened into bitterness until they became a cage around his soul.

On Olympia, Dammekos adopted Perty not out of love but out of utility. Perty's genius was a weapon, a tool with which Dammekos could conquer rival city-states and secure his rule. To Perty, this became the first lesson of life: he was not valued for who he was, but for what he could do. Affection was conditional, contingent on conquest.

When the Big E arrived, nothing changed. Perty was given his Legion, yes, but not the glory campaigns of compliance. He was burdened with sieges, garrisons, attritional slogs. The thankless work of grinding down enemies that others would later sweep in to claim. Big E did not praise him. Instead, he lauded Dorn, who was celebrated for fortifying walls while Perturabo was condemned to break them. Two sides of the same craft, but only one was ever honored. From this, Perty learned a cruel reinforcement of his foster father’s lesson: worth was transactional, recognition was political, and the true value of his labor was forever denied.

Perty spent decades breaking himself and his Legion on the hardest sieges in the galaxy. Attrition wars against the Hrud, fortress-worlds nobody else could crack, campaigns that left his sons half-dead in trenches so that someone else could raise the victory banner afterward. His reward? Silence.

Meanwhile, Dorn built walls. On Terra, he laid foundations for defenses that hadn’t even been tested yet, and the Big E showered him with praise. The “Praetorian of Terra,” the golden son of fortresses, celebrated for building what might stand.

So imagine you’re Peter Turbo: you bleed your sons dry to tear down the walls of enemies, and you’re told your work is meaningless. Then you watch your brother praised for raising walls on friendly soil. The same skill, inverted. But one is lauded, the other ignored.

That is the wound that never closed. To Perty, it proved the lesson he had learned under Dammekos: your worth is not in what you achieve, but in who receives the credit.

And yet, within this bleak pattern, there was one voice of difference. Calliphone, his foster sister, gave him genuine affection. She saw not a tool, nor a weapon, but a brother. She reminded him that perfection was not the only path to greatness, that love and leadership were not contradictions, and that he was not as unloved as he believed. But by the time of Olympia, her words struck only hardened stone. To Perty, her love looked like pity, her criticism like betrayal, and her persistence like torment.

Rather than risk believing in the possibility of unconditional care, he destroyed her. In strangling Calliphone, he did more than kill the one person who loved him, he sealed himself into the fortress he had built around his own heart. In that moment, he proved himself right in the only way he knew how: by ensuring that love could never touch him again.

We have negativity after negativity built brick by brick by Dammekos, Big E, everything that Perty experienced. So by the time Calliphone shows him genuine love, Perty is like "the hell is this???"

This is the tragedy of Peter Turbo. He was a man who most desired what he believed impossible; who mistook love for weakness and truth for scorn; who built walls so strong that even light could not enter. He was never truly unloved. His sister loved him still. But he could never let himself believe it.

"But he wiped out 1/10 of his legion!" Perty always feared he wasn’t respected, that he was seen as lesser. By enforcing brutal discipline, he thought he could prove himself strong. To him, weakness only confirmed what he already believed, that his Legion would fail him if not forced into compliance. Just as Dammekos used him as a tool, and the Big E undervalued him, Perty learned to value only utility, not loyalty or affection. His Legion became tools to be reforged by fear.

All the pieces come together in a truly tragic character. A product of inevitability and tragedy. He never really had the tools to accept love or recognition, even when it was given.

All Perty ever wanted to do was be an architect and build things... :(

Peter Turbo is probably my favoritte Primarch. I always end up finding the fallen Primarchs much more... relatable than the loyalists.

-STS

I think you summed it up very thoroughly.

I find Perty to be one of the more relatable traitor primarchs. Yeah everyone has a moment of rage, or vanity, etc, but those are fleeting emotions. The feeling of grinding day after day without recognition is more true to life. We've all been passed over at some point, seen our accomplishments not recognized, seen the boss's nephew or friend get the promotion, etc.

Perty's alienation from others is the alienation and feeling of being exploited a lot of people in the developed world feel. It's just on an industrial grimdark level because he's a demi-god with a legion of marines to throw around.

He was also excellent at creating things, as he showed one his Brother Primarchs in one of the earlier novels.

I forget which book and which Primarch specifically. But it shows he was able to build perfect, beautiful things of all scales.

And so he had the skills for both sides of siege craft. But was seemingly condemned only to the destructive, soul sapping side. A whole side of creative expression denied to him, but not to other Primarchs.

Also not just those raising the victory flags on fortresses his sons had brought low? But also the “glory” of being first through the breach etc. Repeatedly. And it’s not that his was the Only Legion capable of wrecking even the stoutest of defences - he was just seen as the swiftest way to do that.

He could’ve been used to instruct others in what came so naturally to him. Sure they might never ever master it quite as he had - but he still clearly had insight and a feel for it his Brothers could at least learn from, instead of simply making him do it.

Of course, personal perspective is a big part of it. So he may be somewhat unreliable as a narrator, blinded to anything except the slights against him be they real or perceived. He’s still a very sympathetic character for it. If the Iron Warriors and Imperial Fists had say, simply taken it in turns, and shared the laurels evenly, who knows? Maybe he wouldn’t have been swayed to join Horus’ treachery.

 Mad Doc Grotsnik wrote:
He was also excellent at creating things, as he showed one his Brother Primarchs in one of the earlier novels.

I forget which book and which Primarch specifically. But it shows he was able to build perfect, beautiful things of all scales.

I'm pretty sure we see that in Angel Exterminatus, with Fulgrim if that's what you're thinking of? He builds a tiny model warhound titan amongst other things iirc, plus lots of architectural plans for beautiful buildings rather than siege-related fortifications, etc and he builds one of them for Fulgrim too. There's possibly also something similar in the Perturabo primarch novel, that I can't remember?